Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Veneer question

Posts

Veneer question

#1

Veneer question

Ted Wong

>I have a student that wants to veneer a hollow core door slab. It's half of a bi-fold door and measures 12" wide x 80" long. The slab is typical hollow core construction. 1/8" door skins sandwiching corrugated web and solid 1" edge all the way around.

I'm not sure if she should veneer both sides of the slab or if she can get by with doing only one side with no ill effects. She plans on using formaldehyde resin glue and will be clamping in a vacuum press.

Re: Veneer question

#2

Lee Grindinger

I've always wanted to do that

Lee Grindinger

>I've always wanted to stick a hollow core door into a vacuum press just to see it collapse. If you and your student proceed by all means take pictures and post them here.

Ted, it won't work. There is no way a hollow core door can present a flat face under vacuum. Assuming it doesn't collapse altogether the thin skin will ripple between the cardboard ribs so badly the veneer won't lay flat.

But, if you try it please let me know if the thing coming out of the bag resembles a door at all. I've thought about trying it in my press but feared for the safety of the bag when the skin collapses and splinters which is my guess about the outcome.

I'd say the best option for veneering a hollow core door is (gasp) contact cement. With the give of the thin skin between the cardboard ribs there is just no way to exert even pressure with either vacuum or clamps and cauls.

Lee

Lee

Re: Veneer question

#3

Ellis Walentine

We had a discussion about this a couple weeks ago.

Ellis Walentine

>...although it was not in connection with a hollow core door. I guess you could argue that the corrugated core effectively isolates one skin from the other, but my rule of thumb still holds: warping will occur if one side is subject to forces that the other side isn't. If this veneer shrinks or expands, it will want to cup the door accordingly. Without a balancing force on the other side, there's nothing to stop it. If your student is concerned with cost, have her use a cheaper veneer on the other side.

Another toss-up question here is how well the hollow core will stand up to the pressure of the vacuum bag. I'd try some dry runs to see what happens before you go to all the trouble and find out that the center collapses or something. Also, plastic resin glue relies on intimate contact between veneer and substrate, and I'm trying to imagine how this will play out under these circumstances.

Please let us know how you handle it and the results.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Veneer question

#4

Re: I've always wanted to do that

Ted Wong

>Well I haven't done a door before. But I have done similar types of hollow core construction with some corrugated webbing material that Vacuum pressing systems sells. It didn't exactly implode in the press but there was a slight depression in the center of the panel. Probably because I didn't use cauls. This time I plan to use a sheet of 3/4" material on top of the veneer.

I would probably suggest contact cement to her if she were using paper backed veneer but I'm really hesitant to bring it up because she is using raw veneer that has been jointed.

If I don't get any feedback about the one sided veneer issue I'll probably run out and get a set of Bi-folds myself and see if it works.

Re: Veneer question

#5

Re: Veneer question

Tom Stockton

>Ted,

I've had forms implode in a vacuum press it's pretty interesting. I think a hollow core door would do the same but maybe the coragated interior would hold it together. They do sell honeycomb material for vacumpressing to make large flat surfaces lighter. I'm with Lee I would go with contact cement and good qaulity paper backed veneer, although I hate both products.

For some reason the paper backed stuff works OK with contact cement.

Tom

Re: Veneer question

#6

I forgot

Tom Stockton

>If I were doing it for a client I would definatly do both sides, my own house I would be willing to try just one side as an experiment.

Tom

Re: Veneer question

#7

Re: Veneer question

Howard

>Ted:

You may also want to post this question in a veneering forum:

http://www.vacupress.com/forum

Howard

Re: Veneer question

#8

Re: I've always wanted to do that

Bob Fawcett

>Lets 12x80 = 960 square inches.

Atmospheric pressure is about 15 psi

960 x 10 = 9,600 pounds pressure on the hollow door.

I think Lee is right.

Maybe if you could regulate the vacuum to only about 1-2".

Re: Veneer question

#9

Re: Veneer question

Keith Newton

>Ted, Here are a few suggestions. Nothing says that you have to pull a full vacuum. You can T off of your line, and put in a ball valve that you leave slightly open, If you use a gauge to monitor, you can control how many inches of Hg. it draws.

As for as the concern of dipping in between core septum, I don't think that is likely if you use a thick enough platen.

Re: Veneer question

#10

slap it between some 3/4" plattens.

Ed Snow

>drop your vacuum down to 15 inches and you ought be alright.