Hand Tools Archive

Subject:
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Brian,

Where can I see these pix? Here are the Elliott diagrams, with photos linked from the text:

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/wear_profiles.html

Is quantifiable metal loss confirmed by weight (Not that I think that is possible.)? I don't know of any attempts to do this.
or just shape of object.

IE is the blade deformed showing less material or is material really missing? I believe it's inferred by the registration of the camera to a minute mark or recognizable feature on the blade, and overlaying the successive images. Maybe Steve can help here. Kato and Kawai likewise have made photographic registration and measurement, though surely using more expensive gear. On the face of it, then, I suppose you could say, 'well, maybe the steel compressed, since no weight comparisons were made, or spalled-off particles collected'. On the other hand, steel is a crystalline lattice, through and through, and I don't believe density differences have been detected after rolling under great pressure--the rolling just results in elongation, not compression to higher density. However, I'm only reporting what I've read, and don't know any more than you, and could easily know less.

If it is missing where did it go? Dunno.

Did metal particles get found in the planing/chiseling? Dunno.

Wiley

Messages In This Thread

Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Friction isn't the cause of the heat
Re: Friction isn't the cause of the heat
Reply
Re: Friction isn't the cause of the heat *PIC*
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
you need a trip to Steve Elliott's web site
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
calling Sherlock Holmes
Re: calling Sherlock Holmes
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Making the Wear Profile Test Images
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
replied off line *NM*
Re: Larry, you haven't been totally dismissed..
Re: Larry, you haven't been totally dismissed..
Re: Larry, you haven't been totally dismissed..
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
no, the oposite
Re: no, the oposite
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
heating
heat
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
I'm interested...
Re: I'm interested...
Re: I'm interested...
Re: I'm interested... - goog point
Re: I'm interested... - goog point
Re: I'm interested... - goog point
Abrading steel alloys
May I make a suggestion?
Good points, well said. *NM*
+1 *NM*
Re: May I make a suggestion?
Re: May I make a suggestion?
Re: May I make a suggestion?
Re: May I make a suggestion?
User wear spiraling out of control.....
Tool Wear vs tool geometry *PIC*
Re: Tool Wear vs tool geometry
Re: Tool Wear vs tool geometry
Kato and Kawai shed some light
© 1998 - 2012 by Ellis Walentine. All rights reserved.
No parts of this web site may be reproduced in any form or by
any means without the written permission of the publisher.

WOODCENTRAL, P.O. BOX 493, SPRINGTOWN, PA 18081