Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Buying Lumber at Auction

Posts

Buying Lumber at Auction

#1

Buying Lumber at Auction

Bruce

>From checking woodweb and the local lumber dealer I know the going price for wood. However, I don't know the all the things to consider when not buying from a reliable source. What defects should you be looking for when buying at an auction? How much do you discount over buying at a known source?

Thanks,

Bruce

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#2

Broad question

Chad Pearson

>I think it really depends on the type of wood you are buying. I won't speak to the different grades of lumber,...I assume you already know that. What I can tell you however is my own experience and guidelines in buying lumber sight unseen. What types of defects you should be aware of really depends on what you can personally work around given your project (although warped or insect infected wood is almost always bad).

I believe that the ability to pick and choose lumber has significant value. I can go to my local rocklers and sort through their stack of cherry buying just the boards I need for about 6 dollars a board foot (cheaper from time to time). If I buy 100 bd ft they will discount that price by at least a dollar, however you are not allowed to choose boards. I don't think this is a very good deal at all. I think I loose more than 1/6 of the lumber in waste because of defects and sapwood. I would much rather pay the 6 bucks and choose my boards, if available. (Having said that I very rarely buy from Rockler because I get a much better deal from a local guy.)

On the other hand I have many times bought large lots (200 to 600 bt ft) of cherry for 3 to 3.5 dollars a bd ft. Sometimes this has resulted in fantastic deals with almost no sapwood and very few defects. Other times it has resulted in a lot of boards that are unusable. My rule of thumb is that unless I get a discount of at LEAST 30% I would rather not take the risk.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#3

If you've been to Woodweb........

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....you oughta know about crook, checks, wain, knots, shake, shear, casehardening and the rest of the usual suspects associated with wood.

Unless its a very hard to find wood (exotic or butternut, chestnut etc) I wouldnt pay more than half of what you can buy it locally per bf for. Ive seen it sold by the bf, by the stick, by the row, by the pile. No one auctioneer is the same. A call ahead might better prepare you for what will come on sale day. I would have a quick bftge reference guide with you, as well as a moisture meter too.

Watch out for ppb's in the wood, examine several boards deep and see if theres pinholes in ANY of it.

Read up on how to grade wood too. Theres a big difference in how much a stick of walnut is worth if its clear/select, FAS or #1, #2, #3 etc.

Scott

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#4

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

Steve Kreitler

>The last time I bought lumber at auction, it was from an old cabinet shop in a town about 60 miles from here that must not have been running for twenty to thirty years- it was filled with museum piece machines (no kidding- some of them had been built to run off a line shaft!). I wasn't able to afford the 20" jointer, or the 36" bandsaw (like I could have moved them, anyhow- much less gotten them into my shop!), but I did fill up my 5'x 10' trailer about two feet high with a bunch of black walnut, and all the offcuts from under the radial arm saw (about a twenty foot bench- some short but beautiful wood under there!). I picked up a few other odds and ends, and spent about $65 bucks. Nice walnut, too- not steamed, so lots of nice color variations (I like it that way).

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#5

Re: If you've been to Woodweb........

Bruce Walton

>Your comment on the case hardening specifically is right on track. I saw how to test for it by cutting the wood. However, is there a way to check it in a pile at an auction house?

As to the checks and such, how do you determine the amount of discount from the FAS price that I see on woodweb?

Lets say the wood needs additional drying, how much discount would you take from the FAS price?

Thanks,

Bruce

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#6

a buyers test

bill tindal, E.TN

>what is the current price of FAS1F, 1C, 2C Appalichaian red oak? What is the current premium on bundles of just KD FAS1F? Could you tell with confidence a 1C board from a FAS1F? If you can answer these questions correctly then you may be ready to buy for a source of unknown reliability.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#7

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have bought and still buy a lot of wood at auctions. I have never paid $1 /bf - usually in the range of .20 ~ $.50. I have had a small quantity of "bad" wood - insect infected, a few case hardened boards etc. However considering the price I believe I have made very good deals. Most of what I have is air dried - the last auction I went to was for an Amish gentleman, all the wood I purchased had been in a barn for several years. I paid about $60 for (guessing due to the trailer load) about 3000 lb of walnut, cherry and poplar with a few pieces of highly figured maple. I have a complete cherry tree I purchased at another Amish auction. It was cut about 5/4 about 24" wide that was air dried for at least 6 years in a storage building. It is figured and I paid $120 - estimate between 250 to 350 bf. In this area (central Indiana) rough sawn lumber goes very cheap. However, I have very rarely purchased any planed wood as the prices are much higher. I assume this is because of hobby woodworkers without planers & joiners wanting material - or the fact it looks so much prettier planed! I probably have 3 to 5,000 bf of various hardwoods in my storage room above the shop, estimate I have less than $2000 invested. I would be very careful if this is your first venture in auction buying lumber, I have been to a few auctions I walked away empty handed due to high prices. Don't know where you are located, but I normally find more wood at auctions in Indiana very cheap than I have room to store.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#8

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

Bruce Walton

>It is interesting that you'd mention central Indiana. I'm in Greenfield, so we are neighbors. Where do you find the Amish auctions? I know one is coming up April 28 in Milroy, but I've not run across others. Also, I don't know if the Milroy auction will have any lumber.

