![]() ![]() WoodCentral "Editors Chat Series" CLARENCE BLANCHARD Managing Editor, The Fine Tool Journal June 1, 2004 [EDITED] |
|
| Ellis | Welcome everyone to this evening's special guest chat with Clarence Blanchard, editor of the Fine Tool Journal. And welcome to you, Clarence. Thank you for joining us tonight. |
| Agee | How far from Portland are you Clarence. I work up there fairly often. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | 23 miles or 8 miles from LL bean |
| Mike_G | A question...I have a C.S. inclinometer...how's the best way to restore the markings on the wooden dial? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | very hard to do much with retoring wood rule markings |
| Mike_G | i guess marking new one's would diminish the value of the tool? |
| Ellis | Clarence, could you please tell us about the Fine Tool Journal. What is your magazine about? |
| Stephen | Any Relation to Thomas Blanchard? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | the FTj covers vintage hand tools that is most any tool before 1970-ish. We do history, study that sort of thing. |
| Ellis | I'm also interested in finding good old tools that I can use. Where is the best place to look? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Remarking would effect value negitively |
| Mike_G | thnx |
| Agee | Clarence,I think my wife has talked to you more than me! Thanks for the deals on the LN planes and DT saw.Whenever holidays & birthdays roll around she orders a new tool for me! |
| Ellis | Is there a place that we can find current values for collectible tools online? |
| tcaley | I have had good luck at estate sales finding old tools. You have to get there early though. |
| Stephen | if the remarking can be reversable, that is acceptable? |
| Mike_G | guess I won't mess with it then |
| tcaley | sometimes the prices can be kind of high though..... |
| Ellis | Agee, tell your wife to talk to mine. :-) |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Not a good source for value on or off line. Too much to know. |
| Ellis | So, to be a knowledgeable collector, you need to immerse yourself in the marketplace? |
| Mike_G | i guess it's more a matter of what knowledge you have and some intuition |
| Agee | Simple Ellis,I pick em out & she calls Clarence & orders them! |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Value is more a fuction of what you get. And quality is no longer inexpensive |
| Ellis | I wonder if Ebay is the bottom line. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | Are there one or two best or essential books that provide good foundations or information for valuing old/antique tools? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Oh thanks to all the wives |
| Ellis | Agee, you are a blessed man. Congrats. |
| Agee | That I am Ellis |
| Ellis | :-) |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The best move, if you will, is to look for quality; then value will fall into place once you know the common stuff. |
| Mike_G | Moves might come in handy at the Flea when you and a buddy are racing for the same tool...lol |
| Ellis | What about the old classic Stanley price books. |
| jimc | Clarence, any noticeable trends changes in collecting right now, say away from Stanley towards patented tools or more primitive stuff? |
| Agee | I have had a hard time finding any old planes,chisels etc near Charlotte,NC |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The Anitque Trader price guide we just published is a good source but it deals with only the best. |
| Mike_G | we live in tool hell don't we Agee? |
| Agee | Most of the time when I find a nice old plane it is usually priced out of site! Yeh MikeG,unless you need big industrial production machinery |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Trends today are generally upward in all areas. Patented market is great, Stanley is strong particularly when condition comes into it, and wood is doing better |
| Ellis | Clarence, what about the traffic in infill planes? |
| Ellis | Hi Andy |
| Mike_G | yep...like i saw this weekend...an old wooden jointer with no blade and priced at 90.00 |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Tools were never cheap and old tools are often cheaper than the new. |
| Ellis | With no blade??? |
| Mike_G | nope |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Infills are tough now with the pound where it is. |
| Mike_G | and a hand auger for 75.00 and a small hand clamp for 75.00, also |
| Agee | It seems to me that in any type of collecting,the highest quality and condition items will always be the best bet in the long run from an investment standpoint |
| Ellis | I'd like to grab a couple transitional planes, Clarence. Where would you suggest I look? |
| Mike_G | for sure Agee |
| Clarence_Blanchard | $90 for a jointer is not a high price. It must be someone who does not know what they are doing. Don't make it two big mistakes. |
| DavidB | In Patrick Leach's woodpile, Ellis... he swears he burns them. |
| Ellis | My old favorite plane was my trusty foreplane, with a transitional setup. |
| Ellis | I ought to check that out, David. If he has convincing evidence, I need to know. |
| DavidB | heh |
| Clarence_Blanchard | If you can get to a local tool meet or one of the national meets, that is a great place to buy user tools. Not many looking for them |
