>This maybe slightly OT if Wood Central is only about furniture. Can the wood in your house be too dry for it's own good. Not asking about beauty or really even cracking. Is it possible for your floor joists and other structure to be damaged or weakened by being too dry?
What brought this on was an arguement with a termite company claiming its important for the vapor barrier in the crawl space to let some moisture pass, because "your house NEEDS some moisture". I don't think so. Besides, I'm in humid southside Virginia. I don't think too dry is possible. Even if the wood were baked to Zero percent, would that weaken or damage it or shorten it's useful life?
>Not being a botanist or whatever the profession that studies wood. I'd have to say from personal experience that wood can certainly be too dry. In my former life as a carpenter I recall many instances of dried out warped and twisted brittle studs that split apart rather easily during demolition and not only felt tinder dry but were pretty light in comparison to what I'd consider to be an average weight for a stud.
>Think of wood cells as grapes which become raisins as the wood dries. When you get down to the last few percentage points of moisture, the cells distort greatly. This answers your final question, although your scenario with the builder seems only remotely related.
>Barry, I remember years ago there was an argument as to whether or not a vapor barrier placed on the ground in a crawl space was to cover all or most of the surface. The contention for most was to allow some moisture through for the exposed wood framing. The contention from those that argued for all was that the crawl space vents in the foundation walls would allow enough moisture in to satisfy things.
That said, when we built our present house back in 96, Va. Power was promoting the Energy Saver Plus package for new homes. Besides the extra caulking and sealing of the framing, higher HVAC specs, and better insulation, a big part of this package was how they treated the home's crawl space. The idea was to make it like a dry basement in a home that had one. Our house has no foundation vents, the insulation is sprayed onto the foundation walls along the perimeter, which leaves the floor joists open and easy to get to, there's a French drainage trench with 4" drain tile and gravel around the perimeter of the interior foundation to allow any water to drain away, and the plastic vapor barrier covers 100% of the ground space. In the winter it's just as pleasant under the house as inside and the same goes for summer.
In the ten years we've been here, I've seen no problems with the wood materials under there yet. To answer your question, I don't believe you need to worry, especially if the house in question has crawl space vents. You know better than anyone that most homes aren't built tight enough to keep out all moisture. I'd say put the vapor barrier over the entire space and it'll be fine.
>I actually think the question has two answers....one scientific or literal and the other practical or real world. I suppose it would be possible to kiln or oven dry lumber to 0% and I am guessing somebody in some wood tech lab has done that and tested the wood at that stage. They may have found that the cells shrivel and the wood is weakened or damaged. I would be curious to know. OTOH the lumber industry recommends framing be dried to below 19% (?) and most people dry furniture wood to about 6% if they can. The framing is dried to whatever level for several reasons. To get the lumber to near its natural final state and reduce warping or eliminate hose pieces that warp and to reduce the chances of mold growth and rot.
I have been told that lumber arrives at a MC of about 15% of RH in the surrounding air. So, if the RH around your house is 100% the wood will equilibrate at about 15 to 17%. This would indicate the lumber continues to dry after it is reduced to 19% and that may be true. Maybe framing is supposed to at 12%.(?)
I wonder if the conditioned crawl space as any chance of drying the lumber so far that it shrivels into the raisin state? The other problem with the conditioned crawl space is making it possible to inspect for termites. The insulation on the sidewalls proves an ideal concealed path for them to travel up to the band board. A different issue.
So, as a practical matter, is it possible to dry your house�s framing enough to damage it?
>You need moisture for mold to grow so that quasi-experts in such things can have jobs and support their families in the manner to which they've become accustomed.
OTOH, sealing the structure with completely impermeable barriers like Visqueen and super-insulation will trap moisture inside and promote mold growth. From what I know, a moisture barrier in the crawl space is there to keep the joists in EMC with the rest of the structure, and prevent infusion of bad things like radon. (But you knew that, right?)
I actually had a pest control guy show me a few little black spots in the attic framing members and try to talk me into a mold remediation job. "It's not gonna get any better," he correctly informed me with his best VSF (Very Serious Face). There is a reason that I play dumb when one of these jokers shows up. It's often entertaining to see how creatively the putz is going to try to defraud me.
>1. To cut to the chase, there is no place in Virginia where wood can get near 0 % moisture content under ambient conditions. Doubtful any wood in VA has ever seen even 6% unless in an attic during a drought and a heat wave. Where you live you will have trouble keeping hardwood lumber near the moisture content (MC) it had when it left the kiln. Your rafters might get to 6% MC during July. I doubt that your floor joists have ever been under 10% MC.
2. Some of the responses do not hold up to logical scrutiny. Houses get successfully built in AZ and there it is reasonable to expect rafters to live at near 0% moisture content (MC) in the summer without suffering. Hardwood lumber is commercially dried to something under 7% MC and then steamed back to 7% for sale, all with out issue of wood degradation. Wood taken to near 0% will regain to nearly normal MC when subjected to a humid environment.
3. While there is no degradation of wood taken to dryness, joints are another matter. But I don't see this factor as an issue in house construction where joints are nailed not rigidly glued.
>Jeez. ALl of this overcomplicates something that is fairly simple: vapor barriers need to be permeable for oneprimary reason. Houses trap moisture. That moisture needs to escape. I've forgotten the actual figures, but, offhand, I seem to recall at least a quart of moisture escaping from a single person breathing during a day, and about four times that much from cooking two meals.
That water has to go somewhere, thus a permeable vapor barrier. The other option is impermeability and dew forming on the interior walls.
