Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

Posts

I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#1

I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>too political. This is not the place for discussions of corporate structure, the rights and/or wrongs of outsourcing jobs, and other matters which can and do lead to angry disputations.

Electronics, humor, even help on new positions - ok.

But Please!!, no politics or anything like it.

Robert R. Clough

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#2

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Robert,

Long ago we all kind of decided that these discussions are OK unless it becomes too vitriolic.

Mark

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#3

That in itself is conroversial.

Ted Wong

>And who will be the person to determine what is too political or unrelated to woodworking?

If for instance a government in bolivia decides to cut down all their rain forests and it drops the price of many tropical species in the U.S. is that too political to debate Or if the Department of the Interior decides it wants to auction off several remaining stands of old growth Redwood in the Pacific Northwest is that unrelated to woodworkers?

OT: means exactly that. If the title seems like it won't interest the reader they don't have to go there. On the otherhand if Woodcentral is running low on server space and all these OT: topics are taking up valuable harddrive space then in my opinion it'd be a valid reason to move such discussions off the boards.

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#4

agreed

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#5

OT- "disputations" is not a word

gypsydave

>

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#6

Re: OT- "disputations" is not a word *LINK*

Merriam-Webster

>We respectfully disagree.


http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/disputations

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#7

I was only being disputatious

gypsydave

>

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#8

I'll disagree.

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Here's why. I believe this is an excellent place for all types of discourse. While we all may have the common thread woodworking bringing us together, we are about as diverse a group as an online forum could enjoy. I've also noticed that those who frequent this forum are, in general, either highly educated or haved gained much wisdom and life experience outside of academics. Provided the tone stays civil, the occasional exchange of non-woodworking ideas here has been entertaining at times, but always gets me thinking about and re-thinking my positions on various subjects. Sterilizing this place to solely woodworking and technical OT posts would only serve to detract from the community Ellis has founded. The very fact that we have the common thread of woodworking serves to keep many of us in check when expressing our opinions. Many of us have met and forged friendships that help us refrain from incendiary comments that we might otherwise make on a more anonymous forum. And, should the discussion start to get too personal and heated, many of the good folks here are more than willing to step in and suggest that a cooler tone prevail, often before the moderators get a chance. If we can't discuss topics in a civil manner here, do "we the people" stand a chance?

Jason

P.S. If I'm out of line, Ellis, it's your sandbox...

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#9

Re: I'll disagree.

Rick Snyder

>I disagree with your comments that this forum can be an all-subject type forum. The very title of this website indicates that to me. The main body of this forum should be woodworking and the "all other" areas should be over to the left side of this page. I visit this site everyday for woodworking dialogue. All the other non-wood working information I can easily find elsewere.

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#10

Re: I'll disagree.

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I agree totally. I find the diverse opinions on OT subjects informative and mostly entertaining. I honestly feel if OT subjects were forbidden WoodCentral would lose one of the reasons it has become one of the premier woodworking sites on the net. For those who do not like OT subjects just don't click on them to open. I come here for advice on OT subjects because I think the wisdom and experience here is trustworthy. I will offer my knowledge and experiences when I feel they are helpful and when I don't contribute to the subject I very often learn something new. When I enter this site I feel I am with friends. Good friends are hard to find.

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#11

What.....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>are we back on Golden Pond, where PC was the priority rule?

Clint

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#12

I choose not to click on OT topics, you can too!

Stephen in Utah

>

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#13

Clarification

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I'm not saying this forum should be a political/religious free-for-all, but with the generally civil, intelligent people here, if a thread takes on a controversial tone, it is not usually a detriment to WoodCentral. Sure, we can get that debate anywhere, but I value it much more from the people here, as I've met many of them and would trust them in many ways. I've been on other sites where these types of debates quickly turn into nothing but name-calling and vitriol. That is much less likely to happen here.

Jason

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#14

A little more...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Just take a look at the number of responses to the "Exodus" thread below--it seems like people WANT to talk about this stuff with their fellow woodworking friends.

Jason

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#15

Re: But remember Clint...

Dave Anderson, SoCal - From Home

>...we were told that Golden Pond was an "experiment in Social Engineering" -- doomed to fail much like Russian communism. Once the populace realized they could not only grow the potatoes but eat them also it was only a matter of time...

Dave - former Pond member who enjoys his Island Freedoms!

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#16

Ellis Walentine

Here's the deal on political topics...

Ellis Walentine

>I have been watching the Exodus thread carefully, as it is pushing very hard against our policy of no politics. I appreciate everyone's civility and the thoughtful points you've been making, but I think that socio-economic, political, and religious discussions are always at risk of becoming polarized and nasty -- not to mention that they are off-topic and against our longstanding policy. I have been slow to respond to these posts the past couple days simply because you guys *are* being very civil, and that's important, but I don't want to tempt the inevitable burr under someone's saddle that turns this into a namecalling exercise.

OT posts are fine, but let's keep the big four (see FAQs) out of the arena. I appreciate your cooperation.

Ellis

Re: I Think Our OT Messages are Getting

#17

Well said!

David sparks

>