| Agee | Clarence, do you see an increase in the "user" hand tool market? It seems like a lot of wwrs are getting into handtools more in recent times. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | I live in New England - is there some kind of "insider list" of antique shops/dealers that have good woodworking stuff in this area? |
| Stephen | transitional planes have a center of gravity problem |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Burning any old tool is not cool. |
| Ellis | I know, Stephen, but I had that ol plane tuned so sweetly. I miss it. |
| Ellis | Gives you nightmares, eh, Clarence? |
| tcaley | I lost a lot of my dad's old handplanes when my first shop burned down. |
| Mike_G | i lost all my tools in a fire...now i have more than i did before |
| Stephen | a well tuned plane of any material is a sweet thing |
| Clarence_Blanchard | For years I have been asked the question where to look. And the only real answer is putting in the miles and burning the gas. At $2 a gallon, mail order is cheaper. |
| Ellis | That's what it comes down to. |
| Ellis | Good advice, Clarence. |
| Ellis | So, are there more collectors or users out there, Clarence? |
| Agee | Clarence,I was in Boston a little while back and had the local TV station on. I usually have the TV on for background noise while working in my hotel at night.....Your name came up and I looked up and there you were! |
| Mike_in_Mystic | hmmm. i guess I was just thinking of something analagous to a wine trail - but for antique tools, see what I'm getting at? I pop into places from time to time, but it's usually full of furniture and flour tins - not tools |
| Mike_G | i hope to be able to afford dealer's prices one of these days, but now for me, Ebay's the way to go |
| MournSword | You guys need to be in Ohio, tools (and about everything) are pretty cheap in general. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Yes, I see more users coming into the old tool world. Actully users and collectors are growing more apart. |
| MournSword | Especially the last few auctions I went to. |
| Agee | I check the antique stores in NC from time to time but the prices are always way to high. |
| Mike_G | i missed an auction this weekend because of work |
| AndyL | Ellis, as I don't know the (Stanley??) transitioanl #'s any ideas of which you are looking for? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The collectors can not find the tools users want so that market has dried up some. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | i've done alright on Ebay - but it is a very frenetic experience. I think the process of going and picking up the tool and haggling would be more satisfying :) |
| Mike_G | a friend told me the tools went dirt cheap |
| tcaley | Antique stores in Arkansas are the same way. Too high priced and usually all rusty... |
| Mike_G | and this guy had a garage full |
| Ellis | Some days you eat the bear, Mike_G. :-) |
| Mike_in_Mystic | rust = character, right??:-) |
| Mike_G | yep |
| Mike_G | lol |
| MournSword | For example, I just bought a 12" wood lathe, all parts there, with a 1.5 HP motor and an on/off switch, fully functional even with a belt, total cost $85.00 |
| Mike_G | it's not rust...it's "patina" |
| Agee | There are a couple of guys on another website that buy planes, recondition them as users, and sell them for a pretty fair price. |
| Ellis | I think that if you are knowledgeable, you can find and make the best deals. |
| tcaley | sometimes, but then sometimes they are just too far gone...... Mike_in_Mystic |
| DavidB | A lot of it's regional. When I lived in Northampton/Amherst, MA... mention you like old tools to your neighbor, and he'd likely as not bring you a box of stuff. Florida? I don't bother. |
| Ellis | Clarence also runs Brown's auction in Harrisburg every fall. What about that, Clarence? |
| tcaley | There here in Arkansas, but you really have to work for them. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | I have a sister near there.......road trip |
| Stephen | I have a nice old plane I would like to sell Clarence |
| DavidB | Of course, both of those towns had planemakers; Kellog, etc. |
| Mike_G | i did luck up a couple of years ago...found 2 large tool chests full of patternmakers and woodworking tools at one yard sale...paid 500.00 for both of them |
| Agee | Clarence, is there a market for old mechanics tools? wrenches etc? |
| Ellis | I have always wanted to have the time and the budget to collect tools. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | You may not want to think old tools and cheap at the same time. A good tool is worth a few bucks and cheap tool may always be cheap. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | how much time and $$ did it take for you to get started, Clarence? or was it a gradual process? (do you do this full time?) |
| Ellis | That makes sense. Quality always costs more |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Wrenches have a following, but for every good wrench a hundred $2 ones exist. |
| Jhnp | are small towns good places to look for old tools? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The first thing is to spend about 10 years learning tools inside out. It takes a lot of time to understand and know all the different areas. |
