Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Posts

OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#1

OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Brint in Atlanta (soon to be Richmond)

>Two weeks from now we're moving from Atlanta to Richmond. We found a house there that met most of our needs (read, "except a shop for me"). Thankfully, LOML recognizes the sacrifice I made and has said that "the first thing we'll do after getting moved in is build a garage/shop" (and there's no hidden automotive agenda here: I currently use a little more than half of our current 2-car garage, and the kids' bikes, etc. take up the rest).

However, after watching me spend the better part of three years building an 8x12 shed in our backyard, she is not inclined to let me do it myself. Can't say as I blame her -- plus, I want it sooner than that. ;-) But I have never contracted anyone to do something like this (in fact, I've never hired a general contractor, period).

Of course, since I get to design it, I want all the works: wired for 220V, outlets everywhere, lots of light, plumbed for a deep sink, etc. Perhaps the most difficult request, however, is to ask the contractor if he'd let me work with the framing and drywall crews (I'll be without a job for the time being) and give me a discount on the price.

Any and all advice is much appreciated. Perhaps Taunton or someone has a good book on this subject?

TIA -- Brint

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#2

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Joseph

>Brint, I am suggesting that you look into the corrugated steel buildings that you and another man can assemble inside of a week, and you can insulate it later. Cost would be about 6K I think for a good sized building.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#3

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

David Yoho

>Not knowing where you'll be located exactly, some subdivisions here have covenants that dictate the exterior look of buildings erected on the property. If you're not in that situation, then that make things easier. A friend and fellow woodworker recently built a wonderful and large garage just for his shop. He's got all the bells and whistles and I'm almost sure he did some of it himself. I'd be glad to check with him and get a name for you if you'd like.

I know there are builders who will allow you to do some of the work and price the job accordingly - I just don't know who they are. Maybe Barry Irby will be able to help you there once he sees this.

David

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#4

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Mike Johnson

>I built a shop adjacent to my house in Greensboro, GA last summer and did most of the work myself with some invaluable help from my brother-in-law and one neighbor. If you want to come visit to get ideas about one way to approach the project, just let me know.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#5

Don't do it!

Mike in Paradise

>Really don't!

It will become a time-sucking,

money draining,

addiction that is worse than crack!

The more space you have the more tools you will need!

You will be into your wife purse to steal change to buy sandpaper!

You will get lots of enabling behavior here on this site

as the addicts cannot help but support one of their own!

I can give up my shop any time I want so it is not really an addiction in my case!

Truly I can!

Really don't do it! :)

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#6

Hey! How did I get into this?

Barry Irby

>Actually, as a Home Inspector who does expert witness testimony on construction defects, all I hear about are the screw ups. Nobody ever comes to me and says "You should use this guy, he's great." Sort of sad. Also, the professional group I'm in frowns on us giving recommendations for repair people because it LOOKS like and could be a conflict of Interest. And, having been a builder, if I wanted a garage built, I would do it myself. (Might take about three years, but I would still do it.)

You do need to check on your neighborhood covenants and restrictions. And Zoning. Some will have rules about the appearance and they may have even gotten to the point they are dictating what percentage of the lot you can cover. You may be in the Cheasapeak Bay Protection area and they are very sensitive about run off. I'll send you an e-mail.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#7

PS, I tried to send you an E-mail

Barry Irby

>But it was rejected. We are both on Comcast. Do I need to modify the one you have posted?

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#8

Be careful,

John E. in SC

>Most contractors will probably charge you MORE if you want to "help" - you would mostly be in their way, because if they have any experience, they have developed a way of working together, etc. Having the homeowner around usually slows them down. At the very least, they have to stop and tell you what to do. You might be able to save some money by offering to do things that won't interfere with them, like the clean up, painting, or other jobs where you can do the whole thing yourself. I self-contracted my house awhile back, and that's mostly what I did. I did frame out the roof over a bay window, but I did this on weekends and evenings when the framers weren't even there. Also did the tiling, etc. but whatever "jobs" I took on, I did the whole thing, and didn't try to "help" any of the subs. Having said all that, you might be able to find a contractor to "consult" for you for a set fee, and you can self-contract the construction. The contractor can help you with subs, etc. and you can do whatever you don't want to sub out.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#9

JL

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

JL

>If I were building one from scratch, I would definitely consider a prefab building if they are allowed in your part of Richmond. I used to live in the northern part of Richmond and they were a little picky about what was allowed. Are you going to be in Richmond or in one of the surrounding counties?

Figure on $30K or so if you are going to do a stick built.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#10

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Joseph Mulherin Indio, CA

>Brint, I did a search on steel buildings online: here are three you can look at and price: www.futuresteel.com; www.americansteelspan.com; www.alliedbuildings.com

Do not know what the prices are but there are some beautiful buildings available for you.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#11

I'll second that...........

Nat Robison

>I agree that helping a regular crew might become a hindrance to them, especially if they have to instruct or remind you of things they all know.

I'm currently finishing my basement and putting in a full bathroom with the help of my neighbor, a master plumber. He's doing it on the side and arranged from the start that I would be helping him. My "help" so far has amounted to handing him fittings and holding up an occasional pipe while he glues it. He's not excluding me, he's just working in the manner to which he's accustomed, which doesn't generally involve instruction. He doesn't mind answering questions but he's not going to take 10 minutes to show me how to do something that will take him 3 minutes.

