Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Plate joiner

Posts

Plate joiner

#1

Plate joiner

Tom Dunlap

>If I'm lucky I might be able to get a plate joiner at Lowe's while the sale is on. The catch is...which one?

Before I started I did some searching but couldn't find any thread about preferences. The PC seems to get high praise. What about DW? Is a more expensive unit worth the price or is a less expensive one a good value?

Thanks for the help.

Re: Plate joiner

#2

Re: Plate joiner

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Between the DeWalt and the Porter Cable...I'd get whichever was in stock and qualified for the sale price.(read-cheaper) IIRC there was a patent infringment suit between the two so they must be pretty similar. I'm sure they will both provide good service. Others may have a preference and may chime in. Stay tuned.JR

Re: Plate joiner

#3

Re: Plate joiner

Glenn Madsen on the road from SF Bay area

>The PC will do a smaller FF biscuit that the DeWalt doesn't do. If you want to biscuit face frames narrower than about 1.75", then you want the Porter Cable. This requires changing the cutter wheel, and I don't know if the smaller cutter is an extra cost, buy-it-seperately item. I'd probably lose it anyway.

I have the DeWalt, and think that, for my purposes, it is an entirely adequate machine. My neighbor, an inveterate tool collector and occaisional user, has also a Ryobi, which does 'mini-biscuits'. He's offered, but I've never seen the need. I use pocket screws for most of the 'smaller-than-zero' applications.

My DeWalt has served well for 5 years or more, but fewer than 2000 biscuits have been used.

Re: Plate joiner

#4

Re: Plate joiner

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Tom,

I have had a DeWalt for years, and my #3 son uses a P+C professionally. Both are very fine tools, and the theoretical edge may go towards the Porter+Cable's more versitile fence. Frankly, I don't use mine nearly as much as the original HYPE suggested. I don't believe that biscuits add strength to the joint, as the modern glues are as strong, long grain to long grain, as the wood itself. I am not so sure there is much aid in alignment of boards--perhaps some. I do use them when mitering corners as in a mirror frame. Most of my work is at 90 degree fence setting and any brand can do that. The next time I buy one (which is probably never )I'll get a less expensive machine.

George

Re: Plate joiner

#5

Re: Plate joiner

John Ross

>Tom, like many of the guys have already posted, I got caught up in the hype of the biscuit jointer and purchased a PC. It has been a good tool, but not used nearly as frequently as I thought I would use it. I picked-up my Festool Domino on Friday, and it will replace my Kreg Jig and my plate jointer. I ran it through some tests and built some strong shelves and frames this weekend. I would suggest that you wait, I think a lot of Domino users are going to get rid of their plate jointers. Just my two cents, but the PC plate/biscuit jointer is nice.-JohninRI

Re: Plate joiner

#6

Re: Plate joiner

MountainMan

>Craig - I don't know too much about the domino - only pictures and text - I don't understand how it would replace a Kreg Jig?

Regards

The MountainMan

Re: Plate joiner

#7

Re: Plate joiner

Barry Irby

>I have the PC version and I like it, but I don't use it as much as I thought I would. I use it more as an "alignment" tool than anything else and I am not sure it adds a lot of strenght to edge joints. Its a fine, well made tool, I'm just not sure the concept holds up.

I'm watching the Domino also. Not ready to spend he money for another concept tool. I'll be waiting for some long term reviews and maybe a price cut.

Re: Plate joiner

#8

Re: Plate joiner

David Hay @ Denver

>I've had the DeWalt biscuit joiner for a few years now. I don't use it that often, but when I do, it's worked just fine. It was great for making the joinery for the built in cabinets I made for our family room.

David

Re: Plate joiner

#9

Re: Plate joiner

JohninRI

>Hello Mountain Man,

I use my Kreg usually for joining face frames, or building plywood boxes. The Domino will do both of these faster and stronger from some backwoods experimentation that I did this weekend. For example, the Kreg requires that I drill a pocket, and then drive a screw. To obtain a clean look, I then have to insert a wood plug. The domino does this with one action, like a biscuit, but with the strength of a floating tenon and with clean wood faces. It doesn't seem to be as strong as a true mortise and tenon, so my mortiser is safe, but it held my weight better than the biscuit. There are a lot of videos online of the thing, and Woodcraft has been demonstrating them here in RI. For a part time wood butcher like me, it really seems to be fast and accurate.

John in RI

Re: Plate joiner

#10

Re: Plate joiner

Jesse in New Mexico

>Another angle on the Domino introduction, a lot of us who bought the Domino are selling our plate joiners - I did. Take a look on Craigslist or other local shopping venues for a real bargain!!

Re: Plate joiner

#11

Re: Plate joiner

Tom Dunlap

>Wow! I go to the shop and get some work done and now I have to make another decision...

Thanks for the input! Hmmm...buy a Domino or pick up a used plater...time to check with Craig!

The joy of the day to you all!

Tom