| tcaley | What about tools still in original sealed packaging. Are they a good value? |
| Stephen | W.W.Richie - Louisville Kentucky coffin smoother |
| Mike_G | rulers seem to be a hot item these days |
| Mike_G | especially the combo rulers |
| Agee | Clarence,what are the "holy grails" in ww tools that you would like to personally like to own? |
| Jhnp | why do you want to sell it, Stephen? |
| Stephen | it is apparently rare |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Tools in the box can be worth double or triple the unboxed price. Hardware store new is the condition you want if you collect |
| Mike_G | like that SW 45 someone found in the company safe last year? |
| tcaley | I recently found five Yankee 43 drills still in sealed condition. |
| tcaley | I know that they arent very old, but there not made anymore either. |
| Crackerjack | What exactly is the Fine Tools journal? I'm not familiar with it. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The 45 is a user tool so the value is more or less fixed. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | http://www.finetoolj.com/ |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Thanks. That answers the question faster than my typing. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | The "Fine Tool Journal" is the single most comprehensive resource on hand tools available in the world! Share the fascination of learning about hand tools - their history, their use, their beauty, their value. Whether you collect hand tools, use them, or just study their history, let "Fine Tool Journal" help expand your enjoyment horizon. Power tools have their place, but hand tools keep you in touch with the sense of the wood, and the tradition and history of the craft. Our sole purpose is to spread knowledge of hand tools of all trades and crafts, with the primary focus on woodworking. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | there :) hehe |
| Ellis | Yow, Mike. Nice post! Thanks. |
| Ellis | Fine Tool Journal is like the heartbeat of the collector market |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Rules have moved in value but condition is everything. A worn rule might measure up but not more. |
| tcaley | did you type that or cut and paste? |
| Crackerjack | Cool,thanks I think I got it |
| Ellis | Inquiring minds want to know. |
| Agee | What are the best museums on the East Coast to see the history of fine tools? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | But more than 40% of the readers are users. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | what do you think??? hehe (me be quick with a mouse)_ |
| Stephen | Mercer Museum in PA |
| Ellis | That is a nice balance, Clarence. |
| Mike_G | kind of like tool porn |
| Stephen | Winterthur, the Dominey Collection |
| Agee | Where in PA Stephen? |
| DavidB | Right, Mike. My copies over the years induced more hot flashes and drool than a stack of Playboys. |
| Stephen | Doylestown? |
| Ellis | Twenty miles south of me. |
| Agee | Winterthur is in Delaware isn't it? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Most US museums have a few tools but not a good showing. Not real tool places. |
| Jhnp | yes, Agee |
| Mike_G | mine too DavidB |
| Ellis | Are there any museums that have a good selection, well catalogued? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | I think we have a new aproach to sell the FTJ |
| Stephen | Yes near Wilmington in the Brandywine Valley |
| tcaley | kind of like a Holtley or Anderson plane? Talk about tool porn. |
| Agee | I agree Clarence.I travel the E Coast every week and have been in some fine museums and seen lots of great furniture but the tools usually are a side exhibit if at all. |
| Mike_G | how's that clarence? |
| Mike_G | the Charleston Museum has a nice display of tools |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Tool Porn sound like beginning of a great pitch. |
| Stephen | The Smithsonian has some good tools |
| Ellis | So, the best shot you can find would be at the Brown Auction? |
| Stephen | Sturbridge Village, Williamsburg |
| Mike_G | feel tree to use it |
| Agee | I love tool porn.The last LN flyer with the whole collection was great. I'd buy that in poster form if it was available! |
| Ellis | Right, but does anyone really catalogue them from the user's point of view? |
| Ellis | Tom just sent me that poster, Agee. If I'm thinking of the same thing... |
| Stephen | Plymouth Plantation |
| DavidB | Yeah, but Clarence is right... what's missing is the large systematic comparative collections well-cataloged and curated. |
| Mike_in_Mystic | I have to get going - thanks for taking the time Clarence! :-) |
| tcaley | I've been trying to find the Studley tool poster but can't find one. One sold recently on the bay for 125.00. |
| Mike_G | see ya mike |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Sturbridge and Williamsburg both have tools but more as living displays than real tool set ups. It was not long ago that Williamsburg had Stnaley wood bottoms in 18th c settings. |
| Stephen | Now they have Clark & Williams |
| AndyL | STOP teasing Ellis!! |
| Mike_G | was that before or after Roy Underhill? |
| Stephen | lol Mike |
