Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

career change

Posts

career change

#1

career change

Brian Boersma

>I'm a 44 YO married father of four from Minnesota who has been working as a mental health professional for the last 13 years and am contemplating a career change. To do so would be difficult given the fact that we currently live paycheck-to-paycheck and for me to quit my job and go to school full-time in woodworking would stretch the family, both financially and emotionally. Because of this, I would like to choose the best program to prepare me for a career in woodworking. I've looked into several schools on line and in fact went to the American Woodworking Academy in St. Louis last fall to take a Fundamentals of Woodworking class for a weekend. I'm basically a novice with a passion for doing hands-on work and I love to work hard. I've looked up the New England School of Architectural

Woodworking and it looks like a good program though I'd be out East for almost nine and that's a long way from Minnesota.

What are your thoughts about the best program to equip a novice like me for a career in woodworking, a career I hope would end with me owning my own small business within the next 10 years? I've contemplated taking a correspondence course through Penn Foster Career School to get my feet wet with book knowledge, terms, etc. before going to school full-time but this would be another $1,000. I don't have any friends in the woodworking business given my relatively long (total of 17 years) career in mental health and would appreciate any advice on how to proceed.

Thanks,

Brian

Re: career change

#2

Re: career change

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Brian,

Why not look into a small woodworking or cabinet shop locally that needs the help, but would be willing to teach you what you don't know for maybe a lesser wage to start. It would be a way to learn what you need and have an income to boot, plus be home with the wife and kids at the same time.

Just a thought.

Ron in Iowa

Re: career change

#3

Don't quit your day job

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Individual woodworking as a career is probably among the financially riskiest pursuits one can choose, especially at a not-very-young age. The learning curve is steep and long; there's much competition; it's a niche market; the market is subject to the vagaries of fashion and the economy; the capital and operating costs are high; and it's a 24x7 job that you'll never retire from.

Sorry for the cold water, but you're best advised to take it up as a hobby. Then it's fun.

Clint

Re: career change

#4

Re: career change

Jesse in New Mexico

>I hate giving career advice on-line. How would you feel giving mental health advice on-line? But, having said that, here's my thoughts...

You didn't say that you hate your job. If the job is tenable, then consider doing some woodworking as a sideline to make a little extra money. Find a niche. Talk to some folks in the building trades and find what causes them problems. Out here, they want someone to build gates or southwestern benches. I'll bet there's something similar where you are.

Woodworking for $$ is a way different experience from doing it for fun. Think long and hard about trying to turn a fun hobby into something that pays the rent (or not).

Of course, I'm glad no one gave this soap box speech to Sam Maloof or Franz Klaus....

Let us know what you decide. And good luck on whatever path you take!

Re: career change

#5

Re: career change

Ted Wong

>Really fine craft schools like North Bennett or College of the Redwoods are really excellent programs to learn and hone your skills and develop an insight into the meaning of craft. They promote craft in a very esteemed manner which is well deserved. I think graduates often leave the program feeling very powerful and convicted in what they have learned in their experiences and very much want to put into professional practice their talents. But by and large I think the reality is that there are lots and lots of good woodworkers out there and too few people to appreciate what these talented craftpersons produce. And the premium price for a piece of furniture from a graduate from one of these programs is understood by too few buyers.

However, the skill and wealth of knowledge gained pales in comparison to the lessons impact that it has in other aspects of ones life. I think most graduates tend to simply go back to what they had been doing previously only with a fresh perspective that allows them to do whatever they had been doing and to do it better.

Re: career change

#6

Re: Don't quit your day job

Frank G ( Ingleside Texas )

>I agree. From someome that has quit gone back and repeated the same. Look for a nook now that will bring in extra $$$. If you can do that and keep family and job in line then consider a new direction. The great majority that have bailed and thought they could make it did not, me included. One step at a time.

Re: career change

#7

NM: A Thoughtful Message Well Stated

Paul Leuba

>

Re: career change

#8

Check Marc Adams in Indy

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>He has a master's type program that you can do part time over a few years while you build your skill set.

First a little cool water. At this point you probably don't know what your skill ability is, and that you will have to determine early. A lot of folks just have to many thumbs to do proper work that can be sold. More importantly can you design a line that can be sold, can you design to a customers spec and then produce what you design.

Take small bites until you have a realistic feel for where your skills can take you.

