Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Posts

OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#1

OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We talked about this last month... how meaningful, really, are the eBay ratings?

In the past, as a buyer, the seller posts positive feedback for me as soon as I pay for the item, which is usually anywhere from a few minutes to a few hours after it ends. Then I post feedback for them when the item arrives.

Makes sense to me. Once I've paid for the item, my resposibility ends. I've done my part, I am ready to be judged, graded and given feedback.

But more recently I've been seeing things like this:

"Hello, Sorry for the delay, but your (item) was insured and shipped on (date). Please, leave feedback when you receive it so I will know that it has arrived, then I will leave positive feedback for you and consider the sale complete."

So, how do I interpret this? I paid within 15 minutes of the auction end, they took over a week to send it, but I won't get a positive feedback point unless I leave positive feedback for them first?!?!?!

And how about this one:

"I have shipped the item to you. You should be receiving it shortly. Once your item arrives in satisfactory condition, please leave feedback for me. I will do the same for you."

Seems like more sellers are waiting to post feedback until they see what the buyer posts for them. Ridiculous!

Sorry, I have a high and perfect eBay score because I pay early and always. But I can't say that I put much faith in seller's scores much anymore. Not when I see this sort of thing going on.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#2

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have seen the same thing recently on eBay. My reaction: don't leave any rating for such people. That is what I have been doing anyway.

Howard

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Dale Lenz

>As a seller: I leave feedback shortly after bidder has paid.

As buyer, another eBay name: I usually leave positive feedback, If and only if, seller has left me feedback after I've paid, and of course, if item is as described, shipped in a timely matter etc.

Many sellers want to have an arm hold on the buyer, I personal think: that stinks!

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#4

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

ScottS

>Unfortunately, this seems to be the rule rather than the exception these days! I can't remember the last time I got feedback from a seller before I'd left feedback from them. The unfortunate thing is that this strategy works!

I recently got screwed when a seller advertised one thing and sent me another when I won the auction... plus added a sales tax charge that wasn't disclosed in the original listing. I returned the item and got my money back, but lost $40-50 on shipping (through no fault of my own). I left negative feedback for the seller saying exactly what happened ("Bought X, got Y. Hidden tax charge. Got refund. Lost shipping $$$$") and, of course, they immediately left negative feedback for me saying that I was "completely unreasonable".

The great thing is: since I use eBay infrequently their feedback will be visible on my profile forever. They're a pawn shop eBaying dozens and dozens of items a month, so my comments show up only for a short time before becoming just a statistic.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#5

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Eric M - San Jose

>I've noticed the same thing. My policy has always been leave positive feedback when the item is paid for because at that point, the buyer has completed his end of the bargain. What has happened recently is that maybe half don't bother leaving feedback at all.

I've always gone by a percentage and then if something looks amiss, I'll look at that person's feedback to see the reasons why.

I've even sent emails to sellers thanking them for the transaction and asking for positive feedback and that I would return the favor.

FWIW

Eric

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#6

As always, caveat emptor

Rob Sandow

>I have a number of personal rules about e-bay. I use the service perhaps 5 or 10 times a year, to buy and sell personal items such as tools and musical instruments.

As a buyer, I usually do not buy anything from professional e-bay sellers. If you have more than a couple of hundred feedbacks, I usually pass, no matter how much I may want what you are selling. I like to deal with hobbyist individuals, not e-bay power sellers.

As a seller, I have been burned a few times by people with no feedback so I always state in my listing that you have to have feedback of at least 5 as a buyer with no negatives in order to bid, or else email me first so I know who you are.

I find that about 25% of people don't leave feedback. I always do, but if they put some kind of condition on it like you describe then I simply won't. It's not worth the bother. Don't leave feedback, don't expect any either. It's better than getting in a petty battle with someone and winding up with negative feedback which can damage your good rating.

Rob

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#7

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Charles Self

>A couple years ago, I left neutral feedback because the junk a guy sent me was just that, junk. Valueless in today's world, but touted as the all time gas saving device--I had hoped it would have some information for an article I was working on. It was a carb fuel line preheater plan. It might have worked well when most cars had carburetors. Anyhow, the guy went ballastic and gave me a negative rating, to this day the only one I've had, and one of which I am fairly proud.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#8

Re: As always, caveat emptor

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I also feel if you are uncomfortable with practices on Ebay, then you really should find a differant place to sell or buy. I have had worse dealings with high profile corporations and their products then with transactions on Ebay. I am using one of those products to send this posting.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#9

Ric Taylor

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Ric Taylor

>Mark,

As a buyer, I always send payment within a few hours of the auction's closing. I hope that the seller will leave positive feedback for my quick payment. If that happens, then I will leave feedback when the product arrives in a satisfactory manner.

If the seller does not leave feedback for me after my quick payment, I do not leave feedback for the seller. Some sellers in this situation have send me email sometime later asking for feedback. I write back to them and explain that I will be happy to reward them with feedback, as soon as they give me positive feedback for my quick payment. Believe it or not, this has actually upset several sellers, but guess what? I don't care. I ignore them.

Ric

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#10

I have yet to have a seller leave feedback first

Mike in Paradise

>The way it is a joke as if you leave negative feedback for a seller you know you are going to get it back even if you paid immediately. The only way you can avoid this is to wait unit the time limit is about to expire and leave the negative feedback right at the cut off time.

The feedback system is flawed as you do not have enough space to respond with enough details.

How it should work is that you MUST leave feedback and that both feedback from the buyer and seller are posted at the same time so neither will influence the others.

Plus Ebay to so many people is more about winning the auction than about getting a reasonable deal. I cannot believe how often used stuff goes for almost new prices.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#11

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Chad Pearson

>A seller may post a response that you were "entirely unreasonable etc" but I don't think it matters. If I see a negative on a seller it is an immediate red flag. If I see more than one I just avoid them. I don't care what they say in a response.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Mark,

I think you're pretty much right on. The feedback ratings are n't a very good indicator at all.

My one 'negative' feedback came when I'd bought and paid for an item, and never received it. After several email exchanges, the seller told me he'd 'lost the item during a recent move, and would refund my money.' He did refund - about a month later...

In the meantime, though, he re-listed the same item, which this time sold for considerably more than I'd bid on the first auction. Apparently, he hadn't been satisfied with the first sale.

Anyway, as a result, I left him some negative feedback. In response, he left me a negative saying I "wasn't very forgiving..."

So, it appears that leaving positives will probably get positives in response - or maybe no response at all - and negatives will generate negative responses. Overall, it would seem to negate any values in judging sellers (or buyers) by their feedback.

Jim D.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#13

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Frank G ( Ingleside Texas )

>I have never had a seller leave feedback for me untill I had left possitive feedback for them. One time the seller left feedback that I didn't pay or contact them. I responded that I paid and had item in hand. No response. Whoever leaves the last feedback wins.

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

#14

Re: OT - Questionable eBay ratings

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I stopped using ebay about seven years ago. Many reasons why, one of which is the lack of ebay cleaning up their business. Sorry if I affend anyone who support ebay.

Kevin