Design-Clean and Simple or Fancy and Frilly?
Alan Young
>I am wondering what influences design decisions. For example I recently sent out an e-mail to all my musical friends requesting opinions on what types of features would be good to have on a music stand. The ideas I was soliciting were meant to effect the functions of the stand not the artistic look. I included pictures of two stands I had already made.
A shaker influenced design:

and a more elaborate design.

I was surprised when many people responded not with functional ideas but just saying something like.
"I like the shaker stand- clean and simple"
I am working on some big fireplace corbels. The client and I have been discussing the rosettes that are present on the first set versus the second set that has no rosettes.
She has decided that she wants the rosettes removed from the upper sections but kept on the lower. That is fine with me- It is her project after all. But it leads me to wonder what makes something "too much?"
I admit that I tend much towards the "more is better" rather than "less is more" school of design. As a woodworker I am always looking for opportunities to display skill and technique. But that is apparently not the wishes of many end users.
Is there a psychological barrier to design? What sort of things can be implied in a design? ie..does Fancy and Frilly equate to artistic but snobbish taste? Does clean and simple equate to ????
Is there an implied value in something with more or less frill?
I don't know....
Alan



