Million Miles OT
Howard G
>Would you trust Midas or Meineke to replace exhaust pipe and muffler. I have an Explorer with 105M miles that I really like and don't want to mess up by going budget. Appreciate your opinions.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Million Miles OT
Howard G
>Would you trust Midas or Meineke to replace exhaust pipe and muffler. I have an Explorer with 105M miles that I really like and don't want to mess up by going budget. Appreciate your opinions.
Re: Million Miles OT
Grant Smith(remove 1 for email)
>Howard,
I would use either, but specify OEM grade parts. You got 105K miles on the truck, and most aftermarket exhaust doesn't last that long in 4 season regions.
They may try to offer you their lifetime warranty parts, which is fine if you have the time for regular replacement work.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa.
You might to try yourself.
Nat Robison
>A few years ago when the pipe between the catalytic converter and the muffer went on my 98 Honda, I scoped it out and decided to do it myself. It was literally the pipe and 4 bolts and the cost was about $100 since I reused the muffler. I priced it at about $300-$350 (with muffler) at some shops.
I don't know the particulars of the Explorer's system but I'm sure there are tons of places to get parts and it could be easier than you think to DIY.
Re: Million Miles OT
Joe Pack
>Short answer, NO! They both have grossly overcharged members of my family who didn't know better.
Long answer, maybe, if they used OEM parts, which they typically don't, at least not for their advertised prices. Also, they typically have a "lifetime guarantee" only on the muffler, not the pipes. When you go to collect on the "guaranteed" muffler, you might find that your bill for the pipes, clamps, hangers, etc. will equal the cost of the entire job at a regular independent muffler shop.
Sour grapes, maybe...I had a Midas "lifetime muffler" that was replaced twice in four years (that means each muffler lasted just over a year each). The pipes were pretty much shot at the same time, and I was dumb enough to pay their price. Eventually I got wise and found an independent muffler shop that replaced my entire system for about 25% more than Midas' cost, but the muffler and pipes lasted over four years.
Re: Million Miles OT
Ted Wong
>Definitely not. I think most chains that specialize in one area of auto maintenance are usually overpriced and the workers get a commission on what they can sell you whether you need it or not.
Ten years ago I went to Midas for a new muffler. That is all I needed. The pipes were still in good condition. But the mechanic told me the bolts were so rusted that he couldn't get them off and he'd have to bust the brackets off, drill out the holes and replace all the pipe. About a $600.00 operation. I went down the road to a local garage and had them look at it. He replaced the muffler and was able to loosen the brackets to do the work without all the B.S. Midas told me was involved. Total Cost was less than $100.00.
Re: Million Miles OT
Chuck W
>Why not try aftermarket stainless steel mufflers and pipes? That way you will be sure it is going to last the life of the truck.
What An Exhausting Discussion!
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Howard,
I trust Midas about as far as I can throw a Hummer. They are as notorious as AAMCO transmissions. I learned early and expensively to treat them the same as Sears. I've done business with the same mechanic for 30 years and he keeps the cars/trucks in good shape. I pay for top quality work up front, and never have to bring the vehicles back. Cheaper and safer in the long run.
George
Trust neither
Pat Evans
>Find a local muffler shop and get the job done right. Chain store parts absolutely will not last.
I won't go against the grain here.
Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN
>I'm with the others--find someone local who has a good reputation. Ask friends, family, coworkers, anyone you know. Stainless pipes are definitely the way to go, along with a lifetime muffler (just not one from a chain). I've NEVER heard anything good about either Midas or Meineke. My first experience with Midas was them telling me I needed everything behind the manifold after I ran over some rough train tracks and punched a hole in my '87 Lynx's exhaust, including the catalytic converter--total $300, a bit steep for a poor college student at the time. I went down the road and got everything BUT the cat replaced for $100, including parts. I've been going back to that shop for anything brakes-, muffler- or suspension-related since. Anything, that is, I can't fix or don't have time for myself, which isn't much anymore.
Jason
Amazing!
Bill Earl
>From my experience with Explorers, you should be on your 10th transmission and 3rd set of ball-joints by now. (No lie. I've got the paperwork to back that up!) It was a great vehicle to drive, but a real money pit.
But, if you have one of the good ones and want to keep it, I'd look for a local muffler shop with a good reputation. Warranties are as reliable as the company that backs them. (For example, Don't assume that a transmission is covered under "Engine and Drivetrain")
You can spend extra $$ on a B.S. extended warranty, or spend extra $$ dealing with a reputable company. I'd put my money on local outfit with a good reputation.
Re: Amazing! Really
Dustmaker Mike
>I just got rid of one with 300K on it. Yup I replaced the battery belts tires and hoses. That was all. It was a 96 fully loaded and everything worked like the day it was new when I sold it. I like that one so much I bought another one. Oh yea I had to replace the O2 sensors at 250K miles. I guess I got lucky hope I get lucky again like that(-;
Beg to differ
Rob Sandow
>Sorry, but when it comes to "commodity" auto maintenance like mufflers, brakes, oil changes, etc., you can't go wrong with the chains. The stuff they sell and install is usually just as good if not better than what a local mechanic would put in, and at a significantly lower price. These guys warranty their installations for as long as you own your car. What local mechanic would do that?
Local mechanics don't want commodity business because they would have to charge cut rate prices. Most of them get all the high margin business they need in out-of-warranty drive train and mechanical work, specifically excluding the things that Midas/Meineke do.