Thanks,

Bruce

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#9

answers.........

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>Your comment on the case hardening specifically is right on track. I saw how to test for it by cutting the wood. However, is there a way to check it in a pile at an auction house? NOT THAT I'M AWARE OF BRUCE. JUST AS INTERNAL STRESSED WOOD (REACTION) ACTS ALOT LIKE CASE HARDENED WOOD, IT'S A RISK YOU WONT SEE TILL THE BLADE HITS THE WOOD,ASSUMING ITS KILN DRIED THAT IS.

As to the checks and such, how do you determine the amount of discount from the FAS price that I see on woodweb? I GUESS I'D USE COMMON SENSE...IF THE END CHECK RUNS 12"...IS THE PIECE STILL USABLE?

THIS HAS GOT TO BE A JUDGEMENT CALL. YOU MIGHT WANT 1X2 OR 1X4 MATERIAL FOR FACE FRAMES..THEN IT WOULD BE OK. BUILDING A WIDE PANEL FOR A BLANKET CHEST, THEN NO ITS NOT VERY DESIREABLE.

Lets say the wood needs additional drying, how much discount would you take from the FAS price? IT'S BEEN AWHILE SINCE I'VE HAD ANY WOOD KILN DRIED, BUT A COUPLE YRS AGO I PAID .40 PER BF TO DRY AND STICKER MY WOOD AT A KILN. THEN THERES THE LOADING AND UNLOADING DONE TO GET IT THERE AND BACK FROM THE KILN (YOUR TIME IS $$$ TOO). I WOULD FIGURE AT LEAST THAT INTO ANY WOOD PURCHASE. HERE IS WHERE THE MOISTURE METER WOULD HELP YOU DETERMINE THIS COST.

Good Luck and post the gloat and pics of it all!

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#10

Re: a buyers test

Keith Newton

>Most of what I have gotten from auctions has been at a value of ~ 10� on the dollar. If you are buying it without having a need for it right away, I would not pay over 50% of its current cost.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#11

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction - long reply

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Bruce, the area around Rossville, Flora and Delphi is settled by several families of Amish. Marvin Mohler is the auctioneer who handles most of the auctions for the Amish in the area - he is Amish. He is also one of the best auctioneers I have ever bought from. He is absolutely honest and really moves the material through the auctions. As I have signed up for his handbills, I receive them through the mail. His auctions are always advertised in the local paper. The auction where I purchased the Cherry was a deceased gentleman who had purchased an old school building between Frankfort and Rossville. He had converted part of the building into a residence and part was a sawmill. His sawmill appeared to handle about 40' long logs and had a large lower blade (guess 48") and an upper 24" or so. I would guess he could easily rip through a 30"+ dia. tree. It was powered with the front end of a Case tractor. I had never heard about him selling wood but he had one building (old turkey farm building) I would estimate 120 X 60' full of hardwood, and two small barns also full. They had three skid loaders working full time during and after the auction. There had to be several 100M/bf sold. Several buyers brought flatbed semis to haul their purchases. I just hauled 3 loads on my 5' X 10' trailer. - I purchased the $60 load from the sale at Dallas Meader (not sure of spelling) he was a CPA at Rossville - also Amish. Mr. Mohler had a consignment sale at Flora last summer. There were lumber lots from a couple of families. I bought some green Walnut slabs at that auction from a small lumber milling operation at Flora ran by an Amish gentleman. I picked up a handbill he distributed - haven't been to his place yet. Really don't have any need to buy lumber except when I need a particular species like hickory for a project.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#12

Re:Also Bruce

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have found lumber at several local auctions (not Amish) - usually there are less than 200 - 300 bf. If an auction lists woodworking tools, I usually go as many Woodworkers (and wannabe Woodworkers) buy and stash wood. At one auction at the local Armory about 5 years ago, I picked up a crate of veneer. Crate is 8 to 10' long X 4' high X about 4" thick. I'm ashamed to say I don't really know what is in it. When I bought it I paid about $3.00. I didn't have my shop built so my sons moved it into an unused upstairs room in my house. I finished the shop a couple years ago and moved much from this room but the veneer is still in there. I so know there was an opening in the center of the crate and I could see a Walnut burl flitch at least a foot wide X a couple foot long. Really need to get it down and look it over.

Re: Buying Lumber at Auction

#13

Thanks Larry!! NT

Bruce Walton

>