Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Exotics vs Composites for decking

Posts

Exotics vs Composites for decking

#1

Exotics vs Composites for decking

Mike Brazeau

>Our daughter and son-in-law are in the midst of making final decisions on an elevated deck on their new home. While investigating composites, one retailer brought up Tiger Wood and Ipe as alternatives and they are apparently comparatively priced. Ipe or Pau Lope I am aware of. Tiger Wood is a new one. Anyone out there with any experience in terms of weathering effects on the exotics? I know Ipe will weather to a gray just as Teak does. There seem to be UV resistant oil finishes as well for use on exotics. Appreciate any feedback of all sorts on composites or these exotics.

Mike

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#2

Bart Goldberg

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

Bart Goldberg

>Mike,

I think either option is fine - its more a matter of personal taste then one of functional advantages. The composites will require less maintenance, but will not look as nice as a properly maintained hardwood deck. I have neighbors that have replaced their decks will several different types of material: composites, Ipe, and one you didn't mention - Brazilian Rosewood. I really like the look of Ipe and Rosewood after they have been cleaned and sealed with an oil finish - but they do require annual sanding and sealer reapplication to keep them looking nice. In either case, hidden fasteners is a must.

Bart

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#3

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

John in New Mexico

>Never worked with composites, so can't help you there.

Tigerwood has more color variation than ipe from the samples I've seen. Personally I like the ipe better. We keep ours oiled, prefering the brown look to grey, but it won't hurt it to turn grey. The one thing about ipe (an most other exotics I suspect) is its a real pita to cut with anything but carbide (like a jigsaw), so things like curves are very hard to get smooth. We drilled and plugged ours, but that fits in with the look in our case, works fine, bit of extra labor but saves you about $1 per lf if that makes any difference.

John

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#4

Ellis Walentine

Composites are less expensive

Ellis Walentine

>...at least they were when we were looking to replace the decking on our veranda last spring. Being on a budget, we were originally shopping for composite decking, but we ended up with ipe. (Hey, as a wood guy, how could I put plastic on my back porch?) The yard we dealt with represented about half a dozen brands of composite decking, along with ipe, so we were able to comparison shop. The 5/4 x 6 ipe we bought was around $3 per lineal foot compared to half to two-thirds that amount for the various composite materials. Plus, to preserve the appearance, we bought these special little biscuit-shaped "Eb-Ty" fasteners and stainless screws. Those were really pricey, adding at least a buck a square foot to the installed price.

I wish I knew of a good finish for ipe decking. We ended up using Cabot's "Australian Timber Oil," a soya-alkyd finish that looks great but takes days to dry. Now, a year later, the finish has worn off the areas that are not protected by a roof or overhang. I don't particularly want the weathered look, so I plan to re-oil the deck as often as necessary to keep it looking warm and new.

The upshot is that ipe (I don't know a thing about "tigerwood") costs more up front, is harder to install and requires periodic maintenance if you want the wood color to remain. On the other hand, it is hard as a rock, looks great and was worth the extra cost and effort, at least in my opinion.

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#5

Re: Composites are less expensive

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I agree with Ellis on the looks of Ipe. That is what I have on my back deck. When I bought mine, for delivery here in AZ, the best price I found was from a place in Austin, TX, I believe that it is called Austin Hardwoods. There was a good price from a place in Buffalo, NY but the freight was a killer to AZ.

Howard

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#6

Austin wholesale decking supply

John in New Mexico

>It was cheaper for us to drive there and pick it up than have it shipped, but we're only 12 hours away!

Funny thing though, shipping was about the same from Austin as from the place in NY. Maybe $50 less, but close, and about twice the cost of gas for our little pickup.

Anyway, those guys were a great source, and they have "4x4" post material if you need it - actually 3 3/8 square, but you know how that goes!

John

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#7

Re: Composites are less expensive

Chuck Lenz

>I haven't seen or tried IPE or any other exotic hardwood as a decking material. But I have had experience with TREX a couple of times building decks for customers. The only downside to any composite deck that I know of is composites cannot be used structurally. I personally like TREX alot and I think anyone that can afford the initial investment of the materials should look into it. I have heard alot of good about IPE also. If your looking for the natural grain that it has to offer then you will probably want to go with IPE. But in this day and age people are looking for low to no maintainice. They probably both look good. So I'd say it's a personal choice of looks and if you have the time or money to maintain the hardwood every so often. This is a TREX deck I designed and built for a customer useing powder coated aluminum spindles. I put this deck up about 5 years ago and eveytime I see the customer he mentions how happy he is with it.


img

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#8

Re: Composites are less expensive

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>My house is a hand fitted log house so anytime that you put the composites up next to real logs they look like s**t. At least IMHO.

