Hand Tools Archive

Subject:
Re: minor corrections
Response To:
Re: minor corrections ()

david weaver
I have to think that the reason there aren't many 3V chisels is because most people are used to working O1, and can work O1 faster with machines. And heat treating would have to be done on a separate schedule.

That and especially, most people making chisels wouldn't like to triple the cost of the steel used in their chisels on something that they want to sell to you for $60. Maybe their wholesale is half of retail, or a little more or less (which is still relevant for LV, because they bear the cost of retailing instead). If you've got $30 of budget for a chisel, burning through $10 worth of steel on one instead of $3 is a big deal.

Our odds of getting the best chisel steel in a western chisel, no cost considered, are about as good as our odds of making a perfect original chisel design in our own garages.

If 3V cost the same as O1 and worked as easily without work hardening, we'd probably have it instead of O1.

Messages In This Thread

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Re: Inside Joke / story
Japanese steel and PM V11 *LINK*
more picking on Kees
Re: more picking on Kees
Re: more picking on Kees
Re: PM V11 and LV sharpening mastery + the truth
Where were all you sages back then.....?
Re: Where were all you sages back then.....?
Finck
comparing apples and oranges
Re: comparing apples and oranges
Modern steel
Re: Modern steel
Proposed amendment to Kee`s post
Re: Proposed amendment to Kee`s post
Re: Proposed amendment to Kee`s post
data to disagree with your conclusion *PIC*
Drawing a conclusion
minor corrections
Re: minor corrections
A purveyor of CPM 3V chisels
Re: minor corrections
working porperties of 3V
Some people`s reasoning stumps me
Re: Some people`s reasoning stumps me
that was the conclusion I came to
Re: Some people`s reasoning stumps me
Re: data to disagree with your conclusion
Chisels don't quietly wear away.
Re: Chisels don't quietly wear away.
Flaw in Woodcentral Web site/PIC added *PIC*
Re: Flaw in Woodcentral Web site/PIC added
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Swiss steel?
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Shut your festering gob, you nit!
Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit!
Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit! *LINK*
the brass weight..
can you believe that there are people
Re: can you believe that there are people
Re: If you have a stake..
Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit!
Don't read too much into that, Curt
Steel and Tools
Re: Steel and Tools
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: When you throw out the holteys...
Of course...
Re: Of course...
I did not sneer
Re: I did not sneer
Re: I did not sneer
Re: I did not sneer
Re: I did not sneer
Re: I did not sneer
Well..
Re: Well..
Re: Well..
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread
Re: The News
Excellent analysis *NM*
Re: Not me, dude...
Re: Not me, dude...
Missing the point
Re: I was going to wait a while..
I too subscribe to your rule
Re: I too subscribe to your rule
It's new !! so what
© 1998 - 2012 by Ellis Walentine. All rights reserved.
No parts of this web site may be reproduced in any form or by
any means without the written permission of the publisher.

WOODCENTRAL, P.O. BOX 493, SPRINGTOWN, PA 18081