Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Posts

Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#1

Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Gary Smyth

>Stand back as this is a rant. This afternoon with much anticipation I witnessed a (early) preview of the new Festool Domino mortiser in the outward form of a biscuit joiner. Some of you have seen it or pictures of it by now. I can't get over the price! $700.00 bare and accessories are averaging $70. If you go with available packages you can easily spend over a $1000.00. Now I've ranted here before, and I've even been wrong a time or two, but $700.00! Now I must say it works well, is semi-quick, and doesn't seem to vibrate judging by the demonstration (we weren't permitted to use the tool ourselves), but $700 is a lot of money for that tool. In my view if it stood on its cord and recited the Gettysburg Address it wouldn't have a value of $700. There are a lot of things to do and buy for even the most jaded of woodworker for $700, and even though I'm willing to spend a lot more than that on things I deem to have value this seems to me to be way, way, way out of line. I've worked in marketing for many years and I know that the mantra is sell it for what you think people will pay, but $700? Who came up with that number? They must send them over hhere in their own seat by Virgin Air Business Class. Jeez is German engineering worth that much to the American consumer considering the output from that tool for 95% of us? Somebody thinks so. It ain't me! There seems to me to be a myth out there about certain brands of woodworking equipment and this tool is the one that just broke this camel's back. Ya know, I hope I'm wrong and that when this tool gets launched people will think it's the greatest thing since bottled beer. But for now but I'm actually disappointed in Festool. I wanted to have interest in this tool, but for me, all they did was turn me off as a company willing to gouge their customers. How sad. So sad.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#2

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Tom Stockton

>If you compare it in price to the top of the line Lamello biscut joiner I don't think it is that much more expensive. It wasn't that long ago that the only choices in biscut joiners was Lamello and Elu. The lamello was about $600 and the Elu was kinda strange and not as user friendly.

As a professional I think it could be worth every penny and be a real time saver. I don't think it will replace my multi router but it could compliment it.

All that said yes it is a lot of money and I'm still on the fence about buying one. But we used to talk about how ridiculous a multi router was at $1400 and buying a vacuum press for $900 when you could scab on together for a couple hundred. I don't know what I would do with out either, so I guees it is all relative and I bet festool sells a bunch of them because they are the only game in town.

Tom

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#3

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Todd from San Jose

>Gary,

I see it as expensive, as I do their plunge saw, sander and vacuum that I own. But I absolutely see it as worth it.

A friend of mine sold his Multi-router and accessories ($3K) after getting an early Domino- He likes it that much. Another friend has a slot mortiser on his Mini Max combo machine, that now just gathers dust in the corner. Same with his biscuit joiner. How about those that would consider a Leigh FMT? I think that's about the same price as the Domino.

This really is a remarkable tool, and worth every cent, to me. But that's an individual decision. Just like contractor's saw Vs. cabinet saw Vs. Sawstop Vs. euro sliders. You can do everything you want with a contractor's saw, but some opt for the euro slider. Personal preference, the Domino isn't for everyone.

Todd

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#4

FMT

Chad Pearson

>I am still trying to figure out the relative advantages of the Domino vs the FMT. I have the FMT with a dedicated router. All together it costs about the same as the Domino with all accessories.

The Domino looks like it will be better for those instances where you want to put a joint in the middle of a large field (like a shelf if you are too lazy to do a dado into the side of the cabinet).

I think with the Domino it will be harder to do repeating mortices like you can with an FMT (the FMT allows you to set up a fence and repeat an operation in batch fashion...you only need to measure the first joint) The Domino has some semblence of this but it looks limited (the little nubs that let you reference off the end of the board...great if the mortise you want just happens to be on that spot)

The Domino looks like it will be far more portable.

The FMT does not require you to keep buying tenon stock.

The FMT gives you a greater choice of tenon sizes.

I would be interested in the opinions of others.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#5

I'm sure the Domino is a good tool

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>It is entirely possible it is worth the price but perhaps not for an amateur. As I have two router tables, one if the JoinTech and the other is a horizontal table with x,y, and z movements, I have no need for the Domino. It would certainly be quicker and easier to set up than my current system, but everything I have is all paid for! I'd rather replace my Delta contractor saw with a cabinet saw for the $1,000.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#6

Re: FMT

Todd from San Jose

>Hi Chad,

I think they're both good solutions. I've used my friend's FMT, and was thinking about buying it around the time the Domino came out.

To do repeating mortises, they have an accessory called the "Cross Stop," that can handle spacing wider than the pins that are part of the Domino.

