Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Posts

Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#1

Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Rich S

>Hello all..I wold like to hear your opionions on the Meber (Laguna Tools) LT16 bandsaw. I have an opportunity to purchase an older used unit that is in really nice shape for a good price...I'm debating whether or not this is a step up or not from the current "large" bandsaw I own which is a Jet 18" with Carter guides....when setup right with top notch blades the Jet cuts great, but I'm not entirely happy with the fence system on it..and while the motor is adequate, it still is only 1.5hp....I've resawn mahogany and red oak with the Jet just fine, so I'm not certain if the Meber is a step up in quality from the Jet 18 or simply a lateral shift....the most obvious thing I noticed right away is that the Meber has a foot brake, whereas my Jet doesn't and that the motor on the Meber I'm looking at buying is 2.5hp..plus the Meber has two dust ports, whereas my Jet has only one....curious to hear from others who have a Laguna or who have been comparison shopping closely...

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#2

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Rob Sandow

>I believe the saw you are looking at was sold by Laguna as the LT16SEC (SEC stood for Special Edition Carter) for the Carter guides that were included instead of the standard Euro guides. The use of the Carter guides allowed for some extra resaw capacity over the standard 9" on the LT16. The other things differentiating the SEC version from the base version were the 2 1/2 HP motor (the base version had 1 1/2, and the foot brake. Laguna changed to a different manufacturer for their entry level saws about 5 years ago, and they are not the same.

I know so much about this because in 1999 I needed a band saw and wanted to spend about $1000. The two saws I looked at were the base LT16 and the Jet 18". The only thing the Jet had over the Meber was the extra capacity. In every other way the Meber looked better. Heavier gauge steel, beefier guides, etc.

Jet built that saw to be the biggest machine they could make in an "entry level" Euro-style saw. The Meber is the best machine they could make for the price, but some sacrifice in capacity is the result. I've been very happy with my Laguna/Meber and would recommend the upgrade. But remember, both saws originally retailed for about the same amount. Your LT16SEC sold for about $1200, I think, while the Jet was about $1000. So don't overpay and make sure you get some decent coin for the Jet.

Rob

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#3

I have the Jet and would...

Jim Rahbe, Bedford, TX

>Rich,

I currently own the Jet 18� bandsaw and I think your description of � adequate� just about sums it up. Not good enough to buy again, but not bad enough to sell�

My main complaint is the lack of power. I find the fence and dust collection to be just fine. I do notice that Jet now has added a newer version of the 18� with a 3 HP motor.

My suggestion would be to buy the LT16, take it home and run them side-by-side. Sell the one you like the least. Or better yet, keep one for re-sawing and one for other cuts.

Jim R.

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#4

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I once had the Meber (LT16 SEC) and in my opinion it would not be a significant upgrade. The Meber had a fair amount of play in the riser. The table adjustments were light duty and I had difficulty keeping the table adjusted well. The fence was cast iron but small.

Those were my observations. I traded up to Laguna's 16HD. It is an ACM saw, not a Meber. World of difference IMO.

Maybe rather than investing in a minor upgrade you'd be better off saving a little more money and investing in a saw that will be a more significant improvement.

2 cents.

Tom

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#5

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Nick Tuzzolino

>About 6 years ago I actually compared the Laguna LT16 and the Jet 18" side by side at a wood show in So Calif. No contest! The Laguna is beefier, superior table, two dust ports, etc. I bought the Laguna and couldn't be happier (unless I had the Laguna 18 or 20, of course.) Go for it. Good luck. Nick

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#6

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I looked at the Laguna at the Woodworking show a couple years ago. Don't know what model was on display. However I also looked at the Minimax MM-16. After looking at the demonstrations and the saws construction, I decided not to purchase a Laguna. There are a couple reviews you may want to look at: http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/mm16bs.pdf &

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=reviews&file=articles_437.shtml

I wanted to buy my last bandsaw, ended up buying the MM-16 early this year. IMHO it is everything a small/ medium shop will ever need. It has 16" of re-saw capacity with 4.8 Hp. The fit and finish are as good as any machine I have in my shop. Table is flat, adjustments are easy. Will use blades from 1/4" to 1 1/4" and has a frame sturdy enough to properly tension the wide blade. I bought it on sale - may still be available at the reduced price - for about $2400 delivered, with 3 blades of my choice. Minimax has had the best reviews for service and support (unlike Laguna - when I searched the web, I found many complaints about lack of service and support from them). I currently have a Woodslicer 1/2" blade on the saw, purchased a 3/4" but it was on backorder and came in later. I have done some sample re-sawing and it is pretty amazing. I can't find any reason to purchase any other saw - other than price.

Re: Meber (Laguna) Bandsaw Opinions Wanted

#7

I've the exact same saw....

HC Sakman

>It's an upgrade from 14" Delta and alike, but Jet 18" w/ Carter guides would not make any diffeence in my opinion...UNLESS you've a lemon Jet.

Chico...