Another toolbox restoration.
Over the past weekend I was able to finish up another tool box cleanup/restoration, this one also having been one of my stepfather’s. I was able to get a bit of the history of the box, as my mom was the person who purchased it as a birthday gift for back in November of 2002. To say that it presented a challenge might be an understatement. Physically, the box was not in horrible shape. The hinge was a touch askew, a few of the drawer slides were bent, and there were dents on the lid and on the base, but those weren’t the real issues.
When I first brought the box home I was surprised at how heavy it was, even when emptied out. The sheet metal is of a much heavier gauge than I first thought, in particular with the drawers being very beefy. The box was very dirty, as in coated with a film of grime and dust held on with a coating of machine oil. It was also covered in stickers (please don’t put stickers on your tool box…use magnetic stuff instead) This layer of grime was a problem, because it hid a troublesome layer of rust and made the rest of the box look otherwise deceivingly healthy.
The first thing I did after taking the box apart was vacuuming out any of the dirt that I could, Then the box got a bath with Dawn and a scrub brush, which at the least made me feel better about handling it without getting goo all over my clothes. I then removed the drawers and decorative drawer pull covers, scrubbing them down with Dawn as well. Thankfully, the drawers were mostly in good condition, with only a bit of surface rust in two of the smaller top drawers and the corner of the bottom drawer. But, like many things in life, bringing the box out into the light of day coupled with a thorough cleaning revealed the true nature of the beast, namely a layer of very heavy rust on the toolbox bottom.
I was able to knock out the dent at the bottom easily enough with a rubber mallet (the one on the lid was a bit more of a challenge) , but the rust was so bad that I very nearly decided against attempting the restoration, and if the gauge of the steel had been lighter it probably wouldn’t have been fixable. But, because the box belonged to my step dad, I soldiered on. Just like the smaller box I restored, I soaked this one in rust remover and in WD40 for several days, then came the long, arduous task of grinding and sanding away the rust so it could be painted. (There are more details in the video pasted below).

The box when I first brought it home. There was makeshift clasp attached to the upper left corner that I removed before the photo was taken (hence the holes)

The bottom of the tool box after nearly 2 days of soaking and several hours of grinding and sanding.

A look at the front of the box with the drawers and some of the stickers removed. There is a small hole visible under the lock that was covered by a sticker..not sure why or how the hole got there…

The box after some initial cleaning, grinding, and sanding. Some of the holes are filled in with the first application of epoxy.

The first coat of paint applied. After this coat I applied a bit more epoxy to better fill in the screw holes.

The finished tool box. 3 coats of paint, holes filled, drawer pulls polished.
There was unfortunately no magical transition, and Cinderella didn’t just turn into a princess with the snap of a finger….it just took a lot, and I mean a lot of elbow grease. Removing the stickers and residue was particularly grueling…once again…don’t put stickers on anything…they eventually wear out end up looking like hell. The drawer fronts were painted with a gloss black spray paint/primer combo, which I used because it was handy. But the rest of the box I painted with a Rust-Oleum paint/primer in the Hammered Black color, which I was very pleasantly surprised with. I chose Hammered Black because on the can it was advertised that it would mask slight imperfections, and I must say it did a pretty good job in that regard.
There are many details that I am leaving out that are made more clear in the video (that I hope you might watch). As of writing the post I am still in the process of lining the drawers. I was also able to purchase replacement keys from eBay for the box. Though I applied three coats of paint, I will also be on the lookout for any required touch ups, as there is always something that gets missed. But, all of the drawers work…the lock and release latches are functioning…the rust is all gone and there are no glaring dents or dings…the lid opens and closes much more smoothly…if anything else it is a functioning toolbox again that should last another 20 years.
The bottom line is that this box probably wasn’t as well cared-for as it could have been, but I am glad that I took the trouble, and it was trouble, to get it cleaned up and looking half-decent again. That being said, if I came across another box in the same condition I very likely wouldn’t touch it. We learn from experience…



