Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

I managed to get

Posts

I managed to get

#1

I managed to get

Don Henthorn

>my English made Stanley #80 scraper into pretty decent condition but the blade is pitted and I must get a new one. I can get a Hock for $26.00 plus shipping or I can get an 18" bar of 01 2" X 3/32" steel from EMC that would make nine blades for $18.40 plus shipping. The old blade is 1/16" thick; the hock is supposed to be thicker but I don't know how much thicker. The 3/32" would be half again as thick as the old blade and should be enough to cut down on chatter. $26.00 for a two inch square of steel seems a mite expensive to me. I think I will go with the bar. What do you think?

Re: I managed to get

#2

Hock and Bar Stock

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Don,

I bet you can grind down that bar stock pretty well and not have to go in Hock for too much. Nothing against Hock products, but by comparison your proposal sounds a better value. I dealt with bar stock in other ways, in my younger Air Force days, a bottle at a time. :<)

George

Re: I managed to get

#3

Re: I managed to get

Jerry Nicholson

>The replacement blade for the Lee Valley cabinet scraper is $4.50. Works just fine in my #80.

Jerry

Re: I managed to get

#4

Re: I managed to get

Ted Wong

>what does emc stand for?

Re: I managed to get

#5

JL

Re: I managed to get

JL

>That sounds like a good deal. Question - how do you cut it? I've got the usual cutters for wood. The only thing I have for steel is a hacksaw and the metal blades for my jigsaw and reciprocating saw.

Re: I managed to get

#6

Four words for you

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>"Dremel" and "Abrasive cutting wheel". They'll do number on that stuff. May take a while. But they'll cut it just fine.

Dominic

Re: I managed to get

#7

Re: I managed to get

Don Henthorn

>Tthanks, Jerry. I looked on line cut couldn't find it.

Re: I managed to get

#8

Re: I managed to get

Don Henthorn

>Ted, EMC is a supply house.

JL, cutting is easy with a hack saw. I made three scraping chisels from 3/8" flat bar and cut everything including the tangs with a hack saw. Just has to be done before you harden it.

Re: I managed to get

#10

hardening?

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>I presume the O1 is not hardened, or at least you should hope not. In the annealed state it is easy to cut with a hack saw and it can be shaped with a file or grinder. When sawing don't get it hot or it may work harden and then suddenly the teeth of what is cutting it will be no more.

so after it is shaped it must be hardened and then tempered to appropriate hardness, what ever that would be for a scraper, low 50's? If you hire this done it is way cheap if you are doing several pieces, like about $50/batch.

While you are into it make some chisels.

Re: I managed to get

#11

Re: I managed to get

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I understand that some people can't afford Hock blades, but I have always thought his work was well worth it. As was mentioned, a cabinet scraper is not just a piece of bar steel; it is also hardened and tempered. I put a Hock iron in my 112 and am well pleased with the quality of it. A couple of thoughts here; one is you probably don't need 9 scraper blades; two, you are only spending something like $8 less if you buy the bar and make your own. Is the extra futzing around for cutting the blades and hardening and tempering really worth it? Hardening and tempering in itself could be worth it if you are interested in learning how to do that.

Re: I managed to get

#12

Re: I managed to get

Paul Woolson

>The latest issue of WoodSmith has an article about making brass planes. More to the point, it talked about hardening the iron by heating and cooling it in vegitable oil. Might be worth looking into.

Re: I managed to get

#13

Thanks. all, for your responses.

Don Henthorn

>I miscalculated the size of the scraper blade: it is 2" X 2 3/4" so I will only be able to get 6 and a half blades from an 18" bar. By sharpening both edges I will have twelve edges to dull before I need to re-hone all of them. Oil hardening and tempering is something I have done a number of times before with excellent results. I have been well pleased with these lathe scrapers I made.


They really hold an edge well for carbon steel and the price was right. Moses, you are presently working and can afford to pay a high price for a tool that will make you money. No one will hire an 87 year old so I have to make do with what pennies I can scrap together. I may even take part of that bar and make a plane blade for one of my old planes that rusted after being immersed in water during my move.(G)

Re: I managed to get

#14

Re: 87, eh?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I hope I will be making scraper blades when I am 87. With the diet my wife has put me on I am pretty sure though that I will die young ;)