| Ellis | uh, can't help myself... :-) |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Roy has been around since money was silver and the #1 was $250 |
| Mike_G | dang...that's a long time...lol |
| Agee | I was at Williamsburg recently.It was a lot of fun. I saw mostly C&W planes. I also asked them about the Clifton shoulder plane laying on the bench. Must have been a very EARLY one hehe... |
| Ellis | He has definitely been a strong influence. |
| Stephen | lol |
| Ellis | ar ar |
| Stephen | at least they make an effort |
| Ellis | Clarence, do you see values going down or up in the future? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Have not been to Williamsburg for a while. Sorry to hear they have gone backwards. |
| Stephen | there are more involved programs in different parts of the country |
| AndyL | Is anybody here planning to go to Akron in June? It's only a 3hr drive from here |
| Crackerjack | Sturbridge that you mention,is that Sturbridge ,Mass.? |
| Mike_G | my wife's been watching some show on PBS where some people live like they did back in the early 1700's...using the same tools |
| Ellis | Is that the MWTCA meet? |
| AndyL | Yep, Ellis |
| Stephen | yes cj |
| Agee | One of the most interesting things at Williamsburg was the 8 ft deep pit designed for sawing logs into rough lumber... |
| Ellis | I would go if it were that close. |
| Mike_G | how far from greenville?...5 hours? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Tool values have been strong despite the market. Right now is the time to buy. Things are getting hard to find and prices are moving upward. |
| Crackerjack | I was there last summer. They are understaffed |
| Agee | Colonial House...was fun to watch ,but a few of the characters were really annoying! |
| AndyL | I'll probably run out of money and dehydrate in the parking lot... |
| Ellis | You need to have to be like a pit bull to pit saw, Agee. I wouldn't last an hour. |
| Agee | me neither Ellis. I would have hated to be the one in the pit! |
| Mike_G | just need to work yourself into it Ellis...lol |
| Stephen | the tillerman had the worst job |
| Ellis | That only stands to reason, Clarence. Do you see any particular trends in demand? Chisels? Planes? |
| Stephen | the pit man just needed to keep his head down and his mouth shut |
| Mike_G | he's the one who got the face full of dust |
| Mike_G | oh...the tillerman's on top? |
| Ellis | My wife used to say that to me, Stephen. :-) (Just kidding - hope she doesn't read this.) |
| DavidB | Clarence, apart from woodworking, are tools from other early crafts getting more interest lately? Such as cordwaining, silversmithing, and so on? |
| Stephen | yes, he had to lift the saw up and keep it straight |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Not really by item. Planes are king and the other stuff fills in around them. An article about an item gives a sort boost in interest |
| Ellis | Yes, and does the FTJ deal in other kinds of old tools? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Yes we cover all tools. The other trades do not have the following that wood has. Interest comes and goes; leather is most likely the second best. |
| Ellis | What is the circulation of the Fine Tool Journal? |
| Mike_G | circulation might go up after tonight |
| Ellis | Maybe another question is how many people are into tool collecting versus tool using? |
| Stephen | do you pay for articles? |
| Agee | I recently went to a great used bookstore in Boston with an outdoor alley full of used bargains.Got a great book on colonial crafts for $3.It seems that furniture making was big but silversmithing was the road to fortune. Are any of their tools collectible and still around? |
| Ellis | Yeah, especially if they lead to fortune. :-/ |
| Stephen | or is it a house organ? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Never meet a user that was not a collector. Got to have one more tool just in case that special job comes along. |
| Mike_G | lol...yep clarence |
| Ellis | Gotcha. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | We have about 3000 readers. And have had record mailing the last 3 issues. |
| Mike_G | nice clarence |
| Agee | With three kids,I tend to be more of a user and a wannabe collector! |
| Ellis | It's a nice magazine. |
| DavidB | Hahaha... I'll never admit to collecting. Not even if you use a minty "Tom Thumb Factfinder" screw on me. |
| Mike_G | me either...then i wouldn't be able to justify new tool purchases |
| Ellis | Using and collecting have always seemed separate to me. |
| Agee | I'm still using the "honey I need a new tool if you want that done" excuse.It has pretty much worn itself out though. |
| Mike_G | yep |
| Mike_G | i might have an in...wife's become interested in using some of my tools |
| Clarence_Blanchard | All a wood worker needs a pile of wood and a jack knife. More than that makes you a collector. |
| tcaley | I've gone from 0 to about 20 handplanes in the last two years. No problem here.... |
| Mike_G | i can always...buy yer own...lol |
| Ellis | What is the best way to find out what a tool is worth, Clarence? |