I agree that you should arrange to do certain tasks like cleaning, wiring (if you're up to it), etc. and do the whole task. Don't try and help an experienced crew. They'll likely resent it after a bit.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#12

Re: Hey! How did I get into this?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...as a Home Inspector.... if I wanted a garage built, I would do it myself..."

Barry, that really says alot doesn't it? Sad. I know there have to be guys out there that do a good job building, but I've never seen them. :(

If you want it done quickly, you gotta hire it out, but if you want it done right, you gotta do it yourself.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#13

Remove the Asian country

David Yoho

>

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#14

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

paul in AZ

>I went through a similar process two years ago. Two things that entered my decision process were 1) zoning [contrary to my first impulse I pulled permits and did everything by the book]; and 2) the impact of an addition on appearance and future resale of the house. The first for insurance purposes and also disclosure legalities on future sale. I have no intention of moving but know that some day it may [will?] happen and a more attractive addition will enhance rather than detract from value.

I looked at steel prefab structures. Initially attractive on price, I decided that however functional it could look cheezy to buyers. If you are in a rural area an outbuilding is just that but in urban settings curb impressions matter to me, my neighbors and to buyers.

In the end I went with an attached shop around 2 car garage size that has all the goodies you mention. The exterior is finished so it matches the existing house and looks like it was there from day one.

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#15

Contractors' rule

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If you watch, the price goes up 10%.

If you watch and talk, the price goes up 20%.

If you "help", the price goes up 50%.

Clint

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#16

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop *LINK*

Mark Nowicki

>This guy deals with potential clients like you everyday. He is in Norfolk VA.

Mark Nowicki


Shell additions

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#17

Thanks, Clint

Brint in Atlanta (soon to be Richmond)

>'nuff said.

(and, unfortunately, has a real ring of truth to it...)

;-)

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#18

Here's what you do . . .

CJ McLaughlin

>Get the handyman that lives across the street to help you. Pay him a reasonable amount to do the lion's share of the work as, after all, you likely have a day job. Besides, you and I both know that you lowered your last house's value with that shack out back.

Get the place framed and hire another friend to spray paint all over the neighborhood; at least some of it lands on the garage. Hire a local drywall crew that may or may not have enough green cards to go around (you really shouldn't ask) and then get the spray paint guy to come back and do the inside. Don't look at the uneven, mud and paint covered floor too closely. (The guy who did it lives across the street, played professional football and is a great guy, even if his standards are a bit lower than what you were after.)

Move your woodworking equipment in slowly, by yourself, and then wonder about how to repair the mess in your back yard.

Finally, make sure you set up the automatic transfer with your bank to pay down the home equity line of credit so you don't have to write the check yourself. This makes it easier to pretend that you don't owe anything on the dream shop.

Sorry, finally, fix the door knob that suddenly decides it doesn't like keys.

It's easy. Go for it!

CJ

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#19

Re: Hey! How did I get into this?

Joseph Mulherin Indio, CA

>Brint, Barry gave you some very good advice. I know, because I was a building inspector myself a couple yrs ago, and was in const. for over 35yrs before retirement. I went to the websites I gave you this morning, and decided that you would be best served by going to the AlliedBuilders website and talk to them. They have many outlets, and one would be close to you. Good luck, Joe

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#20

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Paul Mayer

>I am in the process of doing the same thing. I hired a contractor who bid out the job for a flat fee, including framing, roofing, sizing, foundation and slab. In turn I requested that he hire me to do some basic jobs that would not get in his way, and would not require much guidence. I ended up doing things like tarring and insulating the foundation, stapling the plywood to the studs, rerouting some vents, etc. I was actually able to frame it with his assistant while the contractor was out of town. He hired me for the same wage that he pays unskilled laborers, which is not much, but fair for the work. I knew that it would not save me much money, but I got to be involved every step of the way, which was awesome. I learned a lot in the process, and would do it that way again for sure. The portions of the project that I knew I could do on my own, I did not hire him for. Such as electrical, installing flooring on the second floor, insulation, plumbing, sheetrock, taping, paint, radiant heat installation, etc. Doing all of those on my own will save me about $10k, so that is where there is real cost savings. Doing all those things is definitely slowing things down, however. It will take me about a year, from start to completion. But I will feel like I saved some money, and earned the privelage a little bit more this way. I would be happy to compare notes on design ideas if you would like.

Cheers,

Paul

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

#21

Re: OT? - Need Advice on Building a Garage/Shop

Joseph Mulherin Indio, CA

>Paul, the cost of the new metal building and the speed with which it can be assembled, the exterior appearance can be matched to your original house so they both look like they are one unit. If the building is away from the house, it still can have an exterior like the house, whethere it is stucco, vinyl, aluminum, clapboards or whatever. I know, because I was in const for 35yrs and know housing from the git-go, as well as heavy industrial const.

Brint should look into the AlliedBuilding.com website and choose his manufacturer close to him and work with him as to design. The cost will be the main factor. Regular const. could take almost a yr, maybe less, but the steel building is already designed to go together quickly.