In Search Of The Perfect Mobile Base
Dave Morris
>Oh, that small shop quandary--- there's only a limited space available, but you have several relatively big machines requiring enough open space to operate them. Each machine needs enough free area around it to move the wood you are working on, plus enough free area for your body to safely move to, from, and around the tool.
Me? It's a dance to get around stuff most of the time, and I have to move most of my tools to a central "open" location if I want to use them. Soooo... most of the tools have their own mobile base. I tried various types, here's a kind of timeline.
First mobile base-- On an El Cheapo Delta direct-drive "Motorized Table Saw"... This was Delta's POS edition, my first "stationary" power tool. Through the use of this saw, I learned a lot about what I don't want in a table saw, but it allowed me to begin my journey as a woodworker. I screwed a piece of plywood on the back of the base to sandwich a length of all-thread sporting a pair of cheep lawn mower wheels. Grab one end of the fence rails, lift one end the saw off the ground and pull the saw where you want it. This "mobile" base was cheap, not very effective or ergonomic, looked like crud, and reflected my skills at the time (15 or so years ago... where does the time fly?). The entire POS saw has finally found it's calling in life and currently stands duty as a "mobile" base cabinet for my portable planer.
Second mobile base--- upgraded to a Powermatic contractor table saw when I had a LOT of old redwood interior and exterior siding to recycle. Bought the saw, brought it home, and assembled it in the only place available-- the back yard. When the work was done, how to get that heavy (for me) saw into my garage when I had to navigate my back yard? I didn't want to go through the hassle of taking it apart and putting it back togther again. Solution... I made an "off-road" mobile base for the saw, sort of like turning it into a tablesaw version of those two-wheeled wheel-barrows for hauling a big load of dirt. I bought a pair of pneumatic tires, a steel rod for an axle, added some plywood to the sides of the saw legs to prevent flex, ran a couple old-growth Fir 2x4's from the axle in the "front" (left) side of the saw to the "back" (right) side of the saw. Carved the ends of the 2x4's to fit my hands for a nice grip, and I could "wheel" the saw over the bumps and uneven dirt of my back yard. The saw sits of it's own feet, but when I need to move it, I just lift up the saw like a wheel barrow, and the tires contact the ground. I can move this saw easier than a load of dirt, even walking it over a construction 2x4 laying on the ground like it wasn't there. The mobile base worked so well, I left it on the saw and still use it today. The whole thing stays inside the "footprint" of the saw's (left) wing table and (right) fence rails, so no extra space is needed. It's not by any means your average mobile base for a table saw, but it served it's purpose very well at a time of need. Downside... it steers the same as any wheel barrow, and you have to lift a portion of the saw's weight.
Third mobile base--- Delta Universal base kit for my router table. Substituted 1-1/2" square steel tube for the (suggested) wood frame. Strong, simple, don't have to lift anything, and switches from stationary to mobile by use of a foot lever. Great base, but lacks clearance for anything other than smooth surfaces, only steers from one end, and the wheels can get caught up on small debris like an errant 1/4" nut laying on the floor.
Fourth mobile base--- came attached as part of a Delta 50-850 dust collector. Same steering, higher ground clearance, same small wheels, simplest to make since it was part of the tool and was part of initial tool assembly at home.
Fifth mobile base--- Another Delta Universal kit, this time for a Delta DJ-15 jointer. Same pros and cons as before, but steering is even tougher due to the length of the jointer's infeed and outfeed tables... it's needs a lot of room to maneuver this tool. One-sided steering gets a thumbs down for this particular job.
Sixth mobile base--- Homemade, two plywood platforms with four swiveling casters each, bolted/tied together with scrap 2x4's, used to support the paired legs of a *heavy* old cast-iron 16" planer that is awaiting restoration. Relatively simple to make, great mobility, plenty strong, and cheap to purchase the initial parts. Will add better quality swivel/locking casters when restoration commences.
Seventh mobile base--- Woodcraft "Universal Mobile Base Kit" for a Jet 14" bandsaw, purchased a month ago. Cheap (60 bucks), and very easy to make. You cut a piece of 3/4" plywood to size, bolt two wheels and two swivel castors to the four corners, and you're good to go. Raises and lowers with a foot lever on each of the castors. Strong enough for it's weight rating (600 pounds) but would flex if you made it larger than the footprint of the tool since it's strength is a function of the plywood it's bolted to. Also, the foot levelers/swivel castors are not of the same quality as the Delta unit, and the first time I turned the saw on I heard this incredibly annoying buzzing metal-to-metal sound. I thought something terrible was wrong with the saw, only to find it was the foot handle of each leveler vibrating against it's metal base and axle rod. There's a lot more slop here than in the Delta unit... it's not of the same quality. I think some felt washers and/or a dab of silicone will alleviate the metal-to-metal contact and resulting noise, but that's not something I'd expect to find when purchasing a new base for a tool. If I had to do it over again, I'd go with the Delta version.
In the end, each of these mobile bases has their own pluses and minuses. Personally, I'd love to find a mobile base kit with four high quality locking swivel castors for maneuverability, plenty of strength, and the ability to roll over small objects without causing the wheels to stop and/or skid. Not having seen the HTC base or mobile bases by other manufacturers, I can't comment on their attributes.
Anybody want to add to the list? I'd love to hear some first-person comparisons with side-by-side experiences of other bases on the market.
Dave--- dreaming of the day when his shop is big enough that the tools don't have to be moved to be used