Howard

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#9

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

Art Liebeskind

>Hi Bart,

Do yopu really mean Brazilian ROSEWOOD at $100 per board foot? Maybe Braz cherry or Jatoba

Art Liebeskind

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#10

Doug in Seattle

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

Doug in Seattle

>I priced Ipe, tight knot cedar, Trex and some other brands of man-made decking at just a few dollars difference for a 10 X 20 deck a few years ago. Went with Ipe for the decking and clear cedar for the railings. Ipe is tough to work with as mentioned. Prior to installation I belt sanded the mill marks off both sides and rounded all four edges with a round-over router bit. Then applied a coat of Penofin at the suggestion of Teri Masaschi (from whom I took a week long finishing class). Penofin is a 99% U.V. protection Brazilian Rosewood oil. It does come in a lower percentage for a few bucks a can less. Installed the decking with stainless steel screws after predrilling and waxing the screws. Out of 1,000 screws I did not break a one but bent a few. Following installation, I reoiled. The following year cleaned off the moss/mold/gunk (this is Seattle afterall), touch-up sanded everything and reoiled. Every year after that I just reoil. Brush or roll on a coat in a small area and then wipe off the excess like any other oil finish. My 10 X 20 deck takes just a couple of hours. No real need to sand. Teri said there is no such thing as a one time only finish application for a deck or, a maintenance free deck. Afterall, we do wax all our fine furniture several times a year.

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#11

I built a composite deck...

ScottS

>I built a composite deck two years ago... and I wouldn't do it again! I used Trex Brasilia, it's the stuff that kinda looks like wood... for the first 10 or 15 minutes you see it... if you squint. My deck is at ground level and about 300 sq. ft. I used pressure-treated lumber for the underpinnings. Trex said joists could be placed 16" on center; I went with 12". I used Eb-Ty hidden fasteners to hold the deck boards in place and TrapEase screws where necessary. Most of the deck boards are the "burnished amber" color, with "cayenne" used for accents, fascia boards, etc.

The deck looked pretty good when new, but two years on... and I'm wishing I'd gone with Ipe, Meranti, or another exotic. The surface of the Brasilia seems to be only 2 or 3 molecules thick and scratches easily. Scratches are very noticable, because the interior of the boards look nothing like the exterior. The decking stains easily and almost anything you do to clean it will discolor or ruin the surface of the boards. Olympic Premium Deck Cleaner does do a good job of cleaning if applied very sparingly (I apply a fine mist with a pressurized garden sprayer); apply too much and you'll discolor the Trex. When clean the decking looks pretty good, though you wouldn't mistake it for wood. The Burnished Amber color is the more realistic of the two; the Cayenne looks fairly unnatural to me. When it's dirty, which is most of the time thanks to my dogs, I find that it looks amazingly artificial. I thought spacing joists 12" on center was going to be overkill, but in the end I was glad I did it; I've seen wet noodles that were less flexible than Trex! Carrying a 20' board by yourself requires grabbing it in the middle and holding your hands straight up in the air; if you're lucky the ends won't sag enough to touch the ground. I swear there are some areas where I can see sagging between the joists, but everyone tells me I'm imagining it.

Other than the frequent cleanings, the deck seems to be relatively trouble-free. You may hear that it gets hot in direct sun, but I haven't found that to be the case. The Trex decking might be slightly hotter than the wood decking it replaced, but it's not bad. I have one fascia board that seems to be delaminating along the top edge; not sure why and it's the only one I've had any trouble with. Eb-Ty fasteners were a bit finicky at first, but once I got used to them it went pretty quickly. The downside to them, and probably any hidden fastener, is that all of the boards are inter-locked. So if you need to repair/replace a board in the middle of the deck... things get interesting. Seeing how scratch-prone the Trex Brasilia seems to be, I almost wish I'd used screws rather than the Eb-Ty fasteners. The TrapEase screws matched the decking very well and worked exactly as advertised.

Re: Exotics vs Composites for decking

#12

Thanks everyone

Mike Brazeau

>Well all of you have certainly given lots of food for thought and some comments that I did not expect. They have been following the thread and now it is time to do some digesting and make some decisons. Thanks to all for your input.

Mike