Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT - Guitar Question

Posts

OT - Guitar Question

#1

OT - Guitar Question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi Folks.

What forum would you suggest that is like and is as good as WoodCentral (I know, no forum is as good as WC) where noob's can ask questions about guitars? Not a guitar making forum but playing.

Thanks.

Joe

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#2

Re: OT - Guitar Question

David Yoho

>Joe, there are many talented guitarists right here that would be happy to help. Why go elsewhere with the talent we have right here?

David - (Former guitarist whose younger son now owns and plays professionally four nice guitars)

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#3

You Tube videos

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I know you're asking about a Forum, but there are a ton of teachers that have turned to the internet to teach guitar, bass, drums. ALot of them have sample training video's on You Tube. If you like them you are encouraged to buy the whole set. But it's nice cause you can get to see them in action "teaching".

Search for "Guitar" and you'll find them interspersed with all the virtuoso's playing and bootleg concert footage ;) Search for "guitar lesson" , etc and you zero in on them.

There's a guy from Brooklyn that teaches the drums... I like watching only because the guy is so far out that's he's humourous to watch.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#4

Re: You Tube videos

Keith Weber

>I second Mark's recommendation if it's actual lessons that you're looking for. I just discovered the "guitar lesson" search on YouTube about 2 months ago. My guitar playing has improved more in the last 2 months than it has in the last 5 years of trying to figure out stuff on my own. For me, taking "real" guitar lessons would cut into the tool fund -- and I really couldn't justify that silly decision! The freebies on YouTube are awesome.

There's lots of guitar tab (tabulature, or a simplified music for the guitar player) on the Internet, but it's extremely hard to sort through all the junk. I would guess that well in excess of 80% of the tab out there is just downright wrong. It's mostly put together by amateurs that think they've got the song figured out. It's kinda like the American Idol thing. There's millions of people out there who actually THINK that they can sing.

Keith

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#5

hey, me too!

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>I started playing around with a guitar also. a while back I asked this same question. someone pointed me to "wholenote"

good enough place. low traffic but someone always posts.

as far as YouTube. like mark said. search for "guitar lessons" and if you want to narrow that down search for something like "chords".

my favorite guy on there is "NextLevelguitar" you make like others.

I can recommend a few things that I liked.

Fretboard Logic by Bill Edwards. presents a nice easy way to move around the guitar neck. if you like that book and want to play the blues. there is a book that follows the same teaching style of the CAGED system presented in FretBoard Logic. it's called "Blues/rock soloing for the guitar"

I also like the Grimore series of guitar books as a reference and practice routine.

I am a raw beginner so take that FWIW.

later,

Joe P.

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#6

Re: hey, me too!

Paul Woolson

>Acoustic Player Magazine has a forum that is incredible. I'm actually a sponsor there and I don't like to part with my money so that says a lot.

They are a great bunch of guys and welcome with open arms anyone new and especially anyone new to the instrument.

Regardless of whether you play electric or acoustic the techniques for beginners are pretty much the same. If you are playing electric, just keep that under wraps while asking questions. Hope to see you around there. Best, Paul

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#7

OK Mark, David and all...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I won't bother with another forum at this point, I know there are a lot of guitar players here...

I really only have two questions and this is regarding acoustic guitars.

1-

For left handed people- do you play left or right handed? Which hand in on the strings and which is on the neck? I'm left handed. I've picked up my son's electric and can't figure out which hand should be on the neck. Neither feels natural! :) I could always bat left or right, but that's about it.

2-

For a complete newbie, what kind (style? Is that the right word?) of guitar would be recommended for someone with an interest only in Folk and Woody Guthrie type music? This would be a guitar that wouldn't cost much (I can't imagine Woody ever paid much early on for a guitar nor the very young Dylan) and if you decided you wanted to keep playing you could upgrade later to a better one. That kind of guitar. One to play around with to see if it's something you really want, or can, do.

