Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Posts

OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#1

JL

OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

JL

>Okay, the new house has a very c^@##y set of shingles and a very shoddy roof on it. It is going to be replaced.

The LOML would really like a metal roof. So, I am soliciting opinions pros versus cons. I don't really have a preference. We are in the mountains of North GA and there are plenty of metal roofs, so I presume we can find an experienced installer.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#2

Expect to pay.......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>....3 to 4 times more for the metal roof minumum.

Get a reputable installer who knows his schtuff too.

Scott

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#3

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Best quote arond here is $600 square installed for steel. Friend of mine just got a quote.... he is still in recovery.

Ray

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#4

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>It depends on your age I guess. If you are about 40 you can get the metal roof and probably never have to replace it. Shingles are going to need to be replaced in about 20 years if you get some of the best on the market. So if you are about 70, you will probably never need to replace the shingles either ;) If you get much snow make sure you have some sort of heat element to keep the ice dams from building up, while you are replacing the roof anyway. $600 per square installed sounds to me like maybe I should go into the roofing business.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#5

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I've spent a lot of time in northern Georgia and you're right. There are a lot of metal roofs down there. Roofing is not something I know much about but I'd like to make a suggestion.Before making the final decision, ask around and find out how long the metal roofs have been in use and how much maintenance is required. I know that the pole barn method where the screw heads are visible isn't very good because I know of a lot of leaky pole barns. On the other hand, some of the roofs you see in your neck of the woods look like they have been there since most of the traffic out front was horse and buggy. It could be that the metal roof is less expensive in the long run. Also, there are probably more installers down there which could drive the price down a little.

Gotta ask. Are you on the Hiawassee side of the ridge or the Helen side? The part of Georgia I know best is a path along the ridge that continues north for about 2000 miles.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#6

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Charles Self

>Metal roofs are great, but...we replaced our roof not quite two years ago, and wanted metal, but the cost of materials alone was more than double the cost of an installed shingle roof.

You can buy shingles with a 50 year warranty these days, though I have to wonder how long they'll last. Thirty years is fairly common, and those shingles often DO last that long, and longer, if correctly installed.

Metal roofs of the residential variety, on the other hand, may last well over 100 years, well into the range of slate and tile roofing. My cousin's house was built in the 1870s, and has the original roof. It has to be caulked and painted ever seven or eight years, a job that is no longer cheap, but looks good to go for longer than any of us expect to be here (which is the case with our lower cost 30 year roof, too).

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#7

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It depends on the type of metal roof you want. A sheet metal roof like they use on barns and sheds isn't too bad. But a rolled standing seam roof is really expensive. Mine cost 10x what a shingled roof would have cost.

One disadvantage: snow slides off just as soon as the temperature gets above freezing. I end up with huge piles of compacted snow around the buildings. That also is a little hard on any shrubs that are in the way.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#8

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Barry Irby

>I know where three roofs are locally that used the "new" version of metal roofing where they roll the panels out on site with a panel machine. Two schools and a church. The finish was supposed to be baked on and last over twenty years. In each case it is coming off down to the metal in two or three years. Clearly happening on certain panels and not others. The roofs are not "related" because they are different colors and done at different times.

As a Home Inspector, I investigated a metal roof on a doctor's office. It was very complex and as a friend says, "it was leaking everywhere as much as anywhere." I don't envy them getting it straight. Went to a guy that had been doing metal roofing for fifty years, for advice. When I told him it was leaking, his answer was yes, they all do.

Had friend that installed a copper roof (mega bucks). The copper runoff killed all his shrubs.

I personally would like to have a metal roof in spite of all that. If the roof were of a simple design I might give it a shot.

OTOH, locally even top of the line asphalt roofing is much cheaper.

PS. Had a discussion the other day with a fellow inspector. We have pretty much concluded that some of the fifty year shingles are really thirty year shingles that you pay double for. They just wait to see if you live long enough to collect.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#9

Re: Collecting

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Or whether the company is still around in 50 years, or whether, 50 years later, anyone still knows the guaranty was made.

|;-}}

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#10

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Mike Fitterling

>We have metal roofs. On the house we have metal shingles. On the shop and garage we have 5V crimp, which I put on myself. Other than when the hurricane ripped part of our roof off (the roof, not the shingles) we have never had a leak. The shingles are indeed very expensive as we found out doing the hurricane repairs; shingles and their installation alone cost $41,000 (1700 sq foot home, hip roof, each shingle slides together and is screwed down individually). The materials cost for the house shingles was aroudn $210 a square. But the sheet metal (I used Aqualume 5V) was not bad price-wise. I roofed my 24' x 28' shop (regular gable 8/12 pitch) for less than $1000 (I did the labor). I did the stand alone garage I rebuilt after the hurricane with the same 5V stuff.

Now that everything is back and repaired I don't expect to ever replace the roofing again. Even during the hurricane, which sheared our veranda roof away from the house and threw it over the house and into the back yard, there were very few loose shingles laying in the yard; maybe a dozen. The rest stayed put on the severed house parts. (Of course our yard was littered with many regular shingles from the house around us.) The shop would have fared without a scratch except that the house roof hit it on its wild ride. The whole experience sold me on metal roofs as it did for a lot of people around here. There are many more metal roofs around here after Charley.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#11

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

John in New Mexico

>We went with metal, a kind of hybrid locking pro-panel so the screws are concealed under the next panel except at the eave and ridge cap. Cost about twice what a shingle roof would (materials), and I'd bet it took a little extra labor. Standing seams and metal shingles get REALLY pricey. We got a bid for metal shingles that was over $30k for a 2400 sq foot roof.

John

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#12

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Dale Warder

>I live in the upstate of SC. Just installed a metal roof last fall. Cost was about twice that of asphalt shingles. Our last shingle roof was a 30 yr shingle which lasted 12 years in the sun here. The metal roof has a 25 yr warranty for fading of color and a 35 yr warranty for integrity. I never expect to replace the roof again.

The metal roof extends from the ridge to the eve as a single piece of metal, no seams. This roof was installed using neoprene gasketed screws which are also warranted. We are quite happy with it.

My brother has had a metal roof for 25 yrs. No problems yet.

Regards,

Dale

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#13

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

Mark in Michigan

>I had a metal roof put on my house up North 3 years ago and couldn't be happier with it. It was about a third more expensive than shingles at the time. I used a company that brought the machine that actually bends the roll steel into the correct shape, think of it as a U about 15" wide. Each panel (from peak to eave, one piece) overlaps the other on the side so there is nowhere to leak. The only visible screw heads use rubber gaskets and they are on the trim at the ends. Mine has a 50-year finish warranty, but in 50 years who knows where the company will be. Any warranty on shingles will be prorated, it isn't complete replacement. A lot of people ask about the noise and honestly I never noticed a difference from the old shingle roof. I personally like the way snow slides off, it just takes a bit of sun to warm it enough to get a film of water between the roof and the snow and it slides right off.

I am 45 and expect to never touch that roof again, my main goal when I had it put on.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#14

and the fine print says....

Geoff in Madison

>and in most cases the fine print of those warranties spells out that they are for color fastness or some other trivial aspect and is for replacement materials only (prorated), not the labor to get them installed.

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#15

JL

Re: Thanks all

JL

>

Re: OT - Roofs... Metal versus shingles

#16

JL

Re: OT - Roofs... Near Young Harris

JL

>