Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Posts

Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#1

Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Barry Irby

>I have some 16/4 walnut I cut about two years ago and it has been in my Greenhouse/kiln/storage area ever since. I took out a piece and cut four 4 X 4 blanks for table legs and turned them. They have a square top 3 3/4" square and parts of the turnings are 3 1/2" in diamter.

With a moisture meter (mini-lignomat) I took readings. It flickered between 8 and 10 percent and settled on 10 on end grain and 8 on side grain. These were "internal" readings taken on surfaces I exposed when I cut the beam open and the inner end. Actually, the outer surfaces seemed to be very similar.A friend gave me the meter. I ahve never actually used it before. I wonder if I should take readings on some othe wood that has been indoors for a long time as a comparison?

Is this good? What Now?

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#2

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Barry,

Depending on where you live, 8 to 10 percent is about as good as you will do for air drying. Around here, I can go buy wood at 6 to 8 percent, leave it in my garage for a few months and it will be at 10 to 12 percent when I use it.

I feel like the important thing is to keep the wood at a consistent moisture level. I tend to keep everything in the unconditioned garage until I take it inside. I always build with wood movement in mind (sometimes to the point of being quite anal about it). I have never had a piece come apart on me, so I must be doing something right.

I think you will be ok.

Rob Hix

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#3

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Al Stokka - Cambrige, Iowa

>Barry,

I'm confused by your question (not that that is unusual, I'm often confused). Seems to me that you've committed to using the walnut, since you've already turned the legs. You should have asked the question before making the cuts.

I don't recall where you live, but I think you'll be OK at 10%. On the other hand, what alternative is there?

Al

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

>If your walnut has been air drying for only 2 years, it is probably not dry all the way through. Even moisture meters with long pins and whammer handles will only read to the center of a piece of 8/4 accurately. The readings you get at the surface with a hand-held pin meter may be several percent drier than the inside. As I recall, endgrain readings are not accurate because of the difference in conductivity across vs along the grain. If you want to be more accurate about it, take a small cutoff from the wood and bandsaw it into three long-grain slabs, then take side-grain readings in the middle of the interior pieces to get a better reading. And don't forget to factor in whatever species correction your meter advises for walnut.

In the case of table legs, the largest cross-grain dimension will be less than four inches, so shrinkage will probably not be a factor. In fact, assuming you will be mortising rails into the sides of the legs, the final shrinkage of the legs will only tighten the mortise and tenon joint. This is well-established practice in Windsor chair joinery and other m&t applications.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#5

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Dale Stansbery

>Dittos to what Rob said. There may a Species correction chart that goes with your meter as well. I have a Wagner pinless meter and when it reads 10% on walnut, it's actually 9%, which is what a table here beside me is reading right now coming out of a long winter heating season.

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#6

Thanks, and more information.

Barry Irby

>I started with a timber that was 4" thick and 9" wide. I cut about three inches off the end to get rid of some end checks and cut anm piece aobut 61" long and ripped it into two 4x4 blanks. Then cut those dwon to four 29" long blanks. The readings were on the inner surface cut out of the middle of the 4 x 9.

Somebody gave me the meter. I don't have a correction chart. Its a Mini Lignomat. Does anyone have the correction for walnut?

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#7

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

Barry Irby

>Al, I live in VA. Humid Southside VA. The table is going further south.

You are right, it would have made more sense to check the moisture content first. OTOH, what I'm trying to do is figure out where I stand now that I have done the bull in the china shop routine and cut into the wood. I was thinking that I might want to let the legs acclimate and turn them a second time sort of like twice turned bowls, or maybe put finish on them quickly. I actually put them in plastic bags that are not perfectly sealed hoping to retard any further moisture exchange and let them acclimate slowly. Don't know what good any of that will do. I suppose I would rather fail slowly than all of a sudden.

Re: Walnut/Moisture Content Question?

#8

Barry, I have the mini-ligno,

Keith Newton

>and I have a pinless Wagner. The pinless needs to use a correction for each species, but the pin type are not so sensitive.

I think your idea of checking the MC for another walnut finished piece in your, or someone else's home is an excellent idea. That will give you the reading for your meter to expect for EMC.