Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Posts

OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#1

OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Joe Pack

>I have been able to make very good 8x10 prints with my 3.0 mp Canon digital, but they are too grainy above that size to make good wall hangings. I would like to make 11x14, or even a bit larger.

How many megapixels would be required to make a good looking 11x14?

A friend has a 7megapixel, 10x optical zoom Sony H5, which seems to get good reviews. Do any of you have experience with that camera? Others you would recommend? My main focus is lighthouse pictures, which are not always close by, so I am interested in a good optical zoom.

I am NOT a technical photogropher, I am a "point and shooter," so I am not looking for a multi-lens $2000 set up.

Thanks

Joe

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#2

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Sawdust Maker

>I'd go for a 5MP camers. I have the canon S50. Mighty fine 5MP for large prints. Good quality prints from them.

I bought it 2 years ago. Price had dropped dramatically. It's not too expensive for a good 5MP camera. Unless you are doing a lot of cropping from the pictures for large photos, 5MP is more than sufficient. If you're cropping a lit, then go for a 7 or 8MP.

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#3

Steven Antonucci

My observations *LINK*

steve antonucci

>I've done a fair bit of photography and while film still wins for resolution vs. digital, the digital world is closing the gap.

I hiked in Yosemite with my 5MP Fuji last summer, and decided to get a shot of the falls blown up to a "big print". I cropped about 1/3 of the "negative" and had the resulting image blown up to 20'x30". I was amazed at how good the print looked. If you are a snapshooter, I'm guessing the 3MP isn't your problem. It's probably your printer.

By the way, this is the service I used to make the print. Easy to use, inexpensive with great quality, and fast turn around.

Steven


Big Photo Help

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#4

Re: Printer

Joe Pack

>I have my prints made at WalMart. Would that be a significant problem? I have never compared them to other sources.

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#5

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Jerry Nicholson

>Try the bigger print and see what results you get before buying the new camera. With more megapixels (higher resolution) you obviously get less pixellation in the big prints but you might still find that noise, lens quality, and diffraction limiting will degrade the quality of your results. The sensor in a "point and shoot" camera is very tiny and its size is the same whether you have 3 megapixels or 10 megapixels. When you spend a bunch more money and buy a DSLR, you get a far larger sensor even though the megapixel count might be the same. I see little value in going beyond 4mp in a P&S camera. I can point you to some technical discussion of this issue, if you really want to go there.

Jerry

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Try Big Photo Help

steve antonucci

>I think they're reasonable and I know the quality is pretty good. I can't tell you about Walmart prints, since I don't use them. One would assume they've got enough volume to warrant good equipment, but you never know.

BPH is online, and you can upload any file you want and even edit before you order. No surprises.

8x10's are $2.08. I don't know what Walmart charges, but for $2, I'd try it.

Steve

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#7

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Jim Dillon

>Joe,

I also think around a 5MP-6MP would suit you fine. At a viewing distance of roughly 36 inches in a well-lit room, around 200 ppi is considered very acceptable for a 13 x 19 print. This equates to roughly a 5 MP camera give or take. If you are taking shots of your lighthouses from a distance and want to crop and blow up, then you might have to increase the MP count a bit. But even point and shoot cameras are coming with increased resolution and the prices continue to drop. One tip is to buy a camera with a tripod socket and pick yourself up a good but inexpensive tripod and use it. That alone will improve your ability to enlarge your shots tremendously. Their are also printing software approaches (such as Qimage) for enlarging photos, but that is getting into another topic area. I print my own, so I can't help you there. Good luck.

Jim

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#8

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Keith Newton

>I am on my third canon in about five years. I had the S2 IS, and my sister wanted it, so I made her a deal when the S3 IS came out. The former was 5 mp, and the later is 6.

The optical is 12X, and the IS stands for image stabilizer, which allows me to shoot more than I would have ever dreamed of without a tripod. I love this camera. With a 4 gig SD card, I can shoot about 1400 shots at high resolution. You may think hun, I who wants to shoot and store that many shots? Sometime when I want to capture action, I will shoot in continuous mode at 1.5 shots per sec, or 90 per minute. Editing is brutal, out of 100 shots I may throw away 95 or more, but those are all shots that I would have missed by a second if I tried to capture them with single frame shooting.

As an added bonus, this camera has a good macro, and super macro. You can fill the frame is something as small as a postage stamp.