I went with the Domino because I've used slot mortisers (ala Felder and Multi-router) before and really like them. The Domino is like a cross between a stationary slot mortiser and a biscuit joiner. A big draw of the Domino over slot mortisers is the reduced set-up time, and the speed at which it cuts. But I think the FMT is a fine tool as well, and perhaps more personal preference like anything.

Todd

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#7

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Ted Wong

>Hey Gary I agree its kind of pricey. But as a question how much do you think its worth? How much is it worth supporting E.U. countries with stronger labor, environmental, social practices as opposed to asian countries where corrupt capitalism runs rampant, workers are abused, the environment gets trashed etc.? Maybe the price would be lower had the tool been manufactured in China but in the long run you and your kids will pay double the price in the negative effects this planet will suffer from the ill effects of trading with countries that don't always play by the same rules.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#8

FMT is made in Canada...

Chad Pearson

>

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#9

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Ray Newman

>I will be the 1st to say that that Fe$Tool are quality tools.

I have their circular saw & dust collector & it excels @ breaking up plyw�d & excellent collecting the dust from the saw. The accuracy of the saw & the guide rail system is amazing.

But I believe that Fe$Tool will eventually price themselves out of the US market. I say this based upon the falling US dollar value compared to the Euro & high cost of doing business in Europe.

For �those in the trade� tool are a tax write off &/or can be offset by passing the cost onto the customer. But for the serious hobbyist, it is hard to justify the cost.

For �zample: I was contemplating purchasing the boom arm to hold the dust collection hose up in the air. I figured that this would keep the power cord & hose out of the way & off the floor. Less for the wheelchair to get tangled up w/.

I priced it out -- boom arm was US$159.00. Then reading further, I found that it required a $62.00 handle for the dust collector vacuum case/body to attach it to. Total was $221.00. Then on 4/1/07, the price is increasing to $293.00 for these items. @ $221.00 + tax, I could possibly justify it; @ $293.00 +, I�ll forego it.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#10

Time = money

wilbur

>I'm not going to be buying a Domino myself, but based on reviews, I can appreciate the usefulness for the potential Domino customer. The main advantage of the Domino is the speed of putting together mortise and tenon joints, even at odd angles, which will make the chair makers happy. Reviews have commented on being able to whack out as many as 32 mortise and tenon joints (one table's worth) in 30 minutes with the Domino.

Whether these things are worth $700-900 is up to you, but I think the key thing is the time savings. At a (probably underestimated) labor rate of $30/hour, and assuming that the Domino saves you 2 hours per project, the Domino pays for itself after making 15 tables or chairs, which is two dining room sets.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#11

Chinese Knockoff

RobV

>Just wait a few months and you'll be able to buy one just like it at Harbor-Freight for 30 bucks or less.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#12

I see no problem

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Gary,

I'm not on the tools daily now, but if I was, I'd buy one. I can see a cost/benefit return in it as a slot mortiser. Far easier to set up this than to set up the slot mortiser, as well as a portable unit. Accurate as all get-go to boot.

The same cost of these items here, incidentally, is AUD1600, approx USD1250-. Additionally, I'm out of pocket approx USD700 if I buy a Festool vacuum that retails at a lot less in the US

I've got a horizontal (slot) mortiser and biscuit cutter, so they'll do me for the moment.

The US market remains a lot cheaper than the rest of the world.

Best regards

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#13

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Charles Self

>"the Elu was kinda strange and not as user friendly."

That is the politest description of an almost unusable POS that I've heard in a long time.

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#14

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Jesse in New Mexico

>I remember a talk Lon Scheinling (sp?) gave where he answered a question about what tool to buy. He said if you are in business, then its simple dollars and cents, if you do woodworking for fun, then buy the one that's fun to use, that will delight you every time you use it.

I'm in it for the fun. No apologies.

That's why I reach for my Lie Nielson plane instead of a perfectly adequate Stanley. That's why I spend the money on Festool. The tools are fun to use and produce great results. I certainly don't buy everything they make, but I'll bet I get $1,000 worth of fun out of the Domino, and if I don't I'm pretty sure I can sell it for close to what I paid for it.

On the other hand,I have succumbed to the lure of cheap cr**, and I do have a couple of Harbor Freight tools. Funny, but I never seem to use them more than once - now that's a waste of money!

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#15

Good perspective- I agree 100%

Todd from San Jose

>

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#16

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Tom Stockton

>It's interesting when you do this for a living the tools aren't nearly as fun because they take on a much more practical approach.