AFAIK, wood is not harmed by dryness. What would "excessive" dryness be, anyway, in a house? The 6% recommended for furniture and cabinet manufacture? That is unattainable outside a kiln (or an attic space, or winter in a heated area) in most areas of the U.S. It certainly can't be maintained in my area (central Virginia). Anyone who posits lack of moisture as harmful to a house is going in exactly the wrong direction.
Wood that crumbles from seeming dryness has other problems, generally created by too fast drying, or by not drying properly or by not...a host of things, none of which involve too little moisture unless it also involves something that will bring the wood above kindling temperature (or tempachur as meteorologists are wont to say).
>Looking at the structures in the desert - Egypt comes to mind, furniture and wooden sarcophagi removed from the tombs appear to be structurally sound after a few thousand years. Also buildings and furniture in some of the "Ghost Towns" left after the gold rush appear to be intact in the desert. I don't know what the actual moisture content of wood in these environments drop too, but I'm certain its is very low, far below anything we could experience in normal buildings in the USA. I have no scientific evidence to collaborate these musings, but it appears the wood has survived intact and strong enough to survive for many years in these environments without damage.
I was kidding. The wood in any structure is going to reach and maintain EMC for its location, unless it's subjected to wetting and limited drying. The vapor barrier in a crawl space keeps the joists from getting too WET and critters from taking up residence in the insulation. An improperly vented crawl space can build up very high humidity and damage the structure.
Met a guy in CA who had a nice business regluing furniture for people who had moved there from places like New Jersey or Michigan only to have the wood shrink and the joints break from the change in EMC.
I also agree that you are not going to over-dry framing wood by covering the ground completely in the crawl space.
Over-drying can be an issue with furniture wood, though. Drying below about 5% can create issues with machinability. I don't know whether those changes reverse when the wood goes back to equilibrium with its environment.
For what its worth, here in the New Mexico desert, the RH is 2% today. I just checked some maple that I have had in the garage for 3 years. It is 5%. And there are no raisins. I can't imagine how wood would get to 0% outside of a fire ;^).
The thing that causes wood deterioration in the ghost towns is UV as much as heat and dryness.
Now as someone commented, the effect of dryness on joinery is a different matter.
>A few years ago, a friend and I tore down and recycled the wood from a couple century+ old homes. Old-growth Redwood and Fir. That wood had been subjected to desert-dry summers for a loooong time, was bone dry, and you could feel the difference in it's weight. I used a lot of that Fir for some construction projects around the house. Won't comment on the quality difference between the old stuff and what's available now, but I can tell you that Fir wasn't "weakened" in any way.
I don't think you have to worry about the structural integrity of your house, even if the wood is dryer than your ambient environment can keep it.
>The little nasties that breakdown wood and give us breathing problems need either damp or damp then dry conditions to live. If their environment is dry or saturated they can't live. Life needs oxygen, water keeps [most] of that out.
Did the pest guy advocate punching holes in your vapor barrier to allow more exchange? What was his dog in the race?
>Not to be a dink, but what's the logic here? If it's permeable, by definition, it's not a vapor barrior. Why bother installing a vapor barrior if not to stop the movement of moisture?
The purpose of a moisture barrior is to prevent condensation where moist, warm air meets a cold surface, like in your walls, by physically preventing it from migrating there. If trapped, humid air is a problem, ventilate the area.
>This topic of wet crawl spaces is endless for me. My real job that supports my woodworking habit is Home Inspector. I see wet crawl spaces frequently. I've been seeing them for the entire twenty one years I've been inspecting. Every once in a while I get Buffaloed by one of these BS artists that have the latest approach.
The one last night had the "encapsulated crawl space". Should have been called the "Excapsulated" crawl space. They had some 30 mil or 20 mil or 15 mil (if you were cheap) laminated plastic with about six layers and they wrapped the entire inside fo the crawl space up to but NOT including the top row of block.
We asked if they put a heat and AC vent in the crawl space. (BS Alert) His answer was NO, that many heating systems were so closely designed that they would not support an additional vent or the increased heat loss. What they did do was put a pair of through the floor vents with their own fans. One blew air into the crawl and the other returned it to the house. Anyone see the problem here? The heat loss would be the same or worse, just indirect.
They put in interior drainage systems. Said they had never seen a case where improving the exterior grading had helped anything.
>I may not even have the terminology right. Aren't tyvek and other such products "moisture barriers" in that they repell liquid water if the siding material or flashing leaks, yet still are vapor permiable, allowing the house to breath? A vapor barrier is placed on the inside of the insulation (in cold climates) to work as you describe, preventing condensation in the insulation.
At least, that's how I understand it. No clue as to Barry's original question, at least in part because its pointless to put one of those down out here where wood will dry below 6% without a kiln.
One of the most popular and widely known applications of Tyvek� is in the construction industry, where it is used to increase air and water resistance, helping to lower heating and cooling costs in buildings and providing better protection against water and moisture intrusion. The unique qualities of Tyvek� help stop air flow through wall cavities; help hold out bulk water and wind-driven rain; and allow moisture vapor to escape from inside walls. The result is a more comfortable, energy-efficient building with far fewer chances for damage from degradation effects.
Re: confusion between vapor barrier and "house wra
Barry Irby
>John, you have it right. Polyethylene is a VAPOR barrier as well as a water and air barrier. Tyvek and other similar products are Permeable and allow vapor to pass through but will stop liquid water and air.
Here in Virginia we have too many wet crawl spaces and the issues of water penetration and humidity entering through the foundation vents are big deals. Just yesterday I saw what may be the most rotted floor system under a house I have seen in twenty one years as a home inspector. The joists, Sill and band were so rotted you could stick a finger through them most anywhere. The amazing thing was that not only was the house still standing, it was still occupied and from the inside, looked pretty good.