Personally, I don't even know of any "local muffler shops". They have pretty much gone out of business years ago since Midas and Meineke, but even if I did find one, I doubt Joe's muffler shop could compete on price and quality with the big guys.
There are high end places that do exhaust systems for luxury cars and charge a fortune, but that's not what we are talking about here. We are discussing a daily driver that already has 100K miles.
I have taken every car I have owned for the past 20 years to Midas/Meineke for mufflers and brakes when needed. They have always been completely professional and installed top quality parts. They would not have flourished in the business if they didn't, since they guarantee their work for as long as you own your car. If they had to make good on too many of those guarantees, you know they would have folded.
If you have any specific information regarding poor quality parts or installations from these guys, please post that, because I'm sure the readers here would want to know.
Low cost option
DB
>Do it yourself. It is really fairly easy to do. Go to your local auto parts store (maybe even the dealer) tell them want you want. They might even have the parts in stock. You will get all of the needed brackets and mounts. Pick up a repair manual for you vehicle. If needed a wrench and/or socket as needed. Probably a 9/16" will be the right size but that is just a guess so check first. Make sure all of the parts are correct first then follow the instructions in the repair manual.
Thanks Everyone
Howard G
>I know it's not a WW question, but wanted to avoid a porblem. You've confirmed my thoughts, I'm going local. Thanks again.
Re: Beg to differ
Pat Evans
>"If you have any specific information regarding poor quality parts or installations from these guys, please post that, because I'm sure the readers here would want to know."
My experience with Meineke: replaced a muffler with a "guaranteed" muffler. Of course they had to replace all the pipes too. Pipes lasted less than a year, but they weren't part of the guarantee. I didn't get under the car to look at workmanship until the new pipes rusted loose, but it was awful.
Similar horror stories with Aamco transmission and Midas brakes. I rarely give such places a second chance. For mufflers, I checked local garages and got their recommendation for a muffler shop. Slightly higher costs, but no comparison on materials and workmanship. There are numerous muffler shops in my area.
Re: Beg to differ - sorry Rob, I disagree
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>I have had poor luck dealing with Midas although I do have my mufflers installed there, knowing I will have to replace the "lifetime" mufflers in about 2 to 3 years - paying for pipes and clamps. They do sell a decent pipe, (Aluminized heaver gage) but at a much higher price. Last year my rear brakes on my 1989 Dodge B250 van started grinding. As Midas had a special of $69 per axle brake replacement, I went to their shop. They pulled the wheels and said the drums would have to be turned. Ok so how much? Believe it was $20 - $30 apiece. I said ok. Then they said one drum would have to be replaced and the other turned. I said - how much total. They said $350. I said no way. Then the manager re-figured and said he could use non-lifetime parts and do the job for $275. After a brief argument, I made them put the wheels back on and drove away. I couldn't find the drums in Frankfort (city where I live) so called auto parts stores in Lafayette. Drove to Lafayette, bought 2 new (top quality warrantied) drums, lifetime warranty Wagner brake shoes, and all the new spring / hardware for both wheels for $137.50 with taxes (retail, no discount). I didn't want to, but ended up installing them myself in about 2 hours - without a lift or other specialized tools they have. I really believe they could have installed them in an hour easy. $213.50 for 1 hours labor, not counting any profit they would have made on the parts seems just a tad excessive - agree?
Re: Million Miles OT
Chuck Lenz
>I don't think you can say a particular national company is bad, it may be bad in your area of the country, but may be good in other parts of the country, depending on who actually runs each store. You need to do some looking around locally, not nationally to find who your comfortable with.
Re: Beg to differ - sorry Rob, I disagree
Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN
>I agree, Larry. Once I learned how easy brakes actually are to repair/replace, I haven't looked back. I can do the front brakes on either of my vehicles in about 2 hours, including the 45 minute round trip to Lafayette to get the rotors turned, but not waiting on the Not Much Pep Boys to turn them. Rear brakes on the truck took about twice that. I'll find out on the Caravan here in the next couple weeks or so how long the rear brakes take on it--hopefully they aren't too bad, but I have heard some grinding back there for a while now. Larry, if you want good vehicle service, and are willing to drive to Lafayette, check out Beck Muffler & Brake shop near the corner of SR26 and US52--they're straight-up guys there. They do charge for inspections now, as too many guys like me have gone there for an inspection only to decide to do the work myself. I think the inspection fee is waived if they do the work. I do still go there for exhaust work--that one's a no-brainer. They can do in 30 minutes for $100 what would take me all afternoon and about $75 in parts.
Jason
Re: Beg to differ
Bart Leetch
>If you watch the news you'll hear all you need to hear about problems with chains & it all has already been stated just a quick way to stick their hands in your wallet. I'll bet if you really checked the systems over before you had them do the work you could have saved several dollars. I have seen chain stores close due to poor business practices as stated by others here. While the local business just kept working along providing good service & good parts & only the parts needed. Remember the chain stores have millions so if they fail in one place they can afford to go somewhere else but a well established local merchant will usually back up their work & parts because they can't afford to move. If they don't they won't stay in business long.
We have a plumber that is starting to get a bad rep here in our town & there are several of us that are helping him to close his plumbing business hopefully in the near future. You know when the word gets out it doesn't take long before a business can fold.