The tools I consider fun would be chainsaws, cutting and splitting firewood is fairly relaxing for me, the cheap flamethrower I got at harbor freight for torching burn piles, and in the shop my lathe which I hardly use for bussiness but is fun to use for litttle projects around the house and shop.

Tom

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#17

Re: Time = money

Tom Stockton

>Just got done watching the cd festool sent me. nice tool very versatile. As for building chairs with it, I would stick with my multi router I think one nice sized floating tenon is going to be stronger than a couple of dominos and probably a little easier.

I think it's like a lot of things that one tool just can't do it all no matter what they tell you, you end up needing a couple of different tools to do the job efficently and strong. I think the trick is to find out what the dominos strong points are and use it for those things. When biscuts started getting popular FWW did an article on building a chair with them which is something I wouldn't even try because I don't think they would hold up over time and from what I've seen they don't take heavy racking very well.

From what i've seen what I think it would be really good at is face frames, carcase construction (although in some cases a biscut joiner would be equal), putting together miterd and butt jointed frames, table construction and looks like a great site tool for people doing on site interior or exterior work.

Tom

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#18

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I've spent the last 15 years of my professional life dedicated to the definition and creation of commercial building control/automation systems that make use of open protocols. When my customers have the ability of going to another company to get product/service if I don't treat them right, it keeps me on my toes and makes me and my company work just that much harder to maintain the relationship.

Conversely, the technology provider that I deal with can never hold me over a barrel - I always have a choice where I spend my money and who's brand name is on the product I use.

I can do this through allegiance to non-proprietary product. I buy where I want to, not where I have to.

So when I see a product like those that Festool make, I cringe. They may be good design, but the instant I spend my money with them, I'm beholden to them for as long as I deem the tool useful to me. I'll pay a premium for the tools, for the parts, for the service and for the accessories. I pay for the "right" to come back to them for more, and frankly, I've got no interest in that.

If Festool can build a customer base on this ancient business practice and get away with it, good for them. But I have zero interest in supporting what I consider to be overpriced highly marketed tools, regardless of their real or perceived "time advantage". I guess I just have an aversion to being grabbed by my short hairs.

Rob

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#19

But one more thing to consider

nailshooter

>I agree with your post, Rob. If they can build it, sell it, market it and be successful, good for them.

But one thing that is missed time and again on this tool is the fact that you have to have chip extraction. Not dust collection, but chip extraction.

*************

>From their website FAQ:

Q: Do I have to use dust extraction?

A: We strongly recommend it. If dust is not extracted, it will clog

the mortise.

*************

Note the word "will"; not "it could" or "it might". It will clog the mortise.

A call to the local Woodcraft where this tool was demoed to the staff revealed that the chip extraction is considered part of the Domino system. According to the Festool rep, dust collector will NOT provide adequate power to clear the chips inside the larger mortise sizes generated when using this machine. His suggestion of course, a high suction Festool or Fein vacuum as a companion purchase, if of course you don't already have one.

This subject was bandied around on the woodworking NG, and others have heard the same advice from the Festool reps. You must have a high volume vac.

So think about portability with the shop vac attached. And your $1000 investment just went up another $400 to complete "the sytem".

Talk about grabbed by the short hairs...

Ouch.

Robert

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#20

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Tom Stockton

>Rob

While I agree with your argument I see one problem with it that is no other company has taken the time and spent the money to create a similar tool. Maybe if the domino is a hit other manufacturers will create similar systems but at this point in time the domino is the only thing on the market like it. Yes they do have a monopoly but it is because they beat everybody to the market and took a risk.

Tom

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#21

Re: But one more thing to consider

Tom Stockton

>I would be willing to bet any shop vac would work. but of course you have to buy a festool to have a complete "system"

Tom

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#22

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

Don in Northern Arizona

>Charles,

I last used mine as a flooring saw and now it gathers dust. May be worth something as an antique in 50 years.

Don

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#23

flame thrower?

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>you can get one of those? I always thought that the perfect snow shovel would be a flame thrower. pointed away from the house of course :)

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#24

Re: flame thrower?

Gary Smyth

>I passed the television the other day and on was an old Lassie show in B&W from the fifties (June Lockhart as Mom). Not a big deal except that the older male guy on the series went to town and rented a (I guess) Korean Conflict surplus flame thrower from the hardware store to clear brush. So he brought it home in a truck, hung it off his back went out to the field, lit it up and and blasted away. Goodbye Mesquite. Ah the good old days! Does anyone know if it was possible to REALLY rent out surplus flame throwers?

Re: Festool Domino Are you ____ me?

#25

For a writer you sure beat around the bush.

Art Silva

>Tell us how you really feel. Art