Ray

Re: career change

#9

Re: Don't quit your day job

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I agree with both gentlemen. I worked for 45 years as a modelmaker and patternmaker, and the few times I thought I would prefer being my own boss were not some of the happiest days of my life. As stated it becomes a 24/7 operation with more time spent in the operation of the business than in the production. When I finally retired and had a fixed income, I began doing woodworking to keep myself in pocketmoney. I picked what I wanted to do but as the business grew so did the demands. I finally decided I would do for myself for a change but still do occasion jobs for a select few people

Re: career change

#10

Re: Don't quit your day job

ScottS

>As a practical matter, I'd also suggest that you not quite your day job. It may take you a bit longer, but I'd suggest a weekend class here, a week long class there, all while keeping a paying job in your current field. Once you're starting to feel a little confident, try taking on a small project for an understanding client. Or build something yourself and see if you can convince anyone to buy it. Along the way, you'll need to acquire tools to outfit your shop. And if you do decide to make woodworking a full-time career you'll also need a lot of money in the bank to help you through the lean times.

In addition to knowledge of woodworking, there's a lot more you need to know in order to run a successful business! I've worked for some extremely brilliant people... who've gone bankrupt because they didn't know how to successfully execute their ideas. In addition to woodworking classes, you might need to take some classes in accounting, business, or marketing if you don't already have those skills.

If you really want to start a business, I'd begin by working on a budget. How much money do you need to spend on tools? Classes? How much will it cost you to get professional liability insurance? How much money does it take to support your family every month? How long will it take you to save the money to weather the first 6-12 months of your career as a professional woodworker, a period where you probably won't make

Finally, you might consider that there are other careers where you can work with your hands, create things, and be artistic but also make money. Welding comes to mind. I find it very similar to woodworking in many respects, and very enjoyable. If I were going to attempt to turn one of my hobbies into a career, I suspect that I could start making money as a welder long before I'd make a dime as a woodworker...

Re: career change

#11

Re: career change

Chuck Lenz

>Been there, tried that. I use to luv woodworking. I don't do as much of it anymore. Most of what I do is for myself or very rarely a gift to someone in the family. It's not worth it. If you decide to go to work for a custom cabinet shop you have to remember most of those places are small family run bussineses that take care of themselves first and offer very little bennifits if any at all. Don't plan on any retirement working for someone like that, If you ever do make it to retirement after breathing fine dust and laquer for a number of years. Woodworking is the only skill that I know of that a person can spend thousands of dollars on equipment, work in a very dangerous enviroment and see very little compensation or respect for it. Keep it as a hobby. Don't ruin it for yourself like I have.

Re: career change

#12

Re: career change

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>From someone who made a living at woodworking for 24 years. Sort of. I kept the sheriff away from the door. But.

I also wrote, taught, invented tools and sold them, and demonstrated at shows around the country. I did not have a family to support.

On a good week I got 20 hours in the shop to work on a commissioned project. And those were 60+ hours a week. The rest of the time was spent marketing and doing the business end of the business. Marketing is the biggest and best honed skill you will need. I had well over $60K invested in tools. I had a big barn for my shop on my own property, or I would not have made it.

Before I ruined my health, a very real concern, God had a change of plan for me. I was in an auto accident and simply was unable to go back to the work and schedule I had. I sold off half the shop and the property, moved to Arizona, with plans to write and produce WW DVD's. Then another change of plan.

I am now at seminary studying to become a parish pastor. I am as happy as I can be. Woodworking is a wonderful hobby that I plan to continue as I am able. I get to explore new skills for fun, like turning. There again is excitement in getting out to the shop.

So you have heard from those who have thought about it, those who tried and failed, and those who have tried and hung on. I know quite a few people who try to make a living as a professional woodworker. The only people I ever met, and still know today, continue only because they have a spouse with a really good job and health insurance that allows them the luxury of working at woodworking full time.

The reality is that the only market out there for solo woodworkers is the very high end, sophisticated, collector with the bucks to indulge. The other reality is that there are darn few of those and a whole heck of a lot of people seeking to woo them. Visit some galleries that display wood craft. Talk with the owner about what it takes to get to the level to make money at your craft. Don't be surprised if you hear the word 'talent' a lot. Talent is not the same as skill.

Here is another reality. Woodworking is not a skill to learn so you can go out a get a job in the field. Woodworking is a craft to enjoy creating things out of wood, for yourself, for your family, for your friends, and occasionally for money. If you go the money route, then you have liability and the insurance premiums are a killer.

Woodworking is an umbrella term, under which lives many skills, from framing houses, to carving exquisite furniture. There is craft work like you see at neighborhood craft shows. There are kitchen cabinets, a really competitive market, where computer and production skills outweigh woodworking skills. There are lovely turnings and whittled whistles for the kids. And there is a tool set and skill set for each one. There is also a distinctive market for each along with a distinctive way to reach for that market.