It also does video, and can be found online for under $400.

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#9

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

Gene Gauss

>My uncle, who was a printer, told me that publication grade photographs are generally taken to require about 300 dots per inch, or 300x300=90,000 dots/pixels per square inch. For an 11x14 print, i.e., 11x14=154 square inches, that would require 154x90,000=13,860,000 pixels or 13.9 megapixels. That of course would be of a quality level appropriate for National Geographic, and probably a lot better than needed for a nice wall hanging. Some of the new DSLRs are getting up into the 10+ megapixel range, which ought to work out ok for 11x14. I'm seriously thinking of going that way for a project I have in mind. Another option is software that is supposed to improve the quality of lower resolution images. One is called "Genuine Fractals" or something like that. I did a little looking at this kind of thing a couple of years ago, but didn't move on it either. Hope this helps. Gene Gauss

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#10

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints? What camera?

Hamish

>Jo,

I have been using a Fujipix S7000 digital camera for these last two years and I have to say that it has been a joy to use and the photos are great. It is a 6MP camera BUT you must remember that the photos are stored in the camera in the jpeg format, as is usual with most non professional cameras. This means that your 6MP camera compresses the images to around 1.8MP, in the case of my Fuji, and it is this size that is later transferred to the computer.

Having said that, when I have taken a CD of these images to a photo store to have them developed in the traditional way, they look really very good. I have had some blown up to 30 x 45 cm and they still look good with no graininess. I think if I were to make them blown up to poster size, you probably would notice some graininess but only at close range.

So what camera should you buy? My Fuji has now been superseded by newer models, the S9600 and the S6600 cameras. There is also the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ50 which is 10MP. I like these as they perform better than the average pocket sized cameras, they look like SLR cameras but are not. They are really high end automatic /manual cameras with the added possibility of making video shots too.

I like to make up small slide shows or DVD's by combining conventional shots with video clips on my Mac. I use iphoto and imovie, the software that comes as standard with the computer. I should also add that they are light too and are fine for taking with you on country walks etc.

You mentioned that you like taking photos of lighthouses, well if you need a good optical zoom, the Lumix has a 12x zoom which equates to 36-432mm.

Finally, I want to add that I recently bought myself a Nikon D80 SLR camera that has a resolution of 10MP. At the moment, I use the camera in the jpeg mode, resulting in images of 4.5MB on my computer. These I'm sure could be blown up to A3 size with no graininess. I also intend to take photos using the RAW format , once I have the necessary software, and these will be stored at the full 10MP without any loss of quality due to compression, which will give me the best quality I can get from the camera. Don't forget, that with these cameras, you need to buy different lenses. A zoom of say 300mm can set you back more than the price of the camera!

Although the camera is great, it is also a lot heavier than the afore mentioned cameras and does not have video capability. If you are looking for a point and shoot camera with good quality, a good zoom and video capability, I would strongly review the Panasonic.

I hope this will help you decide. Good luck and enjoy yourself taking photos. Let us know what you decided on. Hamish.

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#11

Big Photo looks good

Joe Pack

>Thanks Steve. I checked the link and I like it. I played around a bit with the editing. I will definitely give them a try, especially for the odd sizes and stitched photos I would like to shoot.

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#12

Thanks

Joe Pack

>Thanks for the information, Jerry. I'm either not smart enough or too lazy to do all the technical stuff, so I'll pass on the technical page. :-)

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#13

I know you don't want the techo stuff but ...

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>Is your Canon set to take high quality images ?

One of my digitals is a 4Mp Olympus � the default setting doesn't result in the best printed image. Although the image is captured with the maximum the pixel count, the in camera compression is too high if you want to print a large image.

I've also used a 3Mp Sony which took great photos, which were still great in a frame even when enlarged to 21 x 14. Apart from the Zeis lens, the key was the default stored image, which was around 1.5MB.

If your image files are smaller than this look to see if you can store a higher quality image in the camera itself.

That may "fix" the problem for you

Re: OT - Megapixels for large prints?

#14

Re: I know you don't want the techo stuff but ...

Joe Pack

>Thanks Ian. I don't know the exact settings, but, when I am shooting pictures I might want to blow up, I use the settings that give me the least number of pictures on a Compact Flash card. On a 128mb card, I can get anywhere from 80 to 240 pics. I use the 80 pic setting.

I may need to play with the settings and see if I can go even higher quality.