Hand Tools Archive

Subject:
No death knell in my opinion

Steve Elliott
There are a number of issues here, which I hope I can sort out.

First, for some species of wood I believe a high angle is more effective than a well-adjusted cap iron. Both Derek Cohen and I have reported better results using a high cutting angle (around 60 degrees) for brittle tropical timbers, in my case Bolivian rosewood. I don't claim to have found the optimum cap iron setting for this timber but that would take considerable experimentation, and increasing the cutting angle was quick and effective.

Second, wood-bodied planes are a joy to use due to the low friction of a wooden sole. When I started using infill planes I kept applying wax to the sole to try to overcome the greater friction of the steel sole. Now I apply wax some of the time and just live with the increased friction most of the time.

My Ulmia Reform smoother (double iron, lignum vitae sole) is a good plane but the blade is too near the center of the sole for my taste. I don't want my smoother to act like a jointer plane and just take off the high spots. Also, the throat of the plane is fairly narrow due to the mechanism to adjust the mouth. Shavings don't jam when the plane is well tuned, but they don't fall out of there easily either. Sometimes I resort to using compressed air to clear out shavings caught at the sides where there's a small gap between the blade and the side of the plane. These aren't fatal flaws, but still leave me less than completely satisfied with that particular plane. My infill planes are better in those respects.

Then there's ergonomics, the feel of the plane. I like unhandled planes because they put my hand right behind the blade. Krenov-style planes (short ones) have this advantage and Bailey-style planes don't. My low angle bevel-up smoother is especially bad in this regard and skewing the plane puts the force pushing the plane forward out of line with the blade in a way I find unpleasant.

No style of plane will suit every wood or every woodworker. I'm working on my own ultimate plane, a wooden one with a relatively low bed angle, a double iron, and an adjustable mouth. Pretty much a round-sided wooden plane shaped like a Spiers unhandled smoother with a 40 degree bed angle and an adjustable mouth that doesn't make the throat narrow. I'll post pics if I ever get it made.

P.S. I forgot the name and town part. Steve Elliott in Seattle.

Messages In This Thread

Death knell of the single iron plane?
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Oh, the ringing, the incessant bloody ringing
Re: Death knell - not yet
Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Mouth size/position of CB/cutting angle.
Re: Mouth size/position of CB/cutting angle.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: "Shaving thickness regulator"
Re: "Shaving thickness regulator"
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
1802 double iron chisel *PIC*
Re: 1802 double iron chisel
Re: 1802 double iron chisel
Re: 1802 double iron chisel *LINK*
Re: 1802 double iron chisel
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Shaving...
Don McConnell first
Re: Don McConnell first
Absolutely not
Re: Absolutely not
Double iron jack
Re: Double iron jack
Re: Simple
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Lucky for me...
Re: Lucky for me...
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Lucky for me...
Re: Lucky for me...
Re: Lucky for me...
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
The reports of their death are greatly exaggerated
Death knell was a tongue-in-cheek overstatement
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
I get queasy...
From a maker's point of view.
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Oh, goody! We haven't had a good fight
Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?
Well, it was a catchy subject title *LINK*
No death knell in my opinion
Interesting
Re: Interesting
© 1998 - 2012 by Ellis Walentine. All rights reserved.
No parts of this web site may be reproduced in any form or by
any means without the written permission of the publisher.

WOODCENTRAL, P.O. BOX 493, SPRINGTOWN, PA 18081