And then you have a whole world of hobbyists who can and will work for the price of materials as competition. Remember one thing. The customer does not understand nor appreciate what woodworking skill is or the investment of time and money required. They know what they like and don't like. They only spend money on what they do like, and then they want it right away.

I won't apologize for the bucket of cold water. If you have a family and plan to fund a retirement, your financial needs are far greater that woodworking can realistically meet.

Keep your hobby my friend. Take day classes, weekend classes, week long classes as you find time and money. Enjoy them. Hone your skills for your own enjoyment. That will allow you to be refreshed for your day job. Look for ways to keep your day job fun and stimulating as well. I am sure there are classes, seminars, and workshops in that field as well. Learning new things is what keeps life fun. Making a living is not always fun, and being your own boss is tough - much, much tougher than working for another.

From one who has been there and done that, for more years than most. And I am glad to being enjoying other things, and still able to enjoy woodworking.

Re: career change

#13

Re: career change

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Woodworking as a career is often romanticized into something that it really is not. I would guess that all of the things you dislike now about the mental health profession will be present in your woodworking career. Remember that you will be dealing with customers. My best advice would be to make sure your spouse has a good job and the children are grown up and moved out on their own. Some people can actually make a good living as a woodworker, myself for instance, but it takes dedication and long years of hard work. I still call myself a "cabinetmaker" even though all I do now is run a computer for a woodworking factory. There are people like Frank Klausz and Sam Maloof that you have heard about; think about the number of famous woodworkers you hear about, and then the number of Hollywood stars. It is easier to make it big in the movie industry than it is in the woodworking industry. If you read all of this and still decide to stick with it, I wish you the best of luck.

Re: career change

#14

Re: career change *LINK*

john lucas

>I am a professional photographer who is fortunate enough to shoot a lot of fine are and craft. I hear the same thing over and over when I talk to the artists from all medium. They say that they probably wouldn't be in business unless the spouse was working, or they make thier lifestyle fit thier income. None of them are driving BMW,s. Most are happy and enjoy what they are doing but are worried about retirement and most have little or no insurance unless thier mate does. One friend just got out of a successful business and went back to work because medical premiums simply got too expensive to pay.

I was a very good very serious amatuer photographer. I got layed off a few jobs and found this job at the University. I no longer even pick up a camera when I'm not at work. It simply isn't fun anymore. I picked this job working for the state becaue I new that I was not a good business person and I'm learning from these artists that the business end and promotion end are far more important than what you make or how you make it.

I see a lot of artists come through our school (see the link below). It is an excellent school and I would highly recommend it if you decide to go that route. Most of the ones that I have kept in touch with have gone on to work in that field and some quite successfully. None of them are rich. Even the one that I feel is the most successful and sells pieces for $1000 of dollars, works 60 hour weeks and worries about the bills.

I've been a very serious woodworker for 25 years now and thought about going into full time quite a bit. I've looked at the reality and decided that I'm far better off hanging in here until retirement.


http://www.tntech.edu/craftcenter

Re: career change

#15

Re: career change

Mike Fitterling

>You really did not give enough information for us help you a lot. Do you want to build cabinetry? Do you want to build furniture? Studio furniture? Turning? As you can see, many on this board want to keep woodworking as a hobby, so the pressures of making a living from it are removed from the equation. That's valid and useful information. But we don't know much about you: Is your job pulling down substantial amounts of money and benefits to keep you and your family comfortable for now and the future or are you scraping by at some low paying job in that sector. Mental health worker can mean anything from janitorial work in a hospital to a psychitarist. Also, is there a real need for YOUR psychological well-being to get out of that arena?

As mentioned, making a living at woodworking can be difficult, especially if you have to compare it to a substantial previous income. Making a big step down will be very difficult. If, on the other hand, your current job is making you miserable, is not compensating you well and leaving you without any retirement or insurance benefits (Wait, I just described my my own real job! except the making me miserable part. :) ), then a move may be sideways, depending on a lot of factors.

I don't know about Minnesota, but here in central Florida, I could pretty quickly switch to cabinet-making and have more work than I could keep up with and probably not diminish my salary at all. I've actually set up my shop, so that if that becomes a necessity I can make the switch quickly to full-time. This is cabinet work, though, not high end furniture, although that comes along from time to time.

I think custom cabinetry is the quickest way to making some money in woodworking, but if you don't like that kind of work, then it is not for you. The other option is to keep your kinds of woodworking separate, if you pursue this. Make your money with cabinetry and leave the fine furniture, or turning, or box making, or whatever you really like as your hobby.

So I guess I am one who will say that it is not impossible, but go into it with your eyes wide open and hedge your bets.

