Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Posts

OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#1

OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Hoa Dinh in Alameda

>We are at the cash registers of a large department store....

Two of the registers display a big sign, "Express Line - 10 Items or Less."

My son and I think it is bad English. It should be "10 Items or Fewer."

My SWMBO thinks is is some sort of rhetorical device.

What do you say?

-- Hoa

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#2

Re: OT - 10 Items or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I think you're doing too much reading at grocery check-out counters.

|;-}}

But actually it should be "Limit: 10 Items" since anything less (or fewer) than that number is, logically, included in the stated limit. The "or" + either term is therefore tautological.

mm

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#3

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Al Stokka - Cambrige, Iowa

>I think the signs should be removed since both customers and store employees ignore the limit.

Al

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#4

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Bill Howatt

>My dictionary says that less is correct and means fewer. It also says that less is more likely to be used than "fewer" with plural nouns - "items" in this case.

I don't think fewer is used nearly as much as less since we say things like the distance was less than 10 miles rather than fewer than 10 miles or it cost less than $5, not fewer (dollars) than $5.

Bill

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#5

It DOENS'T matter

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Because I'll go to that line with 2 items and there will be someone who obviously can't read or can't count with a whole cart of items checking out at a cashier who obviously doesn't care.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#6

Re: Was the typo a test?

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#7

Don't you hate that?!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#8

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I don't think it makes much differancve, but would like to add the following to it-"VIOLATORS WILL BE SHOT !!!"

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#9

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>It should also say: CASH ONLY. I don't understand why people write checks for minuscule amounts.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#10

Free Checking (and checks)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>And because they're embarassesed to put a 78 cent charge of their VISA.

|;-}}}}

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#11

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Bob Falk

>fewer is grammatically correct

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#12

Interesteing that so many people

Don Henthorn

>consider the dictionary as an authority on usage which is not it's purpose. I was publishing a vocabulary development program a few years back and at a homeschooling conference a lady wanted to do me the favor of publishing an evaluation of the program. In the program I had included some comments on usage among which was a very common error and lo and behold (an old Bible expression there) the evaluator questioned my criticism because the usage was in the dictionary. Needless to say I told the lady thanks, but no thanks. I didn't want her company evaluating my program. Never did have it evaluated or published. I have about a thousand plus disks. Anyone want a vocabulary development program? (G)

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#13

I can spell but I can't type.

Don Henthorn

>

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#14

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>It is 10 items or fewer (than 10 items). Technically, however, either is correct. Less refers to fewer in amount whether in size or numbers. However, less is more often used numerically. Fewer also refers to numbers and amounts. More often fewer is used as a comparison. The Marines have used it; also Many took the exam but few passed.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#15

Darn keyboard ;)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#16

Re: express

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I don't carry cash and I don't like using a credit card. It is a lot easier to stop payment on checks than cash. It irritates me to no end that writing a check requires leaving your firstborn at the store until the check clears. Life would be so much easier if everyone was honest. And yes, I have also thought that an express line should be cash only but since that is not what the sign says then I will get in that line with my Black Pepper Jack Doritos and Corona and little green limes and write a check.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#17

Say it ain't so!

Ernie Miller

>Moses I never had you figured as a Corona drinker? Learn sumthin new every day.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#18

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

Ernie Miller

>I'm going to twist alot of you people off but the grocery stor where I shop has a habbit of having onlt 3 of it's thirty lines open and one of them it the 10 or less there have been times when they are backed up 10-15 people and I go straight to the 10 or less line with a cart full. if any one says a word to me I tell them to talk to the manager and ask him if he would rather have my $150 or there $10 10 or less is only good if the store is prepared to take care of the rest of there customers. I understand people wanting to get in and out but that is all I want also.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#19

That's one of my pet peeves, but

Johanna

>far worse was the sign: "We don't except checks". I cannot tell you how much I wanted to pay with a check and insist that it was their policy not to "except" them, but I knew there probably wasn't anyone who would get the point.

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#20

Re: That's one of my pet peeves, but

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>Johanna, don't get me started...

except/accept

its/it's

then/than

there/they're/their

here/hear

lay/lie (okay...I could never get these two right, either)

...

You should try reading the truck forum I visit sometime...yikes!

I don't believe I've ever seen anyone spell "solenoid" correctly.

Jason, backing away from the keyboard...

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#21

Forgot a couple...

John in New Mexico

>effect/affect

course/coarse

Probably a few more, but they don't bother me much. I got my first and only D in 8th grade grammar. Learned a lot more english grammar in german class :) :) :).

John

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#22

Ironic, isn't it?

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I never took German, but I learned more about English grammar when I took foreign languages (French, Portuguese and Spanish). Too bad I can't really speak any of them anymore. "Use it or lose it!"

Jason

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#23

Re: Ironic, isn't it? More than ironic!

Carol - Strawberry, AZ

>I have had to learn Ancient Greek and Biblical Hebrew over the last two years. Ain't easy. The reason? Lousy grasp of English grammar. Best help? English as a SECOND language on the internet!

But, so far, I've passed.

But....

Maybe I'd better uncross my fingers and get back to work! :)

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#24

ESL is a regular source of entertainment…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…at our house. My wife's native language is Ukrainian (very similar to Russian and Czech). She didn't learn English until she started school, age five. She still spoke Ukrainian at home until she left, and continued to speak it with her mother until she died about six years ago. She speaks English, however, like a native (well, native Canuckistani, but mostly recognizable here in the States once you get the ehs, oots, and chesterfields out of there) and is very smart.

Nevertheless, even though she's been predominantly an English speaker for over 50 years (I'm not permitted to say how far over), there are still times when some English comes out of her that isn't quite. I've postulated for years that her malapropisms can be laid at the door of her native language (verb/modifier inversion mostly) and of course, they're usually invisible to her until some thoughtless, mean-spirited observer (me) points them out. Then we have a good laugh.

The interesting thing to me is that you'd never know to listen to her that she was ESL. She's an amazing woman.

Rod

Re: OT - 10 Items or ... (English Grammar)

#25

Line is for English and Math majors

Al Kapocius

>