Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Bending for bow-back windsor chair

Posts

Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#1

Bending for bow-back windsor chair

K.S.SONG

>Hi

We are now under trying to bending test for bow-back windsor chair.

We were informed previously it should be used green solid wood for bow bending.

Due to some difficulty to buy those green logs small amount of Walnut, Oak, Hickory etc. in Korea, we prefer to use dried timber imported from America mainly.

Test condition :

Main species for test now is Walnut.

Dipping in hot water - approx. 7days, and then steam bath - 2~3hours.

Result :

Diameter 13mm x 70cm L (for miniature type): good and easily bended.

Diameter 16, 17mm x 105cm L (for actual size): every pieces failed.

Question :

1) Is it imposible to bend with dried solid wood despite any efforts?

2) Any useful experience or technical information for this kind work?

Please let us have your kind comments.

Thanks in advance.

K.S.SONG / KOREA

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#2

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

Philip Duffy

>Mr Song, I would suggest that you try bending a local hardwood that is green. You should find that it bends quite easily, especially if it is a ring-porous tree. There are many different types of woods used to make Windsors as the availability of woods varies considerably in the various parts of our county. If the chairs are to be painted then it makes little difference what woods are used so long as they dry strong. Good luck! Philip

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#3

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

Peter Galbert

>You may find a couple of problems with the way you are proceeding. The reasons to use green wood rather than dried are many. Here are a couple. It is mainly the heat that allows the wood to bend, not the moisture, however, the moisture in the green wood will transfer the heat throughout the piece more readily and help make the bending possible. If you must bend dried wood, try air dried and be prepared for increased steaming times.A hoop back is one of the most extreme bends as far as radius and I wouldn't bother trying anything except a ring porous hardwood. The green wood also allows you to shave along the fibers so that there are no places for a break to start. If you cannot do this due to manufacturing restrictions etc, you may consider using metal bands to support the bend as you wrap it around the form. I never find them necessary with shaved wood. You should still try to include as much long fibers in the piece as possible (as though it were split vs. sawn), it will improve your success in bending and increase the strength of the final piece. I have been covering this topic on my blog www.chairnotes.blogspot.com If you find you have any questions please ask them here (as opposed to my blog) so that you can get the full benefit of the members knowledge. Good luck

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#4

JL

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

JL

>Some background first.

Typically the process of kiln drying "sets" the lignin in the wood.

I've had some success in steaming and bending air dried wood, but no real success in steaming and bending kiln dried wood.

My typical steaming time is about 1 hour per inch. Steaming too long is not necessarily a good idea.

Now, in regards to your questions.

Question :

1) Is it impossible to bend with dried solid wood despite any efforts?

See above - the lignin in kiln dried wood is usually "set". Better luck with air dried and green lumber. That being said - sometimes it is possible to use some chemicals to make the kiln dried wood pliable. This is not recommended as it weakens the wood.

2) Any useful experience or technical information for this kind work?

Useful technical information: Lee Valley has a good book on steam bending wood as well as the "Wood Bender's Handbook".

Drew Langsner has an excellent book "The Chairmaker's Workshop" which has all sorts of useful information.

You said that your bow dimensions were 16-17 mm x 105 cm? I'd really like to see your plans. Most of my bow dimensions for a sack back are 24 mm x 105 cm. But I use green riven lumber to bend.

For a loop (or hoop) back, my bow dimensions are 24 mm x 155 cm or so.

My typical spindle ends are maybe 9 mm on the top and maybe 13 mm on the bottom.

My $0.02.

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#6

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair *LINK*

Keith Newton

>Here is a link for a free booklet that is a must for beginning steam bending.

Wetting dry wood can cause a problem that is invisible until later on in the process. The compression of the wood on the surface expanding can cause splitting on the inside.

If you metered the wood that went into the kiln dry, it would likely come out at ~18 - 20% MC. For this reason, it is a good idea to air dry the lumber to this range before putting it in the steam-chamber.

After that, compression straps will improve your success more than anything.


http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=31161&cat=1,45866,45867

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#7

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

Carol from AZ

>JL ran past a really good point.

He used green riven lumber. If you can't get green, then at least rive it. Really straight grain had greater strength. If the grain is even sightly diagonal to the edge, the bend will break much, much easier.

That helped my students when I was teaching woodworking.

Re: Bending for bow-back windsor chair

#8

Re: Thanks... Thanks...

K.S.SONG

>Thanks a lot to everybody for very useful instruction.

I will study futher and try again upon these comments.

Thanks.

Good luck.

K.S.SONG / KOREA