This isn't a "which is better, Delta or Grizzly" question! :) I'm not necessarily looking for brand names. Unless everyone was to say there is no doubt a blahlahbalh is the way to go. :)

Thanks,

Joe

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#8

Re: Righty or lefty

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Here's my take: If you are just starting out and neither way feels right yet, I recommend learning to play "righty" (with your left hand on the neck). "Left-handed" guitars are few and far between, so if you are somewhere without your guitar and are offered one to play, you will be able to do so if you learn "righty" (well, after you learn to play). If you learn left-handed and are handed a standard strung guitar, you probably wouldn't be able to play it. It also makes it easier to go guitar shopping. I've not seen too many guitars hanging in shops that are strung (and pickguarded) for lefties.

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#9

Re: OK Mark, David and all...

Bob Dodge

>Joe,

Get yourself a decent acoustic guitar. The two elements that are of prime importance if you want a positive experience, are "playability", and "tone/intonation".

Playability has mostly to do with neck set-up. You want a guitar that has a nice easy "touch". Nothing will frustrate you as quickly as a guitar with a poorly set-up neck. You want the strings fairly close to the fret-board to allow easy fingering, but not so low as to cause "buzzing". Look for adjustability.

A guitar with poor intonation, is to be avoided at all costs. No matter how well you tune your guitar, as soon as you switch chords, it'll sound "out of tune". You don't have to break the bank to get a guitar with decent intonation.

Tone, is something you'll get with proper construction, and quality components. Look for a "solid-top" guitar, not "laminate". Generally, solid spruce is the material of choice. Finger-pickers/ soloists, may lean more to a warmer sound, such as that produced by a cedar top.

Inexpensive guitars often use laminated woods. The priority for you is to find a guitar with at least a solid top, followed by a solid back, then the sides.

You'll find different guitars have different "voicings". That has a lot to do with the size and shape of the guitar, as well as the bracing used inside the body. Some guitars are designed for aggressive strumming, others, a more delicate touch. A "jumbo" or "dreadnought", will usually have deeper bass and volume than a smaller-bodied guitar, but, don't get the impression that a smaller-bodied guitar is lacking, especially in finger-style.

Tone-woods also affect the cost of the guitar, as well as the tone. Generally, the less-expensive guitars will use sapele for the body and sides, followed by mahogany, maple, then the rosewoods. Each have their own particular sound. Depending on the manufacturer, you'll even find exotics such as koa, or cocobolo.

In my opinion, there's nothing worse than buying a "cheap guitar" to learn on. Inexpensive doesn't have to mean "cheap", and it's a relative thing.

Buying "used" can be a great way to get started. Be careful however. Know the instrument well before taking the leap. DO NOT buy "on-line", or, "sight-unseen". Try it first.

If you want a good guitar, go to a well-stocked music store, and look for a Taylor guitar. The playability, intonation, and tone, are superb, and they have a huge price-range. Even if you don't buy one, it'll give you a good idea of what a nicely set-up and constructed guitar can do for you insofar as playing enjoyment is concerned. Also, you won't lose your shirt if you decide to sell the instrument.

Try to not be influenced by "looks" alone. There are many great-looking cheap guitars out there, and many are nothing but junk. Playability, Intonation, and Tone should be your guidelines.

Good luck,

Bob

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#10

Re: hey, me too!

Keith Weber

>NextLevelGuitar..."Hey good people..."

I love that guy!

Keith

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#11

Good people!

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>He cracks me up. but I just learn more from his free clips thans few DVD I tried.

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#12

Agree with Bob

David Yoho

>Bobs comments are spot on. Joanne's advice on the left/right-handed deal is good too.

For me, there's nothing worse than trying to learn on a guitar where you have to push down on the neck real hard just to make the strings note. The only acoustic guitar I owned was many, many years ago and I bought it after selling off my Gibson electric and amps. Being spoiled by the nice setup of the strings and neck on the Gibson, I wanted something equally nice in an acoustic. I found that in a Yamaha (don't remember the model) and the price back then was reasonable. I don't begin to know what's out there today. I do remember buying our elder son an Epiphone some years ago that wasn't bad and the cost was below $100. Seemed like a good enough "starter" guitar for the cost. My best advice would be to go to a well stocked music store where the folks are knowledgeable and you can see and try out what's available.