| Agee | Me too Ellis.I used to "collect" vintage guitars.I pretty much "use" ww tools these days.(and it's much cheaper than collecting guitars!) |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The best way is send me a photo. Must tools are of low value and getting beyond them is the trick. Need to know the bottom end first. |
| Agee | How about luthier tools Clarence? |
| Ellis | Clarence, what about joining a tool club? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | All instrument maker's tools are great. The planes are best. You don't see many as only a few were in the trades. |
| Mike_G | like MWTCA? |
| Ellis | It's nice having Bill Phillips a half hour away. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Mid West Tool Collector meets are great and you will see more tools in 3 days than in a 100 shops. |
| Mike_G | too bad they're so far away |
| Ellis | When will the Brown Auction be this year, Clarence? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Bill is a great source. And he is recovering nicely from the operation. |
| Ellis | His collection is amazing. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Brown is Oct 23 |
| Ellis | Hey, I may actually be able to make it this year. |
| Stephen | Ever seen the Ray Wilson Collection in Indianapolis? |
| Mike_G | i'd like to, but probably only to drool...lol |
| Clarence_Blanchard | We have a great line up and some tools you will not see again for a long time. Also the show the day before is a nice source for user stuff |
| Ellis | Clarence, you might want to stop by our Hand Tool board now and then. There are some wonderful discussions about tools. |
| Ellis | So, Thursday is the best day for users? |
| Mike_G | and some knowledgable people, too |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Hey, I do that. This is my first short at a chat room as you can see. |
| Ellis | You are doing just fine, Clarence. |
| Ellis | Personally, I like a conservative pace.... whatever suits everyone best |
| Ellis | Hello, Jim |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | Fell asleep in the chair or I'd of seen you all earlier |
| Clarence_Blanchard | One thing we have add to the FTJ is new tool reviews by Chris Schwarz. He is doing a great job and LN chisels are next. |
| Mike_G | Clarence, someone asked if FTJ solicits articles...or is it an in house thing/ |
| Agee | I saw Chris's post today that he was writing for you. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | We purchase about 50% of the articles we print. Always looking so give me a call. |
| Stephen | a number? |
| Mike_G | thanks Clarence |
| Ellis | Clarence, loaded question: Do you think L-N planes are superior to their Stanley and Bailey counterparts? |
| DavidB | Ha, speaking of calls, I just remembered Clarence once returned a call several years ago and my friend took the call and introduced him as Clarence Thomas. Now that I've seen the photo Ellis posted, I have to say you don't really look much like him. |
| Ellis | Whew. Close call. :-) |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | I have a old brass and ebony or teak marking gauge maked JW PEST__LL any idea if that is someone's name or a maker's mark? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | I remember that. And we both could not be GGTOW. |
| DavidB | Yeah... I'll never let him live it down, haha. |
| Agee | I have an idea for an article,not centered around collecting,but the love of a fine tool. I used to work in motorsports and we had all of the latest tools.....but there was this one old no name wrench that fit my hand perfectly that I always went to.The crew used to laugh at me about my old wrench.I'd like to hear stories of that one tool that people always "went to" |
| Clarence_Blanchard | A lot of people are looking for parts. Most of the parts have to come from other old tools. A few have turned up at hardware stores and the like but most come off broken or "junk" tools. That tends to make getting parts expensive and quite hard. It is best to buy things complete. The only parts we deal in regularly are bench plane blades and those for the 45. We did purchase a large lot of original 45 parts from the Canadian factor years ago and have been selling them. |
| Ellis | You're beyond salvation, Agee. |
| Mike_G | just like an old shirt |
| Clarence_Blanchard | One tool makes an article. |
| Stephen | Do you have a number at which we can call you Mr. Blanchard? |
| Mike_G | i need several cutters for my type 7 45 |
| Clarence_Blanchard | 800-248-8114 |
| Stephen | Thank You |
| Agee | Come on Ellis,I bet everyone here has a favorite tool that they love to use, be it a collector, new,or just an old dog. I'd like to hear about them! |
| Clarence_Blanchard | We most likely have the cutters you need in new old stock. Give us a call or email and we will send you the list. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | I must say I do not do much WW now but I did like the Stanley 140 skew block plane. |
| Ellis | Yeah, that's what I would like, too, Agee. The mystery and mystique are big dimensions for me. |
| tcaley | I keep going back to my SW era number 4 plane. |
| Ellis | How do the LN tools compare to the antiques? |
| Agee | Sometimes your favorite tool dictates how you ww, even if ther might be a better or faster power tool way,right? |
| Crackerjack | faster but never better |