Here's a school I just looked at online (a brochure came in the package from Lie-Nielsen that had my bed float in it--stealth gloat!). It looks interesting and they say they teach some of the business end of woodworking. This school is geared towards the high end furniture work, not cabinetry. Names of instructors is impressive.

Good luck.

Re: career change

#16

Nicely writen Carol.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>

Re: career change

#17

Re: career change

Michael Wilkins

>Another vote for not quitting your day job. Woodworking for me will never be more than a very serious hobby, with small but steady jobs doing new work, refinishing and building for my own home/relatives.

Unless you are a medium-size company turning out high-grade woodwork on million dollar homes, it is difficult squeezing out a living working wood.

And furniture making is even riskier. In today's "Walmart economy", folks are looking for cheap, cheap, cheap. It is difficult for me to compete with Queen Anne coffee tables out of a box, made of stained MDF, when I build with premium-grade cherry and hand-rubbed finish.

I often get people saying I should do this for a living, but I think they are just paying a compliment without knowing the full story.

If you keep it on a hobby level, your enjoyment will keep you from turning this wonderful craft into a 9 to 5 grind.

Just my 2 cents.

Its Saturday. Lets go make some sawdust.

Re: career change

#18

Re: Nicely writen Carol. Thanks, Ray.

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>A dose of reality is often not what anyone wants to hear, but it is precisely what ought not to be overlooked. :))

Re: career change

#19

Re: career change - First read a book.

Don L.

>In everything, there is a right way and a wrong way to do something, and a right reason and a wrong reason to do it. Going into business isn't any different.

I would strongly recommend that anyone considering starting their own business read, "The E-Myth: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and What to Do About It" or "The E-Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and What to Do About It" (HarperBusiness), which is an updated printing.

Most businesses fail in a relatively short period of time. Many people suggest that it is a lack of knowledge and/or a lack of the money needed to sustain a startup business.

I believe that the problem is even more basic than that and Mr. Gerber has defined it precisely.

Before putting your future on the line, invest $10.00 to $15.00 and buy his book. It may save you a fortune in money, headaches, frustration and disappointments.

Having gone into business 30-years ago with the wrong expectations and for the wrong reasons, I only wish that I had read such information as his beforehand.

Don

Re: career change

#20

Ellis Walentine

I'll go along with the majority opinion here...

Ellis Walentine

>...but there's one avenue that worked for me, so it may be worth mentioning: custom commissioned work. Mike characterized it as cabinetry, and a lot of it was indeed custom cabinetry, but it cascaded into a lot of other interior and exterior architectural woodworking and quite a bit of freestanding furniture and minor odds & ends, too.

As several folks mentioned, marketing is usually cited as the stumbling block for most wannabee professionals, and rightly so. For me, though, once I had ingratiated myself with a few key architects and designers, I never had to go looking for the next job -- well, rarely -- it always found me. Not only that, but since I had built a reputation for doing excellent work and delivering on time without a lot of hassles and hitches, I rarely had to bid against other makers and I could charge what I wanted. Even if my bid was high, I could usually convince the customer of the value and land the job anyway.

I probably couldn't have perpetuated the custom business for twenty years without some background in design and my early exposure to the architectural community, which enabled me to do shop drawings and suggest palatable alternatives to the specifiers -- not to mention that I had been exposed to high-end woodworking in the late '70s. But I didn't take classes; I took commissions and then learned the best ways to do them by talking to friends who were studying this stuff at RIT -- sort of a learn-as-you-go strategy -- and it worked for me.

To sum up, you will need excellent woodworking chops, effective marketing chops (and/or a small circle of specifiers who like your work), a lot of tenacity to get you through the lean times. And, to make a point, I used to say that some years I made six figures and some years I made four figures. If you don't have a safety net -- or if you are overestimating your qualifications -- it can be pretty nerve-wracking and you can easily fail. That's why I prefer to keep woodworking as a pleasurable hobby and only take commissions if I feel like it.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: career change

#21

career change

nailshooter

>I don't post much here as I belong to too many other forums. But this one had me, as I couldn't imagine responses more accurate, well thought out, and just plain truthful.

I have started four small companies, all of them successful. I am currently self employed as a remodel/repair/specialty carpentry company. I have had as many as 16 people working for me on payroll and as little as none. I have been in business for myself about 25+ years and the phone now rings on its own. I neve advertise, as all my business is either repeat or referral.

