Messages
Wiley Horne
In context, Ben Franklin was saying pretty near the opposite of what is implied in Mr. Morgan’s post. The quote came during the French-Indian Wars, when raids on the frontier settlements were a real problem in Pennsylvania.
Franklin was addressing the PA legislature, asking them to insist upon taxing the Penn family proprietors, to help pay for the collective defense of PA. Penn family wanted to pay a smallish lump sum, in exchange for the legislature stipulating it had no taxing authority over the Penn proprietors.
Franklin was telling the legislature that Liberty lay in taxation to provide for the collective defense, and there was no Safety to be bought by accepting the Penn family deal.
Franklin was advocating for doing the responsible thing: To take specific collective action against a real threat that was killing the citizenry.
Mr. Morgan is taking the opposing position: To deny any collective responsibility to act against a real and present threat that has so far killed 300,000 of us. Strange to use Ben Franklin’s words to support this thesis.
Wiley
Messages In This Thread
- anybody vaccinated yet? *NM*
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Yep
- Wish I knew
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Never. !
- Why
- Re: Never add me to this list
- Vaccination is not a personal choice.
- I disagree...
- Re: Vaccination is not a personal choice.
- I disagree...
- Re: Never add me to this list
- Never. !
- Yes...
- ASAP
- I will get it as soon as it's an option
- Re: I will get it as soon as it's an option
- There's precedent, and memory is fleeting
- That will be the issue...
- There's precedent, and memory is fleeting
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- ADMIN! Hey, folks, let's remember: civility
- It's not just the deaths
- Re: Mom was in an Iron Lung. What do you think?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- No ... but
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?
- Re: anybody vaccinated yet?