Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Posts

Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#1

Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have some friends who are metalsmiths. They were contacted by a company that has jewelry stores (high end) around the world. The company representative asked my friends if they would design a metal jewelry cabinet for them and then sell them the design so they could make many copies of it for their stores.

They are artists and have never sold any of their designs. But if the price were right they would consider it. They want to know how one would go about pricing a design? Apparently this is not a royalty contract. From what I was told it is a one time, lump sum sale of the design and the company would then own the rights to the design.

So any ideas? I told my friends I would ask here and see if anyone in the wood world had any wisdom in this area. Thanks

Tom

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#2

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Tommy,

Would they be building the first one of the design, or just doing the design (drawing)? Also, I would ensure that only the total concept is being sold, not individual aspects of the design.

Me personally, assuming this company is going to have a bunch of copies made, and I had to make the first one, I would charge 2-3 times what I would have asked if they were just going to have me make one.

Just my opinion. No experience in these matters.

Mark

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#3

JL

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

JL

>I hate to say it, but contact a lawyer.

A friend of mine who is a engineer and a machinist sold his design for a particular application. He didn't want to do the royalty thing or get a patent. He is "reasonably" happy with his decision - but there is still that niggling feeling that he could have gotten more.

Of course a lawyer isn't going to be cheap either.

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#4

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm not in that business either, but I had a thought on Mark's post.

If I built and sold one, that would be it. No further changes, liability (well, sorta, but let's set that aside), technical support, etc. If I built a pattern that someone else would use, it becomes an ongoing project. With intermittant demands and cash flow.

There's nothing wrong with that, but the product is different. The customer demands could be significantly different, and stretched over time. How I was set up to do the work, as a piece of the rest of my life, would influence the potential agreement, or non-agreement.

Right now, the chance of getting me to agree to produce anything before I finish what my wife and daughter-in-law have on the list is pretty slim.

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#5

It's done all the time

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Most large company now contract out design services, both product and tooling. They then own the design and everything produced with or from that design. Most of the time it is just an hourly rate to complete the design and any prototypes produced. Having said that my personal opinion is slightly different. If I were in similar circumstance I would calculate the number of hours to complete the design and what it would take to make any prototypes involved. Then I would take a SWAG at how many they are going to produce, figure my royalty fee and add that to my upfront quote, figuring on the high side all the way through the quoting process. If they still wanted me to do it I would feel amply paid for my services, and let them do whatever they wanted from there.

Ray

Addy Protocol: Former Design Manager

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#6

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Pat Evans

>I think if I were selling them the design, I would limit it to their use only in their stores only. You should be entitled to royalties if they sold either the design or the cabinets for profit.

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#7

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I can't answer your question directly, but as a person who sells heavy industrial engineering services (through a corporation) for a living, I have a few comments...

1. Are you selling the artistic arragement (ie. how it looks), how the thing is built, or both? If you are providing info on how to build the thing, or even major dimensions, you are probably taking on some liability for potential future failures...eg. if it tips over and kills some lady's pet poodle, then the company will get sued who will then be required by their insurer to turn around and sue you..the designer.

Take this potential into account when setting your design fee and take action to prevent liability from coming back to you. This might be in the form of disclaimers on the design or explicit exclusions in your contract. At the end of the day you may not be able to protect yourself against this no matter what your contract states. Ensure that your design is well thought out in all aspects, including public safety, longevity, potential mis-use, etc.

Sorry to say that things have come to this point, but unless the benefits exceed the potential liability we do not take on the work. eg. if you do $1000 of engineering work to size a $150 safety relief valve, which ends up failing and burning down a $5,000,000,000 refinery, what is your liability for getting $1000 of fees??? Probably more than a $1000, nevermind the legal fees to defend yourself.

2. Appropriate disclaimers and limitations should accompany the design. May be worth talking to a lawyer about this.

The above is not meant to scare you away, but to remind you to protect yourself (or your friends). You are probably already exposed to these liabilities by selling custom furniture to the public, although at a relatively small scale and most pieces are in private homes not public areas where the fools/square foot increases dramatically.

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

#8

Re: Selling a Design...Legal/Business Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I am surprise that Mark Mandell has not stepped in to this.

Mark