| Ellis | That's a tough call, Agee. The reason to use a planer is because you don't want to waste the muscle power to plane it with your #7 or #8 |
| Clarence_Blanchard | LN makes some great tools and comparing the two is a yes and no answer. The bench planes by LN are better: thicker irons, heavier cutters, true and flat. The other planes are much closer to equal, and price becomes more of a factor. An original 164 is worth $4000 while an original scrub plane is about 2/3 of the LN. The edge trimming planes are about equal in price and user quality. The 140 skew block is cheaper in an original but no fence, but on the other hand I have never had call to use the fence. So, pick and choose is the real answer. |
| Mike_G | thnx again Clarence |
| Agee | I can't speak for all the LN planes, but my LN 62 (with several blades ground at different cutting angles) is an ABSOLUTE JOY to use. My wife bought it from Clarence for me. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Thanks Mike |
| Mike_G | grand daughter just brought a mud turtle home,,,had to fix a terrarium for it |
| Ellis | Sounds like you're sold, Agee :-) |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Yes and at a good price I might add! |
| Ellis | You might add.......:-) |
| Ellis | So do you collect yourself, Clarence? |
| Agee | Speaking of price Clarence....yours are the best I have found on LNs if every one here didn't know already. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Stanley by the numbers. A user that escaped. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | And with free US shipping. |
| Ellis | Put me on the plane of the month club list. |
| Mike_G | speaking of users...i think i missed my auction...lol |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | We Canadians always get exlucted on the free shipping |
| Clarence_Blanchard | No, it is this weekend. The FTJ absentee auction ends Sunday night at about 2am. |
| Ellis | I am debating whether to buy old Bedrocks or new LN planes. Sounds lilke you prefer the LN bench planes. But Bedrock user planes are less than half the price. What do you say? Can an old Bedrock be made to work like a Swiss watch? |
| Agee | Clarence,I was dead set on getting a LN 4 1/2 next, but the 62 with different irons ground at 45,50,& 55 have made me think again.I just can't imagine much better performance! |
| Ellis | There oughta be a law, Jim. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Bed Rocks are great planes, but at the same price, the LN will outdo them, so I leave the choice of which to buy to you. |
| Mike_G | something i saw at an online auction |
| Stephen | some old British wooden clocks work as good as the metal Swiss movements |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | I am glad to hear you think LN are better |
| Ellis | I can get Bedrocks for less. Should I be investing in them? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | The 62 is great but every plane is just a bit better for a certain task so... |
| Mike_G | thast's why there's so many of them...:) |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | Ellis I have replaced the irons in all my bedrocks made a 1/8 inch thick blade for the 608 filing the throat out and have come to the conclusion that the LN are still better |
| Ellis | And, to change the subject somewhat, if you are amenable, ... what are the old chisel brands to look for at flea markets? |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Bed Rocks are strong but most of the power is from users and that can shift. Investment may not be as solid in BR as some other areas. But they are still great user planes. |
| Mike_G | gotta be Charles buck, S.J. Addis and butcher's |
| Agee | FWIW, I travel 3-5 days a week.I would love to have time to recondition old Stanleys and fettle them into great working order.But reality is that I get a little time each week in the shop.My LNs have saved time for me by being almost perfect out of the box.I then spend time woodworking! |
| gtools | Greenlee..............always good metal...... |
| Stephen | Spears & Jackson |
| Stephen | Swan |
| DavidB | I've gotta go, but I did want to mention that even though I don't collect, FTJ has been a great reference and inspiration for the handtools I've made over the years. I gotta re-up my subscription. Thanks Clarence, Ellis. Night, all. |
| Stephen | Peter Stubbs |
| Ellis | See you David |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Most old chisels were made by a few makers and many are great. Problem is more what has been done to the temper over the years. |
| Ellis | Clarence, I'd like to thank you for being here with us tonight |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Was fun. And great to be here. Thanks |
| Jim_in_Burlington_Ontario | Thank you |
| Ellis | It has been our pleasure to have you with us in the guest chat seat. We'll archive this chat so future visitors can find out about you and your fine magazine. |
| Agee | Yes, thanks so much Clarence! My wife will be calling you with my next order..... |
| Crackerjack | I enjoyed this. I'll be checking out your magazine. |
| tcaley | Thanks Clarence and Ellis. |
| Ellis | Folks, thank you all for joining us tonight. |
| Clarence_Blanchard | Thanks all and good night. |
| Crackerjack | Thank you Ellis |
| Ellis | Best to you all. You are most welcome |