David

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#13

Used

Joe Pack

>Joe,

A good quality used acoustic is my recommendation. Let someone else pay for the privelege of putting the first scratch on it. You want to look for one that is easy to finger, has a straight neck (just hold the body and sight toward the winding pegs - if there is a bow, you will see it) and has the sound you want...bright, mellow, etc.)

Brand is not critical, particularly in the mid-level ($250-$500) guitars, but quality control is. Even in upper end guitars, there is a variation between instruments, just not as much as in lower and mid-priced guitars. I bought a Takamene classical for just shy of $1000 at Guitar Center. I played 4 of the exact same model. One was clear, three were muddy. Quality control. Do NOT buy anything you have not played!

Someone else recommended a Taylor. These are excellent instruments. I bought one new for my oldest son for a college grad gift. I bought a used Martin for my youngest son. I play around with a Gibson Dove, an Alvarez RD20S (bought used; played 3 new ones, same model, that sounded crappy and played worse, bought the used one that played and sounded better than some other brands for $1000) and a Takamene classical. I would LOVE to have a Laravee (Metronome Music, Mansfield, OH), but can't justify it, just want it. These all play well and sound great, but range in price from $250 - $2500. The point is, don't fall in love with a brand, fall in love with a particular instrument.

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#14

Re: OK Mark, David and all...

Keith Weber

>Joe,

I can't say that I'm familiar with folk music, nor even know who Woody Guthrie is, but if you're looking for an easy guitar to learn on, try a classical guitar.

A classical looks like an accoustic, but with a few differences. It usually has 12-frets above the body vs. 15. As a beginner, you'll never use those frets anyway. The classical has a wider neck (strings further apart), which makes it easier to finger the chords without muting adjacent strings with your fingers. They also use nylon strings instead of steel strings. Nylon strings are much, much easier on the finger tips, as they're easier to press to the fretboard.

My first guitar was a cheap electric with frets at varying heights. It was horrible to play. I played a friends Yamaha Classical guitar. It was so nice that I sold my electric and bought a similar one. It only cost me about $100. I've now got a couple of other more expensive guitars, but that old $100 Yamaha is still my favorite and usually the one that I pick up first. It's got a nice mellow sound. Just something to consider. I also agree that if both ways of holding a guitar feel odd, try learning on a standard guitar if you can.

Keith

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#15

Check out the local trader mags...

Andy Halterman: Flowers are blooming

>I'd imagine your area has a few. You can get a decent used acoustic and save a pretty good stack of money. I've got a couple of Washburn 6 strings and a Takamine 12 string. Washburn's D10 (I think) is a decent less expensive guitar. Like others have said, play it first. You may not like the sound of a cedar top or the feel of a particular neck etc, etc. If you can get a solid wood top, do so. I think that is important. You can hear and feel the difference a solid top makes.

My caution about a classical guitar is that if you have small hands/short fingers, the wider neck can be a bit tougher to get used to. Also the nylon strings may not offer the sound you are looking for.

Good luck in your search. I haven't plugged in my Strat for several years now. So much easier to pick up the acoustic and just play it.

Andy Halterman

4 glorious hours on the mtn. bike today in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#16

Re: Used

Gary Tenney

>Hey Joe, I have a Larrivee about 10 years old. Don't remember the model number, but it is the one with the Eagle head inlay and Eagle feathers for position markers on the fretboard and oversized soundhole. The sound is absolutely the best and it feels and plays great. You are right about the cost though! 10 years ago, 2,000.00 US. The money was well-spent as it is worth more today than when I bought it!

Gary

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#17

Re: OK Mark, David and all...

Gary Tenney

>You could always buy a mid-high end kit and build one, but then you would have to buy more tools! Darn!

Gary

Re: OT - Guitar Question

#18

Thanks everyone!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>