Sounds great, right? In one way yes, in another, no. Anymore custom cabinetry means custom sized, not custome work. Same old carcass construction, just the doors are different. I have more fun finshing pieces now than I do building them. I have never been commissioned to build a piece of Federalist furniture, but I have built a lot of bathroom cabinets, some kitchen cabinets (cheaper for all to buy these days), and a cabinet here and there for a personal library or a receptionist's desk for a commercial client.

I imagined myself in a well lit, but cramped shop full of well used tools of all manner, many I had spent years mastering. I would have solitary time in the shop to exercise my craft, recalling the skills of the ancients and applying them to the piece at hand.

Then I woke up.

The real money in carpentry is repair/rehab of houses. I can make more in a day of 3 layer crown molding installation than my buddy that is a full time custom cabinet maker can make in the same week. His pieces sell for thousands, but he spends so much time on them that he wishes he was able to do something else. We figured out how much he made a month, and it was grim.

I can go to a client's house and hang two exterior doors and walk out of the deal with $600 for a 8-10 hour day, depending on how difficult the installation turns out to be. He hasn't seen a $600 day since I have known him. But his work is so good and so well received that he has about a 3 year wait list from people wanting him to do their work.

Like me, he doesn't enjoy it anymore. Worse for him, he makes enough money to keep going, but not enough to get well. He will have a good month, then he is pleased, but then another like last month will roll around when his landlord upped his rent and he broke the motor shaft on his bandsaw when resawing some veneer on a punky log.

I have been to his shop many times to help him out since we are buddies, and I usually have to buy lunch if I want something other than McDonalds. His company would be pretty good for him if it was JUST him, but like you he has kiddos and working wife. This is sad, but he was telling me the other day that he overwhelmingly thankful that his kids weren't interested in college but had opted out for trades school and military to finish their educations.

In your community you should try to find a group called SCORE. It is a group of retirees that were successful as entrepreneurs and business owners, and they can really be quite helpful. They have helped many here in my city and seem to be a pretty good group. At the last time I heard, their advice and guidance is free.

The SCORE folks can help you with the aspect of your business that will take 75% of your time. Marketing, client retainage, budgets, how to keep your books in line for that first mind numbing audit, when to make quarterly tax deposits, how to write a valid contract, etc. Time in your shop making sawdust will seem like a dream from your past if you really push this idea.

One last thing. If you are going to be successful at it, you will need to be committed to the point of obsession. If you are undercapitalized (80% of all businesses fail from that alone) than you will be putting in your own personal sweat and time to make up for it. Weekends, holidays, vacations, etc., will grow to mean little. Now that me and my cohorts are all in our 50s and 60s (me the youngest but started the earlies) almost none of them feel like what they put into it was something they would do again. They would spend their time with family, especially their kids.

If you do it, good luck, but I would really think it important to read and reread the info you have on this thread. Who cares if you lose your hobby... who cares? You will find another.

But if you are living paycheck to paycheck and have a wife and family, what if you bollox this up and lose them? Think of this: one study I just saw said that 93% of all business fail in the first three years. Somewhere in the upper 80s for the first year. (See above comments on undercapitalization). I don't remember how many it said wound up in bankruptcy and how many had huge debt load they simply couldn't service.

The best advice on this has been given here. But I would certainly suggest you do a lot more research and all the contingency planning you can before you take you and your family on that ride.

Robert L. Witte

Prime Resource Construction, Inc.

Re: career change

#22

Dale Lenz

Re: E-Myth

Dale Lenz

>Is an excellent book. I love Sarah and her pies, don't think it was Sara Lee pies the book was talking about. As I sold a piece of work to an executive of Sara Lee once and Googled Sara Lee Pies. The main thing I got out of the book was: The owner of the business **works on the business not in the business **. I still work in and on the business, always will. That said, I will never make 6 figures. As one friend told me, you are the most expensive floor sweeper in your shop!

Anyway, back to working wood for a living. What I've done is test the waters before diving in. That has been pretty much my way of thinking. I got bit by the woodworking bug my last year in college. I went ahead and followed my degree for a living. But I have always worked wood after 5 and on weekends, mostly projects for myself and the family. Had a few custom jobs, worked for min. wage, my fault. I have found a small niche, and still have not made 5 figures yet, might this year. In my case, : ' > marketing is everything. Many folks will purchase my work, if they can find it. Obviously, if I went full time, I think I could make 5 figures, low side. Without hiring help or commission tasks, I just can not produce enough work. It's been suggested once, that I consider a CNC machine, that's to be seen. It's also been suggested for me to throw my hand planes in the trash, will never happen!

The bottom line: woodwork after 5 and on weekends and see what becomes of it. I think many folks on this board do that and enjoy both worlds. Who knows, you might decide to take the jump in the future, but you should be better prepared at that time.