Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Band SAw motor question?

Posts

Band SAw motor question?

#1

Band SAw motor question?

Barry Irby

>I have a Delta 14" bandsaw with riser block and whatever motor came on it (3/4hp?) I have a 2hp motor stashed that has the mounting that envolves bolting something to the end of the motor, not the backet on the side like on the BS.

The qusetions are can I make or have made a bracket that would allow me to easily mount the motor on the BS? Would upgrading to 2hp be a significant enough improvement to make this worthwhile.?

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#2

Re: Band SAw motor question?

Paul Waddle

>Sure would be a fine idea.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#3

Re: Band SAw motor question?

Tom MacGregor

>Frame sizes are standard, and I've seen bolt or strap on frames that attach to the side of a motor body. I'd check around for a pre-made mount before having one made. If the plate on the BS motor lists a frame size send me that and the OD of the 2hp. motor. I've got several boxes of motor parts & will see if I have something that might work.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#4

Re: Band SAw motor question?

Barry Irby

>The motor on the machine is a 3/4 hp 1725 RPM with a 56 frame and the motor is 5 5/8" in diameter.

The "new" motor is a Dayton Model 5K470C, 2 HP 3450 RPM, with a 56C frame and it is 6 1/6" in diamter.

The existing mount appears to be a stamped steel cradle tack welded to the motor. The new motor jsut has four approximately symetrically palces threaded holes in the end. So Ineed some sort of cradle.

I did not realized the existing moter was a 1725 RPM and the new one was a 3450. I guess this will give me and oppoertunity to change the pullies and adjust the speed of the bandsaw blade. Anybody got any advice on that?

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#5

Adjusting bandsaw blade speed the pulley way

wilbur

>I just tweaked my bandsaw blade speed this this week with my bandsaw. There's a formula to calculate the bandsaw blade speed in surface feet per minute (SFPM) based on the RPM of the motor, the motor pulley diameter, the bandsaw pulley diameter, and the bandsaw wheel diameter:

(Motor RPM) x (motor pulley diameter) / (bandsaw pulley diameter) x (bandsaw wheel diameter) x 3.1416 / 12 = SFPM

How fast your SFPM will depend on your blade. Suffolk Machinery recommends a SFPM of 2400-3300 for a 14" bandsaw for their Timberwolf blades. 3000 SFPM for a 14" bandsaw is pretty standard.

If you mount your new 2 hp 3450 RPM motor, and aim for a speed of 3200 SPFM, a motor pulley to bandsaw pulley ratio of 1:2 will put you pretty close. Getting the largest bandsaw pulleys you can that will give you that ratio will also help make your bandsaw run smoother. In other words, a 2" / 4" pulley combination will run your bandsaw blade at the same speed as a 4" / 8" combination, but the 4" / 8" combination will run smoother overall.

One last thing -- use the datum diameter of the pulley wheels for these calculations if possible. The outer diameter can be used in a pinch, but the datum diameter will give you the most accurate results in calculating your bandsaw blade speed.

Let me know f you need any more help.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#6

If the motor RPMs are the same you're cool

Forrest Addy

>If the motor RPMs are the same you're cool. If the replacement motor is 3450 RPM and the existing motor in 1750 then you'll have to change the pulley ratio. Changing the pulleys is sometimes expensive ($50) to do.

Motors come in standard frame numbers. All motors with the same frame will have the same mounting dimensions and in some of the smaller frames the base flange will be universal, that is punched with a variety of bolt patterns allowing the interchange of motors over a HP range in the same equipment.

The 2 HP replacement motor may have a 56 frame or 182 or 184 frame while your 3/4 HP might be a 56 frame. Both will likely bolt directly on your saw's existing motor mount. The 2 HP may be longer which may be a problem if you have an enclosed cabinet.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Adjusting bandsaw blade speed the pulley way

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Wilbur,

By my calculations, your 1:2 ratio will result in a blade speed of 6322 feet per minute on a 14" saw. WAY TOO FAST!

I have a 3450 rpm (1.5 hp) motor on my saw, with a 2" motor sheave (pulley) and an 8" driven sheave. That gives me about 3150 feet per minute blade speed, which is pretty close to the generally recommended 3000 fpm.

