Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Posts

which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#1

which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Hey! An ON topic post!

Which domestic hardwoods do you wish you could find segregated at your dealer as quartersawn?

I already segregate red oak and white oak this way (as well as rift sawn v. plain sawn; this takes up space!). And my sycamore and sweetgum are essentially only sold as QS (for stability reasons). So, aside from those species, would you pay a small premium to have QS cherry or QS walnut or QS _______ in its own bin at your local dealer?

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Dale Lenz

>Cherry QS is a go. Trying some red elm for the first time, I maybe getting half usuable material. Suggest to my sawyer a few days ago, will continue with some red elm, but will want it QS.

I like flat sawn sycamore also, I ask for nothing over 8" in width. I think QS walnut is somewhat boring. This is just a list off the top of me head.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#3

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Tom,

I think one of the attractions of cherry and walnut both is the striking grain patterns when plain sawed. Neither of them have the volume of ray flake that the other mentioned woods have, thus aren't as attractive when quarter-sawn. Not sure about sweetgum, however. Not sure I've ever seen it QS.

I'll be surprised if you get much postive response for those two. On the other hand, ash looks nice when it's rift or QS. I would suspect that elm would also look good. Might be worth looking through your stacks and planing some different species to see what they look like. Could be a niche market out there that lacks sufficient service.

Gary

Gary

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#4

all of them :)

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>I would love to find a regular selection of quatersawn wood. I Really like straight grain and it is essential to frame some nice burl, etc

IMO.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#5

Cherry

Chad Pearson

>While I don't think q sawn cherry looks all that much different I do appreciate the stability for making doors and legs.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#6

All of them

Ted Wong

>

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#7

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I always demand that my balsa wood be quarter sawn. ;-)

T.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#8

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>I always order QS oak closet rods! LMAO!

Ron in Iowa

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#9

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Dean J in MN

>Not hardwood -- but I'm always keeping an eye out for QS pine.

Really.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#10

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Al Killian(Westeren NY)

>QS Maple looks nice. I am not a fan of QSRO.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#11

Well I will toss Blacklocust on the heap

Keith Newton

>It and its cousin mulberry have a nice fleck when QS. I just wish they would stay that nice gold color.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#12

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Definitely all of the above. And Pine as well.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#13

Agree

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#14

A question(s) about quarter sawn?

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>There is the NHLA definition of QS which allows the growth rings to deviate some number of degrees from "true" quarter sawn (30 if I recall correctly). So in fact "quartered" commercially graded lumber contains pieces with grain that would be considered "rift" if it was veneer. I suppose this results from the practical matter that I don't know any way to hold a log on a modern carriage to cut most or even much of it true quartered.

When I have had logs "quarter sawn" some slabs are taken off opposing sides of the log, the resulting "cant" is sawed through the heart and these more or less half logs are then laid down on the carriage and sliced to yield rift grain on the edges and more or less quartered toward the middle. This technique is the best that can be done on a modern carriage (as far as I know) while providing stable support for the logs(cants) and a place to secure it with the dogs. Alternatively, many mills now saw cants and send them through a gang saw. This process will yield a board or two from each cant that is true quartered, but usually of low grade.

Given this background that I have never seen a modern mill that could produce much "true" quartered lumber from a log my questions are many.

1.Is the lumber you speak of "true" quartered or quartered by NHLA definition?

2. If "true" as defined by growth rings 90 degrees to the board face, how is it produced in any quantity? The answer could be "selected from rift". But if it is sawed that way what is the sawing technique?

The motivation for the question is I have bought a 450 bdft poplar log that, for a special application, I want to get as much true quartered lumber from it as possible.

Re: which domestic hardwoods do you want QS?

#15

hi BIll *LINK*

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Scott Banbury's site has pictures of the method we have our sawyer use to QS. (His explanation is for a smaller log. We follow the top picture as described below). For sycamore and oak, I define QS as a board with visible ray fleck; no fleck, it's rift. We get better than 75% QSA yield (guessing) with this method:

1 - quarter big fat (>36") sycamore/oak with chainsaw.

2 - lay a quarter on the bandmill with one "flat" face down and remove a wedge from the top, leaving maybe a 6" flat.

3 - flip and do the same with the other big flat down.

4 - remove a few boards from the big flat faces. These are pure QS and the widest ones you will get. It's pretty cool to see people's eyes pop out at 16"+ wide QS material.

5 - slab the remaining "quarter" shaped piece through and through with the arc on one side and the point of the quarter on the other. The sawyer might saw a wedge and make a flat surface at some point to keep this stable; I don't remember. The first and last boards from this step are narrow and rift while the center few are true QS, so this method yields the widest boards as all QS.

HTH


Scott's most excellent diagram