Jim D.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#8

Re: If the motor RPMs are the same you're cool

Barry Irby

>Forrest, The Larger 2 hp motor has the mounts that are four threaded holes in the end of the housing. I think it was a water pump motor that my Dad left behind and it has never been used. It would mount solidly from the end, but has no "feet" or bracket on the side. Basically a cylinder with four holes in the end. The old motor was 1725 and the new one is 3450. Clearly I need to change the pulleys. I was wondering if it it made sense to up the speed a bit. I believe Louis Ittura discusses it.

Thanks for the help. I am realizing this means changing the pulleys and the switch and probably going to 240 volts. This free motor is not so cheap.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#9

Stupid me -- 1:4 ratio, not 1:2

wilbur

>Ack! Stupid stupid stupid me!!!!!!

Had a real brain fart there. Sorry, and thanks, Jim, for catching that.

The ratio should be 1:4 for a 3450 RPM motor to give a 3160 SFPM on a 14" bandsaw, which jives with Jim's 2" / 8" setup

Sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry sorry.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#10

What you jave there is a Cface motor, probably a

Forrest Addy

>What you jave there is a Cface motor, probably a 56-C designation in the label plate field for "frame". It's a PITA to use on your bandsaw as it is without some metalwork and new pulleys. The motor rus at double the RPM of the existing motor, much more that a "little" faster.

You will definitely have to change the pulley ratio. The next questions are: are the shafts the same size and how do you mount it on your bandsaw? If the shafts are the same size you may be able to swap the existing motor on the replacement motor but you WILL have to find a band wheel shaft pulley double the size of the existing one and a longer belt.

No, you cann't halve the motor pulley diameter even though it's a lot cheaper to do so. The much more poweerful replacement motor will most likely smoke the belt if you do. A half-sized motor pulley will be too small for the HP transmission, the belt will surely slip on any kind of load.

And yes, a 2 HP motor's full load Amps is over the rated capacity of a 15 Amp wall outlet. So you either cheat or got with a 230 outlet. If you plan on doing much re-sawing, you'll probably be happier with 230.

Getting down to the C face. If you're metalwork challenged there no reason you cant mount the C face to a hunk of stout plywood and attach that to your bandsaw with a means of adjustment. If you or somone who owes you a favor can do metalwork, you can order a base flange from the motor manufacturer. Then open the motor and carefully select your place so you don't fry anything criticala in the motor. Attach the add-on flange to the motor case with four stout tack welds. Reassemble and paint. If you locate the motor base flange on the case in accordance with the NEMA motor base diagram standard dimensions the replacement motor will fit in the same place as the old.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#11

Re: What you jave there is a Cface motor, probably

Barry Irby

>Thanks Forrest. It is indeed a Cface motor. The one on the saw now is a 56 and this one a 56C. I know nothing about this designation system, but it strikes me as peculiar that two mounts that are so fundamentally different have such similar designations.

So now, I am down to three things. Finding out if I can get a "56" base or cradle that will fit this motor and have it tack welded on.

(or making a suitable home made mount thing sort of cobbled together)

Buying a larger pulley for the lower wheel on the band saw. Every solution has its problems. That means I will not be able to use the existing belt guard. Oh well, Real Men don't use belt guards anyway.

And buying and installing a new switch and wiring for the saw. I was thinking orf adding an outlet in the 230 circuit for my TS. I almost never use the TS and BS at the same time, so that should not create a conflict and if it did it would just trip the breaker.

Thanks for the lesson on the pulleys. I would have been approaching it on an intuitive level and my gut would have told me I should go to a larger pulley on the driven shaft and not a smaller one on the motor shaft, but my wallet may have voted for a smaller one rather than a larger one. Thanks. I am still wondering about increasing the blade speed. Maybe to 3500 or 4000 fps.

Re: Band SAw motor question?

#12

Re: Band SAw motor question?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Barry

I recently replaced the 3/4 hp motor of my Carbatec BS1400 (same as Rigid BS1400) with a 1 1/2 hp, both running at 1420 rpm. Running a 6" riser kit, previously the bandsaw really struggled with the local hardwood. Now it slices through this with relative ease. Definitely a worthwhile upgrade.

Now I am goind to turn the old 3/4 hp motor into a slow grinder and sharpening centre!

Regards from Perth

Derek